This blog presents Metropolitan Engineering Consulting & Forensics (MEC&F) claim management and claim investigation analyses of some of the typical claims we handle
Wednesday, June 1, 2016
Trying to put the brakes on road rage
A motorcyclist and the driver of a red sedan engage in a protracted example of road rage at high speeds in Homestead, Fla.
Take a deep breath before you head out on that holiday
drive -- all the better to help keep your cool if you have an unwelcome
brush with ROAD RAGE. Our Cover Story is reported by Kris Van Cleave: Punches
thrown in the middle of a Houston intersection ... grown men and a
woman brawling in front of stunned onlookers ... then one of the drivers
purposely ramming his truck into the other car before speeding off. Road
rage, it seems, is everywhere (and caught on video) as drivers use
bats, fists, guns, even golf balls in street showdowns that can
sometimes have tragic consequences. "I would hope he wasn't doing
it with the intention of killing someone, or paralyzing someone, but
that's what ended up happening," said Stevie Vanausdale. For Vanausdale, road rage wasn't a video that went viral; it was a life sentence. "I
want people to learn from what we did," she said. "Because we were good
kids. We were honors students. We were varsity athletes. We were good
kids with bright futures."
CBS News
Futures that forever changed one June night in 2006. Then-17-year-old
Stevie and four high school friends went for a drive, and one of the
boys in the backseat threw a water bottle at another vehicle. It was a
mindless teenage prank, but in response car ended up chasing the teens at 90 mph down a country road. The driver of the car Stevie was in lost control and hit a tree (left). Stevie's best friend, who was sitting next to her, died. Stevie was paralyzed from the waist down. Both drivers went to jail. "I
think people don't realize that the moment that could change their life
is something so miniscule," Vanausdale said. "And I would say it's
really hard to realize that that one water bottle changed five families,
five individuals, forever." A survey by AAA found nearly half of drivers believe aggressive driving is a very serious threat to their personal safety. Fatal
road rage incidents are up more than 30 percent since 2010, and were
the cause of more than 1,700 deaths between 2010 and 2014. But anger behind the wheel is not a new phenomenon; it's played out in popular culture for decades. In the 1950 Disney cartoon "Motor Mania," a mild-mannered Goofy turns Jekyll-and-Hyde when he gets behind the wheel. But the very real violence of road rage is no laughing matter. Mike
McCloskey, an expert on aggression and a professor of psychology at
Temple University in Philadelphia, says one of the aspects about driving
that makes some people so angry is that it is stressful: "The days of
taking a leisurely drive have kind of gone. Now when you're driving,
you're really trying to get from A to B, and you usually haven't given
yourself enough time to do that. So just the trip itself is very, very
stressful." "Is there something about being in the car, though,
that makes people feel more comfortable to express that anger?" asked
Van Cleave. "You don't see people screaming at each other in the grocery
store because somebody's in the express lane with one extra item. In
the car, you see people lose their minds." "Yeah. The car kind of
affords us a certain level of safety and anonymity. Even though we may
be on the road with a whole bunch of other people, we kind of feel like
we're in our own little cocoon in our car." This weekend 33.9
million Americans are expected to hit the roads, and McCloskey says
millions of them will be driving angry: "The statistics suggest about
one in three people engage in some form of road rage." "That's a lot of road rage." "Mind
you that the majority of that is relatively minor," said McCloskey.
"It's the honking your horn real loud, flipping someone off, screaming.
But for a small portion, like a couple percent, they engage in much more
violent, destructive behaviors -- trying to run people off the road,
trying to attack people." That's the kind of rage Evan Wilder ran
into in 2014 when he was cycling home in Washington, D.C. Evan was
riding, legally, on a shared roadway when a pickup cut him off, sending
him crashing into its bumper. That's when the driver became irate. "It was like this wall of anger from this guy, coming at me," Wilder recalled. Three years earlier, he was almost killed when a truck sideswiped him. "That happened so fast," Wilder said. "By the time it happened, you don't even know what's going on, what had just happened." "Is this hard to watch?" Van Cleave asked. "Yes. This is hard to watch," he mused. "His intention was to strike me with his truck." When
Mike Shen moved from New York to Los Angeles, he was shocked by some of
the rage he encountered on the crowded roads -- including his own. "When
I came out here, I was literally rolling down the window -- I was like,
'Do you walk the way you drive?'" he told Van Cleave. "I'm like, 'Stay
on the right.' And you can't do that, 'cause here the ego is so attached
to people's vehicle, and people start really shouting back, people
pulling cars in front of me. I was like, OK, someone's going to get
hurt." The father of three decided it was time to put his own anger in park. So he started a blog instead called L.A. Can't Drive. He calls it a "platform for cathartic release." Van Cleave asked, "Do you really think L.A. can't drive?"
A driver (and her cat) behind the wheel in Los Angeles.
L.A. Can't Drive
"Yes,
hands down. They absolutely cannot drive," Shen replied. "I've seen
people -- actors constantly driving with their knee, reading scripts. I
have a picture I could show you of a woman holding a cat on the freeway.
She was going, like, 20 miles per hour slower than everyone else in the
left lane." The site is home to video and pictures of Southern
California drivers behaving badly: swerving through traffic, blowing red
lights, or using the shoulder as a passing lane -- the kind of behavior
that often provokes road rage. There is, Shen said, a lot of anger and frustration on the roads. "And it's understandable. I'm not immune to it, I feel it." Van Cleave asked McCloskey, "How do we decrease the risk of road rage?" "Before
you even get in the car, give yourself time," he replied. "Don't cut
everything to last-minute. One of the biggest things that exacerbates
road rage is someone being stressed out, and time-urgency. When you're
in the car and someone does something and they cut you off, they're
driving too slow, they're tailgating, whatever it is, one of the
simplest things to do -- and it sounds trite, but it's helpful -- just
take a deep breath. "If nothing else, it buys you some time. Puts
things in perspective. This is not a major thing -- unless you do
something to make it a major thing." Of her experience, Stevie
Vanausdale said, "I don't remember exactly what our intentions were that
night, but I do know that we did NOT think through the consequences." Vanausdale now works with a group called ROARR (Reaching Out Against Road Rage). She hopes by telling her story to high school students, her tragedy can be their life-saving cautionary tale. "Just
stop for one moment before you engage in that, and think," she said.
"Because I think if any of us had done that that night, maybe Charlie
would still be here and maybe I would still be walking. That's one thing
that I really wish I would have done."