MEC&F Expert Engineers

Thursday, September 6, 2018

BSEE Reports Tropical Storm Gordon Activity Statistics: Sept. 5, 2018





BSEE Reports Tropical Storm Gordon Activity Statistics: Sept. 5, 2018


The BSEE Hurricane Response Team continues to monitor Gulf of Mexico oil and gas activities.

NEW ORLEANS, LA — 


The Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement (BSEE) Hurricane Response Team is monitoring offshore oil and gas operators in the Gulf as they respond to Tropical Storm Gordon. The Response Team works with offshore operators and other state and federal agencies until operations return to normal and the storm is no longer a threat to Gulf of Mexico oil and gas activities.

Based on data from offshore operator reports submitted as of 11:30 a.m. CDT Tuesday, personnel have been evacuated from a total of 48 production platforms, 6.99 percent of the 687 manned platforms in the Gulf of Mexico. Production platforms are structures located offshore from which oil and natural gas are produced. Unlike drilling rigs, which typically move from location to location, production facilities remain in the same location throughout a project’s duration.

All of the 20 rigs (non-dynamically positioned), currently operating in the Gulf, including several types of offshore drilling facilities including jackup rigs, platform rigs, submersibles and moored semisubmersibles are in operation.

Further, all of the 19 dynamically positioned rigs are on location.

As part of the evacuation process, personnel activate the applicable shut-in procedure, which can frequently be accomplished from a remote location. This involves closing the sub-surface safety valves located below the surface of the ocean floor to prevent the release of oil or gas. During previous hurricane seasons, the shut-in valves functioned 100 percent of the time, efficiently shutting in production from wells on the Outer Continental Shelf and protecting the marine and coastal environments. Shutting-in oil and gas production is a standard procedure conducted by industry for safety and environmental reasons.

From operator reports, it is estimated that approximately 9.36 percent of the current oil production in the Gulf of Mexico has been shut-in. It is also estimated that approximately 10.39 percent of the natural gas production in the Gulf of Mexico has been shut-in. The production percentages are calculated using information submitted by offshore operators in daily reports. Shut-in production information included in these reports is based on the amount of oil and gas the operator expected to produce that day. The shut-in production figures therefore are estimates, which BSEE compares to historical production reports to ensure the estimates follow a logical pattern.

After the storm has passed, facilities will be inspected. Once all standard checks have been completed, production from undamaged facilities will be brought back on line immediately. Facilities sustaining damage may take longer to bring back on line. BSEE will continue to update the evacuation and shut-in statistics at 1:00 p.m. CDT each day, as appropriate.

This survey information is reflective of 26 companies’ reports as of 11:30 a.m. CDT today.

Seguro-Suarez Ex Rel. Connette v. Key Risk Insurance Co.: an injured worker whose insurer knowingly provided false information to police to frame him for insurance fraud, resulting in his arrest, incarceration and indictment on felony charges, can pursue malicious prosecution, abuse of process and unfair and deceptive trade practices claims






Injured worker framed for insurance fraud gets split ruling on appeal

Gloria Gonzalez


September 5, 2018

The Court of Appeals of North Carolina has ruled that an injured worker whose insurer knowingly provided false information to police to frame him for insurance fraud, resulting in his arrest, incarceration and indictment on felony charges, can pursue malicious prosecution, abuse of process and unfair and deceptive trade practices claims, but not bad faith and civil conspiracy claims.

In 2003, Mario Seguro-Suarez was working for Southern Fiber when he fell from a height of approximately 18 feet onto concrete, striking his head and suffering several broken bones and severe traumatic brain injury, according to court documents in Seguro-Suarez Ex Rel. Connette v. Key Risk Insurance Co. He was rendered comatose and underwent emergency neurosurgery to relieve pressure on his brain. He eventually emerged from his coma, but the brain injury changed his personality, requiring physical, speech and occupational therapy. He currently suffers from significant behavioral and memory deficits, and his injuries rendered him dependent on others for dressing, feeding and other self-care activities. Southern Fiber and Key Risk, as Southern Fiber’s insurance carrier, admitted that his injuries were compensable, according to the ruling.

An authorized treating physician performed multiple tests to discern the nature and extent of his condition, with each test showing symptoms consistent with traumatic brain injury and requested an occupational home therapy evaluation, according to court documents. Key Risk denied the request and refused to provide the evaluation as well as a subsequent request for an evaluation by a neurologist and additional treatment by the treating physician. A neuropsychologist treated Mr. Seguro-Suarez and initially believed he was legitimately suffering from the stated conditions until Key Risk showed the neuropsychologist video footage that convinced him otherwise. The video, cut from nine hours of surveillance footage taken by Key Risk over a six-month period and edited down to 45 minutes, led the neuropsychologist to opine that he was willfully exaggerating his symptoms and that he needed no further treatment.

In 2008, a deputy commissioner of the North Carolina Industrial Commission ordered Key Risk to authorize further treatment by the treating physician. In 2010, after Key Risk argued that his benefits should be cut off for fraud and misrepresentation, a deputy commissioner entered an opinion and award requiring Key Risk to pay continued compensation for his care, with the full commission issuing an opinion in the injured worker’s favor in April 2011. Following its losses before the commission, and after exhausting its appeal efforts, Key Risk hired an investigator to surreptitiously surveil and record Mr. Seguro-Suarez for several weeks. Key Risk also arranged for an independent medical exam of in June 2013 to determine whether his symptoms were legitimate and if he required ongoing care. The forensic psychiatrist who examined the injured worker observed his “childlike” demeanor and concluded he was suffering from dementia, traumatic brain injury, chronic dizziness, and chronic headaches — all stemming from his workplace injury. Key Risk’s chosen examiner further opined that his “symptoms appeared to be valid. There was no apparent malingering, in [her] opinion.”

“The mounting medical evidence and full-throated rebuke from the commission left Key Risk undeterred in its efforts to undermine plaintiff’s medical diagnosis and continued care,” court documents state.

After the independent medical exam, Key Risk directed its investigator to convince the Lincolnton Police Department to bring criminal charges against the plaintiff under the theory that he was obtaining his workers compensation benefits by false pretenses and provide the department with extensively edited videotape that led to his arrest, jailing and indictment on 25 counts of obtaining property by false pretenses and one count of insurance fraud, all for accepting the checks ordered paid to him by the commission, according to court documents. The charges were dismissed after a psychological examination to determine his competency to stand trial noted conditions consistent with his documented medical history.

After his release from custody, Mr. Seguro-Suarez filed suit against Key Risk and the investigator asserting malicious prosecution, abuse of process, unfair and deceptive trade practices, bad faith, willful and wanton conduct, civil conspiracy and punitive damages. The trial court denied the defendants’ motion to dismiss. The appellate court upheld the trial court’s order, with the exception that the trial court erred in failing to dismiss the bad faith and civil conspiracy claims.

“When a North Carolina worker is hurt on the job, his injury is within the exclusive scope of the Workers’ Compensation Act and he can obtain relief only by pursuing a claim before the North Carolina Industrial Commission,” the court ruling stated. “But when, after the commission awards the injured worker benefits, an employer’s insurance company knowingly provides false information to police to frame him for insurance fraud, resulting in his arrest, incarceration, and indictment on felony charges, the worker’s claims for malicious prosecution, abuse of process, and unfair and deceptive trade practices exceed the scope of the Workers’ Compensation Act and are properly before the General Court of Justice.”

A Key Risk spokesperson said the company does not comment on pending litigation.

A painter was injured in Portland’s Old Port when he was standing on an elevated scissor lift that fell over onto Center Street in Maine


  A worker was injured in Portland’s Old Port on Tuesday morning when he was standing on an elevated scissor lift that fell over onto Center Street-  News Center Maine 


By Megan DoyleStaff Writer


A worker was injured in Portland’s Old Port on Tuesday morning when he was standing on an elevated scissor lift that fell over onto Center Street.

Capt. John Brennan of the Portland Fire Department said the man was injured but conscious when he was transported to a local hospital.


“He was conscious and breathing and talking,” Brennan said.

It appeared the man had been painting the side of a building at the intersection of Center and Commercial streets, and the scissor lift was on the cobblestone sidewalk when it toppled.

“It fell into one lane of Center Street closest to the building, and he ended up in the other lane on the ground,” Brennan said.

Multiple bystanders called 911 to report the accident, and one person alerted a nearby fire crew that was completing a call in the area. It is not clear who the worker’s employer is.

The Portland Police Department was also on scene, but did not immediately return a call for comment.

A backhoe operator for Atchley Farms, Fernando Romero Martinez, 27, died after he was buried in 10 feet of dirt for an hour in Aston, Idaho

 A backhoe operator for Atchley Farms, Fernando Romero Martinez, 27, died after he was buried in 10 feet of dirt for an hour in Aston, Idaho

The backhoe operator told law enforcement that he and a helper had been digging a trench and the helper had gone into the trench to put pipe connections together.

The backhoe operator told investigators that when he moved the backhoe forward to continue digging, he turned back around to operate the hoe and saw that approximately 15 feet behind the backhoe a 10-foot section of the trench had collapsed and the helper was nowhere to be found, a Fremont County Sheriff’s Office news release said.


ASHTON, Idaho (KIFI/KIDK) - UPDATE 9/5/18: 



The Fremont County Sheriff's Office has identified the man as 27-year-old Fernando Romero Martinez of Ashton.

Romero Martinez was located approximately an hour after the incident was called in and declared deceased at the scene.

ORIGINAL:

A man was killed Tuesday afternoon in a trench collapse near Ashton.

The Fremont County Sheriff's Office says it got the call about the collapse around 4:00 p.m.

A backhoe operator was installing plastic pipe for a drainage system, and the man was in the trench to put pipe connections together.

The backhoe driver told the sheriff's office he pulled forward to keep digging the trench and when they turned around the trench had collapsed on top of the man.

The man's body was uncovered about an hour after the 911 call about the accident came in, he was pronounced dead at the scene.

The identity of those involved has not been released. 



====================================




ASHTON, IDAHO — 


The Occupational Safety and Health Administration is investigating a trench collapse that killed a 27-year-old man Tuesday evening.

The man, whom relatives and authorities identify as Fernando Romero Martinez, was in a trench installing plastic pipe for a drainage system in the Ashton area around 4 p.m. Martinez was working as a backhoe operator for Atchley Farms.

Another backhoe operator at the site told deputies he turned around to operate the machine and saw a 10-foot line of dirt suddenly collapse into the trench, burying Martinez.


Fernando Romero Martinez | GoFundMe

Volunteers and emergency responders from multiple jurisdictions rushed to the area and dug for an hour until Martinez’s body was found. He was pronounced dead at the scene.

OSHA confirmed to EastIdahoNews.com on Wednesday morning that it has started an investigation but declined to provide further details.

Federal law requires any trench more than 5 feet deep to have cave-in protection unless the excavation is made entirely in stable rock. Officials have not said if a trench box or other protection was used in this case, and the name of the company doing the work has not been released.

Martinez is from Mexico and a GoFundMe page has been created by a friend “to bring him back home, to his daughter and family … where he can have a proper funeral and burial.”



=================================
Idaho man dies after being buried in trench for an hour
By Nate Eaton, EastIdahoNews.com 


September 4, 2018

ASHTON, Idaho — A man buried in dirt for an hour Tuesday was found dead after a frantic search by emergency responders.

The 27-year-old was in a trench installing plastic pipe for a drainage system in the Ashton area around 4 p.m., according to a news release from the Fremont County Sheriff’s Office. A backhoe operator above the trench told deputies he turned around to operate the machine and saw a ten-foot line of dirt suddenly collapse into the trench – burying his helper.

Emergency dispatchers were contacted and multiple agencies, including the Fremont County Sheriff’s Office, Fremont County Fire Department, Fremont County EMS, Fremont County Search and Rescue, Madison EMS, Air Idaho and multiple people, responded to the area and began digging.

The man’s body was found an hour after the collapse and he was pronounced dead on the scene. His name has not been released.

MESSY AUSSIE: A tub of WET concrete fell into a pit, killing one worker and injuring others at a construction site in Melbourne's east in Australia



Box Hill crane accident: Melbourne worker killed, two men injured on construction site

Updated
Media player: "Space" to play, "M" to mute, "left" and "right" to seek.
Video: Workers injured on Melbourne construction site (ABC News)
A man has been killed and two others are injured after a tub of concrete fell from a crane at a construction site in Melbourne's east.

Key points:

  • A tub of concrete fell into a pit, killing one worker and injuring others
  • Two of the men working in the pit were submerged in concrete
  • The CFMMEU says counselling has been offered to the men's workmates

Paramedics said two of the men were submerged and trapped in concrete after the tub fell on top of them at Box Hill about 12:20pm.
One of the trapped men died, while paramedics and workers had to race against the clock to free the other from the wet cement.
"He was struck by the object as well and he was partially submerged in the concrete," said senior intensive care paramedic Gary Robertson.
Emergency workers at the scene of a crane accident. Photo: Specialist rescue teams were deployed to the scene. (ABC News: Iskhandar Razak)

"So he had to be extricated from the concrete to get him out.
"It was wet concrete and obviously as you can appreciate there's a timeline with that as well, because concrete sets."
The man suffered extensive injuries to his head, chest and abdomen, including fractures and internal bleeding, paramedics said.
He was taken to the Royal Melbourne Hospital, where a trauma team was standing by.
Emergency workers at the scene of a crane accident. Photo: The union believes mechanical failure caused the accident. (ABC News)

Another man with minor injuries was taken to Box Hill Hospital, Ambulance Victoria said.
The injured men, from the suburbs of Caroline Springs and Southbank, were both in their late 20s, police said.
Forty firefighters, including specialist urban search and rescue teams, attended the scene, along with heavy rescue and high angle appliances.
"It's been a very difficult incident as it's a building site," assistant chief fire officer Brendan Angwin said.
Mr Robertson said workers, including the crane driver, were "incredibly traumatised' by the incident.
Victoria Police said it was investigating, and WorkSafe has been notified.
Emergency workers at the scene of a crane accident. Photo: Authorities said workers were "incredibly traumatized".  They wanted to talk to their mamma and suck their thumbs. (ABC News: Nathan Stitt)

'No-one should go to work and die'

Union leader John Setka told 3AW Radio that the union had sent counsellors to the scene to offer support to the traumatised workers.
"It's absolutely terrible," said Mr Setka, the Victorian secretary of the Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union (CFMMEU).
"You know, there's people on site crying at the moment. 
"It is just something that should not happen ever, to anyone.
"It's just … no-one should go to work and die."
He said he believed a mechanical failure had occurred.
"From what we can tell, it's one of them hammerhead cranes, the ones that sort of stick out vertically.
"[It] looks like the hook's come off with the kibble on it.
"The kibble is the sort of big bucket they whack on there full of concrete.
Emergency workers at the scene of a crane accident. Photo: Emergency services were called to the scene about 12:20pm. (ABC News)

Mr Setka said one of the injured men had broken both of his arms.
The union said the crane belonged to Clark Cranes, which it said also owned the crane that collapsed on a Richmond construction site in July.
The company declined the chance to comment when contacted by the ABC.
VicRoads said motorists should avoid the area around the site, on the corner of Watts Street and Whitehorse Road.
They recommended using alternative routes such as the Eastern Freeway and Canterbury Road.