MEC&F Expert Engineers

Thursday, November 13, 2014

SASKPOWER CEO RESIGNS FOLLOWING INVESTIGATION INTO SMART METER “CATASTROPHE”. SMART METER FIRES HAVE ALSO BEEN REPORTED IN THE US AND FORCED UTILITIES TO REPLACE HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF METERS.

SaskPower CEO resigns following investigation into smart meter “catastrophe”.  SMART METER FIRES HAVE ALSO BEEN REPORTED IN THE US AND FORCED UTILITIES TO REPLACE HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF METERS.




SaskPower CEO Robert Watson has resigned — without severance — after an investigation into “smart” meter fires throughout Saskatchewan.
As reported in late July, following a series of fires throughout Saskatchewan, Canada, “SaskPower ordered to remove all 105,000 smart meters in the province.”

On October 27th, the Government of Saskatchewan released the results of a scathing review on the smart meter “debacle” which is now commonly being referred to as a “catastrophe.”  The  report concluded that “customer safety was not given enough priority.”

SaskPower CEO Robert Watson resigned his position immediately following the release of the report on the smart meter program.

Findings from the investigation
According to the government’s review:

“The primary issue of catastrophic meter failures which prompted the AMI program to be halted was not identified as an initial program risk.  When additional information about smart meter fires from other sources came to light, the risk of catastrophic meter failures did not prompt an independent reevaluation of the risk related to Sensus smart meters.”

Additional key findings:

Moisture and contaminants getting inside the meters were a major factor in the meter fires.

There is no evidence to indicate the fires were the result of improper installation or hot sockets.

SaskPower did not adequately consider the potential for significant meter failures resulting in damage to homes.

VIDEO: SaskPower CEO Robert Watson resigns amidst smart meter “catastrophe”
Jack Ritenburg, an electrical engineer and head of Ritenburg & Associates concluded that moisture and contaminants inside the meters was the cause of the smart meter fires.  He also concluded that “water intrusion due to holes in meter boxes, ‘hot socket’ conditions in the meter box and over voltage in the distribution system” or other “external factors” were not the cause of the fires as previously claimed by the manufacturer:

Jack Ritenburg, an electrical engineer and head of Ritengurb and Associates, reports on the suspected causes behind the SaskPower smart meter fires.
According to the independent fire investigation report:

“There was significant precipitation in the previous thirty days for all of the fires. There was significant precipitation in five of the fires within the preceding two days. The remaining three fires had light precipitation within the preceding two days.  There is evidence that moisture and contaminants have been getting into the meters and possibly being trapped.”

“Hot socket issues have been flagged as a possible reason for some of the meter failures. … [W]e feel that a hot socket condition resulting in a destructive meter failure and fire are not likely.”

“Sensus has claimed that some of the smart meter fires were caused by utility over-voltage. … We have not found any evidence to support that a significant over-voltage occurred and resulted in a destructive meter failure.”

The photo below shows electrical arcing inside a smart meter that was taken out of service under the category “Display Error.”  This failure is in the same location as smart meters which suffered a catastrophic failure.



The following photo (below) shows a meter that was taken out of service by SaskPower that has staining from smoke and evidence of moisture at the bottom of the meter.  This meter had not yet suffered a catastrophic failure.




The fire investigation report concluded with the following statements:

“In view of the above, we are of the opinion that moisture and contaminants within the meter has been a major factor in the meter failures and ensuing fires.”

“As there is some danger with destructive meter failures and potential resulting fires, we recommend that the existing Sensus Generation 3.3 meters be replaced as soon as possible.  As the existing meter fires have had a close relationship to precipitation levels, SaskPower might wish to consider replacement no later than the end of winter and before the spring thaw and spring rains begin.”

Just to be clear, the fire investigation report reveals that the principal problem is  primarily rain water  (and/or condensation along with other contaminants) that gets into the smart meters themselves, causing arcing across electronic components with eventual catastrophic failure of the meter with a possible explosion or fire.  Furthermore, based upon a review of the investigative report, it is clear we basically have “cheap” meters with a number of design deficiencies which includes uninsulated busbars in close proximity to printed circuit boards and which further allow easy entry of water and dust into the meter enclosures.
Bottom line, … the existing smart meters on people’s homes still present a fire risk in Saskatchewan and elsewhere.  In addition, these types of problems would not occur with traditional analog meters that do not contain fragile electronic components.

Smart meters a catastrophe

As a supplement, this website will quote a portion of an October 28, 2014, article in the Leader-Post entitled SaskPower smart meters a ‘catastrophe’:
“Lest there still be any doubt how badly bungled the SaskPower smart meter debacle was, consider how frequently lawyers, technical specialists and others used the word ‘catastrophic’ in their joint review released Monday.

‘The primary issue of catastrophic meter failures which prompted the AMI (Advanced Meter Infrastructure) program to be halted was not identified as an initial program risk,’ stated the $500,000 Crown Investments Corp. (CIC) report entitled Smart Meter Review.

‘When additional information about smart meter fires from other sources came to light, the risk of catastrophic meter failures did not prompt an independent re-evaluation of the risk related to Sensus smart meters.

An escalation of the risk assessment could have prompted additional investigation, testing and either closer monitoring of installed meters or a pause to the rollout of smart meters until issues were better understood.’

‘Catastrophic’ in Monday’s report refers to not just the eight fires started by the smart meters, but occasions when things like smoking in the smart meters – largely due to moisture or debris getting inside what should have been a sealed casing – might have easily led to fires.  In all, there were some 359 incidents of meter failure, although the majority were for things like improper readings.
Yet according to the review – [comprised] of three separate reports by Ritenburg and Associates looking into technical issues, Robertson Stromberg commissioned to look at legal matters, and PwC asked to review procurement and contract management – little or no thought was ever given to the inherent risk of catastrophic events.”




SASKPOWER CEO RESIGNS FOLLOWING INVESTIGATION INTO SMART METER “CATASTROPHE”. SMART METER FIRES HAVE ALSO BEEN REPORTED IN THE US AND FORCED UTILITIES TO REPLACE HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF METERS.





SaskPower CEO resigns following investigation into smart meter “catastrophe”.  SMART METER FIRES HAVE ALSO BEEN REPORTED IN THE US AND FORCED UTILITIES TO REPLACE HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF METERS.




SaskPower CEO Robert Watson has resigned — without severance — after an investigation into “smart” meter fires throughout Saskatchewan.
As reported in late July, following a series of fires throughout Saskatchewan, Canada, “SaskPower ordered to remove all 105,000 smart meters in the province.”

On October 27th, the Government of Saskatchewan released the results of a scathing review on the smart meter “debacle” which is now commonly being referred to as a “catastrophe.”  The  report concluded that “customer safety was not given enough priority.”

SaskPower CEO Robert Watson resigned his position immediately following the release of the report on the smart meter program.

Findings from the investigation
According to the government’s review:

“The primary issue of catastrophic meter failures which prompted the AMI program to be halted was not identified as an initial program risk.  When additional information about smart meter fires from other sources came to light, the risk of catastrophic meter failures did not prompt an independent reevaluation of the risk related to Sensus smart meters.”

Additional key findings:

Moisture and contaminants getting inside the meters were a major factor in the meter fires.

There is no evidence to indicate the fires were the result of improper installation or hot sockets.

SaskPower did not adequately consider the potential for significant meter failures resulting in damage to homes.

VIDEO: SaskPower CEO Robert Watson resigns amidst smart meter “catastrophe”
Jack Ritenburg, an electrical engineer and head of Ritenburg & Associates concluded that moisture and contaminants inside the meters was the cause of the smart meter fires.  He also concluded that “water intrusion due to holes in meter boxes, ‘hot socket’ conditions in the meter box and over voltage in the distribution system” or other “external factors” were not the cause of the fires as previously claimed by the manufacturer:

Jack Ritenburg, an electrical engineer and head of Ritengurb and Associates, reports on the suspected causes behind the SaskPower smart meter fires.
According to the independent fire investigation report:

“There was significant precipitation in the previous thirty days for all of the fires. There was significant precipitation in five of the fires within the preceding two days. The remaining three fires had light precipitation within the preceding two days.  There is evidence that moisture and contaminants have been getting into the meters and possibly being trapped.”

“Hot socket issues have been flagged as a possible reason for some of the meter failures. … [W]e feel that a hot socket condition resulting in a destructive meter failure and fire are not likely.”

“Sensus has claimed that some of the smart meter fires were caused by utility over-voltage. … We have not found any evidence to support that a significant over-voltage occurred and resulted in a destructive meter failure.”

The photo below shows electrical arcing inside a smart meter that was taken out of service under the category “Display Error.”  This failure is in the same location as smart meters which suffered a catastrophic failure.



The following photo (below) shows a meter that was taken out of service by SaskPower that has staining from smoke and evidence of moisture at the bottom of the meter.  This meter had not yet suffered a catastrophic failure.




The fire investigation report concluded with the following statements:

“In view of the above, we are of the opinion that moisture and contaminants within the meter has been a major factor in the meter failures and ensuing fires.”

“As there is some danger with destructive meter failures and potential resulting fires, we recommend that the existing Sensus Generation 3.3 meters be replaced as soon as possible.  As the existing meter fires have had a close relationship to precipitation levels, SaskPower might wish to consider replacement no later than the end of winter and before the spring thaw and spring rains begin.”

Just to be clear, the fire investigation report reveals that the principal problem is  primarily rain water  (and/or condensation along with other contaminants) that gets into the smart meters themselves, causing arcing across electronic components with eventual catastrophic failure of the meter with a possible explosion or fire.  Furthermore, based upon a review of the investigative report, it is clear we basically have “cheap” meters with a number of design deficiencies which includes uninsulated busbars in close proximity to printed circuit boards and which further allow easy entry of water and dust into the meter enclosures.
Bottom line, … the existing smart meters on people’s homes still present a fire risk in Saskatchewan and elsewhere.  In addition, these types of problems would not occur with traditional analog meters that do not contain fragile electronic components.

Smart meters a catastrophe

As a supplement, this website will quote a portion of an October 28, 2014, article in the Leader-Post entitled SaskPower smart meters a ‘catastrophe’:
“Lest there still be any doubt how badly bungled the SaskPower smart meter debacle was, consider how frequently lawyers, technical specialists and others used the word ‘catastrophic’ in their joint review released Monday.

‘The primary issue of catastrophic meter failures which prompted the AMI (Advanced Meter Infrastructure) program to be halted was not identified as an initial program risk,’ stated the $500,000 Crown Investments Corp. (CIC) report entitled Smart Meter Review.

‘When additional information about smart meter fires from other sources came to light, the risk of catastrophic meter failures did not prompt an independent re-evaluation of the risk related to Sensus smart meters.

An escalation of the risk assessment could have prompted additional investigation, testing and either closer monitoring of installed meters or a pause to the rollout of smart meters until issues were better understood.’

‘Catastrophic’ in Monday’s report refers to not just the eight fires started by the smart meters, but occasions when things like smoking in the smart meters – largely due to moisture or debris getting inside what should have been a sealed casing – might have easily led to fires.  In all, there were some 359 incidents of meter failure, although the majority were for things like improper readings.
Yet according to the review – [comprised] of three separate reports by Ritenburg and Associates looking into technical issues, Robertson Stromberg commissioned to look at legal matters, and PwC asked to review procurement and contract management – little or no thought was ever given to the inherent risk of catastrophic events.”


Fire Concerns Lead PECO to Halt Smart Meter Installations

PHILADELPHIA -
After at least two fires and over a dozen incidents of overheating, PECO is halting its controversial smart meter installation program.
The stunning announcement came Wednesday morning as FOX 29 Investigates pressed the company over a spate of recent incidents, including fires in Bucks County.
PECO had plans to install 1.6 million of the so-called smart meters.
The digital units are designed to conserve energy and help customers monitor their usage.
But over the past few months, concerns and complaints have grown that the installation of these new meters have sparked fires, including two recently in Bucks County.
Now, PECO is stopping installations as it takes a hard look at the meters and prepares to put safety measures in place.

"Is PECO concerned that it has 186,000 meters in people's homes here that may represent a danger to them and their families?" FOX 29's Jeff Cole asked.
"This situation is obviously being taken very seriously," PECO spokeswoman Cathy Engle Menendez answered. "We have 186,000 meters, the vast majority of which are performing well., but we've had 15 cases where there have been issues."
Of the 15 incidents, PECO says it is still investigating nine. Six, they claim, were not caused by the smart meters.
Along with the abrupt halt of the meter installations, PECO says it will install warning and shutdown components on those already in place.
In his video report for Wednesday's FOX 29 News at 10, Cole spoke to some of the property owners who were impacted by the fires.
If you want your PECO meter or equipment inspected, officials there want you to give them a call. The number is 855-741-9011.


Wednesday, November 12, 2014

THE FIRE AND DEATH RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH PORTABLE SPACE HEATERS


THE FIRE AND DEATH RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH PORTABLE SPACE HEATERS
 


Space heaters annually account for one-third of reported U.S. home heating fires, and four out of five associated civilian deaths.  Therefore, the safety of heating equipment is a growing concern.  Firefighters say that about 80 to 90 percent of the heater fires occur at night when the residents are asleep.

During winter months, the potential for house fires increases as people seek warmth using electric space heaters. Electric space heaters do not have an open flame, but the heating elements can get hot enough to ignite nearby combustibles.
Stationary (fixed) and portable space heaters, excluding fireplaces, chimneys, and chimney connectors, but including wood stoves, accounted for one-third (33%) of reported 2007-2011 U.S. home heating fires, four out of five (81%) associated civilian deaths, more than two-thirds (70%) of associated civilian injuries, and half (51%) of associated direct property damage.
The leading factors contributing to ignition in home heating equipment fires were failure to clean (28%), heat source too close to combustibles (14%), and unclassified mechanical failure or malfunction (12%). Heat source too close to combustibles was a factor in half (53%) of associated fire deaths.



Placing space heaters too close to combustibles such as carpeting, bedding, draperies, newspapers or books, clothing, furniture, or flammable liquids is the leading factor contributing to home heating fires.  Space heaters need space. 
 That’s a key message from the nonprofit National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) and the United States Fire Administration (USFA), who are teaming up to reduce the risk of home heating fires this December, January and February, when half of all U.S. heating home fires occur.
As part of their joint fire safety campaign, “Put a Freeze on Winter Fires,” NFPA and USFA urge everyone to practice extreme caution when using space heaters this season.  Keep things that can burn at least 3 feet away from space heaters, and create a three-foot “kid-free zone” around them.  Make sure to use equipment that has the label of a recognized testing laboratory, and have a qualified professional install stationary space heating equipment according to the local codes and manufacturer’s instructions.

The most dangerous space heaters are the kerosene models with an open flame.  A safe alternative would be a low-wattage electric space heater.  Family members should take special note of elderly or disabled relatives using space heaters.  It is common for those with arthritis, diabetes, and circulation problems to require additional warmth.  A personal heater may be the perfect solution – as long as it is a safe product and it is used properly:



For portable electric heaters:

·      Place them on a solid, flat surface, away from high traffic areas and doorways.
·      Turn them off when you go to bed or leave the room.
·      Use and purchase heaters with an automatic shut off so if they’re tipped over they will shut off.
·      Plug power cords directly into outlets and never into an extension cord.
·      Inspect for cracked or damaged, broken plugs or loose connections; replace before using.
·      If you are unable to plug the unit directly into a socket and have to use an extension cord, consider using a heavy-duty cord marked with a #14 gauge or larger wire (#12 gauge is larger than #14 gauge). An incorrectly sized cord could create a fire hazard. If the heater’s plug has a grounding prong, use only a grounding (three-wire) extension cord.
·      Never run the heater’s cord (or any cord) under rugs or carpeting.
·      Do not leave the heater operating unattended. Turn the unit off when you are sleeping. Portable electric space heaters are designed for use only as temporary supplemental heating and only while attended.
·      To prevent electrical shocks and electrocutions, keep portable electric heaters away from water, and never touch an electric heater if you are wet.
·      Do not use an electric heater as a dryer by placing clothing or other fabric over it, and never use a heater to thaw pipes.
·      Keep the heater in safe, working condition. Replace missing guards and controls at once. Never operate a defective heater.
·      Keep children and pets away from space heaters. Place the heater on a level, stable surface where it will not be tripped over, bumped into, or pushed over. Children should not be permitted to either adjust the controls or move the heater.





As with any type of heating system, install and maintain at least one smoke detector on each floor of your home. Make sure each smoke detector is in good working condition at all times.
In the event of any fire, in addition to CO, there are Products of Incomplete Combustion (PICs)—known carcinogens—released into your home by smoke and soot.  This presents a serious health hazard.
 Winter fires are preventable! For more heating safety advice from NFPA and USFA’s “Put a Freeze on Winter” campaign, visit www.nfpa.org/winter.



DEFECTIVE CONSTRUCTION PRODUCT MANUFACTURERS MUST BE DEFENDED BY THEIR GENERAL LIABILITY INSURERS IN PENNSYLVANIA



DEFECTIVE CONSTRUCTION PRODUCT MANUFACTURERS MUST BE DEFENDED BY THEIR GENERAL LIABILITY INSURERS IN PENNSYLVANIA






Two months ago, in Indalex v. National Union Fire Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh, Pa., No. 126 WAL 2014 (Pa. Sept. 18, 2014), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court refused to hear a petition by the CGL insurers of Indalex, et al in an attempt to overturn the Superior Court’s ruling last year where the court held that the CGL insurers have a duty to defend the defective product manufacturer against claims of third party property damage, mold and personal injuries.  Based on this decision, loss arising from a defective product may constitute an “occurrence” triggering general liability insurance coverage under Pennsylvania law. 






Background



Indalex, a window and door manufacturer, sought coverage under a commercial umbrella insurance policy issued by National Union Fire Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh, Pa., for multiple lawsuits filed by homeowners and property owners. The lawsuits alleged that Indalex’s windows and doors were defectively designed or manufactured and resulted in water leakage that caused physical damage, including mold and cracked walls, as well as personal injury. The claims against Indalex were based on strict liability, negligence, breach of warranty and breach of contract.



The insurer argued that there was no “occurrence” triggering coverage, relying on Kvaerner Metals Division of Kvaerner U.S., Inc. v. Commercial Union Ins. Co., 908 A.2d 888 (Pa. 2006).  In Kvaerner, Bethlehem brought an action against Kvaerner asserting claims of breach of contract and breach of warranty.  In its complaint, Bethlehem alleged that it entered into a contract with Kvaerner (the “Contract”) pursuant to which Kvaerner agreed to design and construct a coke oven battery (the “Battery”) for Bethlehem.  According to Bethlehem, under the contract Kvaerner (1) agreed to build the Battery according to certain “plans and specifications that were made a part of the [Contract],” (2) warranted that its materials, equipment, and work would be free from defect, and (3) agreed to repair or replace any defective work or materials.





Bethlehem then contended that based on these facts, Kvaerner breached the above Contract terms because the Battery built by Kvaerner was “damaged” and “did not meet the contract specifications and warranties, or the applicable industry standards for construction ․” Bethlehem further alleged that although it sent Kvaerner a “non-performance list” detailing the Battery's “damages and breaches,” Kvaerner had failed to remedy the Battery's problems.   Moreover, Bethlehem incorporated by reference the “damages and breaches” listed in the non-performance list, which enumerated numerous problems with the Battery,



In Kvaerner, the PA Supreme Court ruled there was no “occurrence” because the underlying complaint alleged only property damage from faulty workmanship to the work product itself.  Kvaerner also was based on an underlying complaint that contained only claims for breach of contract and breach of warranty.



The facts in Indalex are much different than the ones alleged in Kvaerner and in addition, the cause of action was not based on contract but was based on tort, negligence and third party personal injuries.  In Indalex Inc. v. National Union Fire Insurance Co., several lawsuits were filed against Indalex, alleging that windows and doors it supplied to a residential construction project were defectively designed or manufactured, resulting in water leakage that caused physical damage to the underlying plaintiffs’ residences, as well as personal injuries in some instances. Many contractors also impleaded Indalex into lawsuits brought by homeowners directly against them.  The primary insurer, One Beacon, defended and indemnified Indalex in these lawsuits.  But when its policy limits were exhausted, National Union, the umbrella insurer, refused to defend and indemnify Indalex.  Relying upon Kvaerner and its progeny, it claimed that faulty workmanship and product defects do not qualify as an “occurrence” under the National Union policy.




The Indalex court held that National Union was required to defend Indalex with regard to the underlying claims of property damage and personal injury. “Simply stated, because Appellants set forth tort claims based on damages to persons or property, other than the insured’s product, we cannot conclude that the claims are outside the scope of the coverage.”






The Indalex is an important, as well as correct decision



This is an important decision, especially for manufacturers who supply products that are used in construction projects. The critical distinction is that where a faulty product causes harm to other property, a CGL policy may provide coverage, because the damage to the “other property” constitutes an “occurrence.”



Many state supreme courts (for example, Connecticut, North Dakota, and West Virginia) have, in the past year, determined that faulty workmanship can be an occurrence, particularly where it causes unintended and unexpected damage to other property. And, some states have even enacted legislation requiring CGL policies to define occurrence to include property damage or bodily injury resulting from faulty workmanship, or have made it easier for insureds to obtain coverage for damages as a result of work the insureds performed (for example, Arkansas, South Carolina, Colorado and others). New Jersey also recently introduced legislation seeking to require CGL insurers to alter the definition of "occurrence" to include property damage from faulty workmanship. 





Although the Indalex decision centered around faulty products, a parallel can be drawn between a faulty product and faulty workmanship, both of which may cause similar unintended damage. At the least, this decision widens coverage for policyholders, and appears to be a step in the right direction toward the majority view nationwide, that CGL policies should cover faulty workmanship that causes damage to other property.




Defense coverage (and perhaps even indemnification) for unexpected damage caused from allegedly defective work or products such as stucco or concrete may now be more likely. 






Builders, contractors and manufacturers historically purchased such CGI policies to protect themselves against a multitude of risks and lawsuits, including claims for defective or faulty workmanship or manufacture of their products, and regardless of whether the damages sought from the contractors or manufacturers were for property damage or bodily injury, and by whatever theory of liability which was asserted against the companies.



Over the past several years, however, the Pennsylvania appellate courts had issued several decisions that significantly narrowed the scope of what was a “covered” claim under such CGI policies, which consequently limited the scope of the carrier’s duty to defend the builder, contractor or manufacturer which had been sued for alleged defective or faulty workmanship or products.  Businesses were at a serious disadvantage in defending against such lawsuits if they could not at least count on the carriers’ duty to defend them in such a suit, let alone a duty to indemnify them.









Metropolitan Engineering, Consulting & Forensics (MECF)



Providing Competent, Expert and Objective Investigative Engineering and Consulting Services


P.O. Box 520


Tenafly, NJ 07670-0520



Tel.: (973) 897-8162



Fax: (973) 810-0440


E-mail: metroforensics@gmail.com

Web pages: https://sites.google.com/site/metropolitanforensics/


https://sites.google.com/site/metropolitanenvironmental/