SaskPower
CEO resigns following investigation into smart meter “catastrophe”. SMART METER
FIRES HAVE ALSO BEEN REPORTED IN THE US AND FORCED UTILITIES TO REPLACE HUNDREDS
OF THOUSANDS OF METERS.
SaskPower
CEO Robert Watson has resigned — without severance — after an investigation
into “smart” meter fires throughout Saskatchewan.
As
reported in late July, following a series of fires throughout Saskatchewan,
Canada, “SaskPower ordered to remove all 105,000 smart meters in the
province.”
On
October 27th, the Government of Saskatchewan released the results of a scathing review on the smart
meter “debacle”
which is now commonly being referred to as a “catastrophe.” The report concluded that
“customer safety was not given
enough priority.”
SaskPower
CEO Robert Watson resigned his position
immediately following the release of the report on the smart meter program.
Findings
from the investigation
According
to the government’s review:
“The
primary issue of catastrophic
meter failures which prompted the AMI program to be halted was not identified as an initial
program risk. When additional information about smart meter fires from
other sources came to light, the risk of catastrophic
meter failures did not prompt
an independent reevaluation of the risk related to Sensus smart meters.”
Additional
key findings:
Moisture
and contaminants getting inside the meters were a major factor in the meter
fires.
There
is no evidence
to indicate the fires were the result of improper installation or hot sockets.
SaskPower
did not adequately consider the potential for significant meter failures
resulting in damage to homes.
VIDEO:
SaskPower CEO Robert Watson resigns amidst smart meter “catastrophe”
Jack
Ritenburg, an electrical engineer and head of Ritenburg & Associates
concluded that moisture and contaminants inside the meters was the cause of the
smart meter fires. He also concluded that “water intrusion due to holes
in meter boxes, ‘hot socket’ conditions in the meter box and over voltage in
the distribution system” or other “external factors” were not the cause of the fires as
previously claimed by the
manufacturer:
Jack
Ritenburg, an electrical engineer and head of Ritengurb and Associates, reports
on the suspected causes behind the SaskPower smart meter fires.
According
to the independent fire investigation report:
“There
was significant precipitation in the previous thirty days for all of the fires.
There was significant precipitation in five of the fires within the preceding
two days. The remaining three fires had light precipitation within the
preceding two days. There is evidence that moisture and contaminants have
been getting into the meters and possibly being trapped.”
“Hot
socket issues have been flagged as a possible reason for some of the meter
failures. … [W]e feel that a hot socket condition resulting in a destructive
meter failure and fire are not
likely.”
“Sensus
has claimed that some of the smart meter fires were caused by utility
over-voltage. … We have not
found any evidence to support that a significant over-voltage occurred and
resulted in a destructive meter failure.”
The
photo below shows electrical arcing inside a smart meter that was taken out of
service under the category “Display Error.” This failure is in the same
location as smart meters which suffered a catastrophic failure.
The
following photo (below) shows a meter that was taken out of service
by SaskPower that has staining from smoke and evidence of moisture at the
bottom of the meter. This meter had not yet suffered a catastrophic
failure.
The
fire investigation report concluded with the following statements:
“In view of the above, we are of the opinion
that moisture and contaminants within the meter has been a major factor in the
meter failures and ensuing fires.”
“As there is some danger with destructive meter
failures and potential resulting fires, we recommend that the existing Sensus
Generation 3.3 meters be replaced as soon as possible. As
the existing meter fires have had a close relationship to precipitation levels,
SaskPower might wish to consider replacement no later than the end of winter
and before the spring thaw and spring rains begin.”
Just
to be clear, the fire investigation report reveals that the principal problem
is primarily rain
water (and/or condensation along with other contaminants)
that gets into the smart meters themselves, causing arcing across
electronic components with eventual catastrophic failure of the meter with a
possible explosion or fire. Furthermore, based upon a review of the investigative
report, it is clear we basically have “cheap” meters with a number of
design deficiencies which includes uninsulated busbars in close proximity
to printed circuit boards and which further allow easy entry of water and dust
into the meter enclosures.
Bottom
line, … the existing smart meters on people’s homes still present a fire risk
in Saskatchewan and elsewhere. In
addition, these types of problems would not occur with traditional analog
meters that do not contain fragile electronic components.
Smart
meters a catastrophe
As
a supplement, this website will quote a portion of an October 28, 2014,
article in the Leader-Post entitled SaskPower
smart meters a ‘catastrophe’:
“Lest
there still be any doubt how badly bungled the SaskPower smart meter debacle
was, consider how frequently lawyers, technical specialists and others used the
word ‘catastrophic’
in their joint review released Monday.
‘The
primary issue of catastrophic meter
failures which prompted the AMI (Advanced Meter Infrastructure) program to be
halted was not identified as an initial program risk,’ stated the $500,000
Crown Investments Corp. (CIC) report entitled Smart Meter Review.
‘When
additional information about smart meter fires from other sources came to
light, the risk of catastrophic meter
failures did not prompt an independent re-evaluation of the risk related to
Sensus smart meters.
An
escalation of the risk assessment could have prompted additional investigation,
testing and either closer monitoring of installed meters or a pause to the
rollout of smart meters until issues were better understood.’
‘Catastrophic’ in Monday’s
report refers to not just the eight fires started by the smart meters, but
occasions when things like smoking in the smart meters – largely due to
moisture or debris getting inside what should have been a sealed casing – might
have easily led to fires. In all, there were some 359 incidents of meter
failure, although the majority were for things like improper readings.
Yet
according to the review – [comprised] of three separate reports by
Ritenburg and Associates looking into technical issues, Robertson
Stromberg commissioned to look at legal matters, and PwC asked to review
procurement and contract management – little or no thought was ever given to
the inherent risk of catastrophic
events.”













