MEC&F Expert Engineers

Friday, July 7, 2017

Norway's Protector Forsikring, the insurer of London's Grenfell Tower, where at least 80 people died in a devastating fire, raised its estimate for property and liability insurance claims to 50 million pounds






OSLO (Reuters) - The insurer of London's Grenfell Tower, where at least 80 people died in a devastating fire, raised its estimate for property and liability insurance claims to 50 million pounds on Friday.


British police have said the final death toll from the blaze that gutted the 24-storey apartment block on June 14 may not be known until next year and the government has appointed a retired judge to lead a public inquiry into the disaster.


Norway's Protector Forsikring the insurance provider for the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, which owns the building, also said it had been aware Grenfell Tower had been refurbished during the insurance underwriting process.


It said it had considered this renovation, which was criticized by some residents, as a positive step.


Asked whether the company was aware at the time that the cladding used for the tower block was potentially flammable, Protector Forsikring's chief executive Sverre Bjerkeli told Reuters: "We must let the investigation run its course."


Protector Forsikring said in its second-quarter earnings that it estimated gross claims would total 50 million pounds ($65 million), doubling a previous 25 million pound forecast.


"Figures are preliminary, uncertain and will include both property, liability and other potential related costs," it said.


Protector's previous estimate was for claims of 20 million pounds to cover the building itself, with the remainder covering additional expenses such as alternative housing for residents.


It provided no breakdown of the updated figure, but it has previously said the cost would largely be covered by reinsurance through Germany's Munich Re, which declined to comment on Friday.



Britain's Jardine Lloyd Thompson, which was the insurance broker for Grenfell Tower, has previously said it was working closely to assist its client in the case.


For Protector itself, net property and liability claims relating to the fire are not expected to change from a first estimate of 2.5 million pounds, Bjerkeli said.


Before the fire, Protector Forsikring had rated the borough of Kensington and Chelsea as a good customer for the insurer.


"The client is better than the London average, the London average is better than the UK average and the UK average is better than Scandinavia," Bjerkeli said.


This assessment was based on data the company has gathered during 10,000 visits of properties in Britain, Bjerkeli said, adding that he remained confident in the country's public sector and the firm would maintain its UK growth strategy.


Britain said on Wednesday it was sending in a task force to help run the local authority, which has been struggling to cope with the aftermath of the fire.


Kensington and Chelsea has been criticized by victims' relatives and survivors for its handling of the disaster and its leader quit last week.


Prime Minister Theresa May promised that all residents would be offered good temporary homes in the local area within three weeks, but that deadline passed on Wednesday and while 139 families had been offered homes, only 14 had been accepted and just three had moved in. 






Protector Insurance is a Scandinavian company listed on the Oslo Stock Exchange. Since the beginning of 2004 we have had a fast and profitable growth. The company delivers land based insurance to commercial and public sector, and we distribute our products through insurance brokers. We also sell change of ownership insurance through real estate brokers and lawyers in the Norwegian market, which has an agreement with Protector.

In 2016 the company's written premium was NOK 3.439 billion compared to NOK 2.843 billion in 2015. This gave us a growth of 21%.

Protector has grown rapidly, and we are currently counting almost 300 employees; in Norway, Sweden, Denmark, UK and Finland.

Timeline

  • 2004 Sale of insurances
  • 2004 Launches change of ownership insurance
  • 2005 Started settlement of claims in-house
  • 2006 Strong growth in public sector
  • 2007 Protector is listed on the Oslo Stock Exchange in May
  • 2008 26% growth in the private and public sector
  • 2009 20% increase in total premium income
  • 2010 Passing one billion NOK in premium income
  • 2011 Starts selling insurances in Sweden
  • 2012 Starts selling insurances in Denmark
    1,5 billion NOK in premium income, 26% growth
  • 2013 23% growth
  • 2014 28% growth
  • 2015 20 % growth
  • 2015

THE VENUS WILLIAMS WRONGFUL DEATH SUIT: Circuit Judge Cymonie Rowe on Wednesday granted a request by Williams’ attorney to temporarily prevent a data download from the car occupied by victim Jerome Barson, 78








Venus Williams




Venus Williams wins emergency court ruling in fatal crash wrongful death lawsuit

A Palm Beach County judge has granted an emergency request by an attorney for Venus Williams to temporarily stop data downloads from the vehicles in the wrongful death lawsuit against the tennis star. A hearing on the matter is set for Friday.


Venus Williams’ lawyer has obtained an emergency order in the wrongful death lawsuit against the tennis great over her June 9 crash in Palm Beach Gardens.

Circuit Judge Cymonie Rowe on Wednesday granted a request by Williams’ attorney to temporarily prevent a data download from the car occupied by victim Jerome Barson, 78.


The court has scheduled a hearing on the matter at 2:30 p.m. Friday at the Palm Beach County Courthouse.

Barson died June 22 from traumatic injuries in the crash, including a broken spine and massive internal bleeding.

Williams is currently in London competing in the Wimbledon tennis championships and is not expected in court. She is scheduled to play a third-round match on Friday.

On Wednesday, Williams’ attorney asked the court to intervene and stop the Barson estate’s lawyers from inspecting and getting information from the 2016 Hyundai Accent.

The concern is that the planned download by Barson attorney Michael Steinger could fail and the data would be lost, argued attorney Kevin Yombor of Fort Lauderdale. He asked for the judge to approve a joint inspection carried out by experts for both sides.

Both the Accent and Williams’ 2010 Toyota Sequoia are being stored at a West Palm Beach tow yard, records show.


“The on-board data of both vehicles will be critical evidence,” Yombor wrote. “The actions taken by Plaintiff should not occur until … a procedure is in place to ensure that the data of each vehicle is properly collected.”

Palm Beach Gardens police say the crash remains under investigation. Williams has not been cited with any traffic violations.

Attorneys for the Barson estate could not be reached for comment Thursday despite attempts by email and phone.

The crash happened in the intersection of Northlake Boulevard and BallenIsles Drive.

Williams was driving north toward BallenIsles, where she lives, while the Barsons, who reside west of Palm Beach Gardens, were heading west on Northlake. Linda Barson, 68, was driving her husband of 33 years.

Williams’ SUV was hit on the right side by the Barsons’ Hyundai when the Toyota came through the intersection in front of the Barsons, police wrote in an initial report released last week.

“The driver of [the Toyota] is at fault for violating the right of way of [the Hyundai],” the police report stated, listing Williams speed as 5 mph and the Barsons’ speed as 25 mph.

But the cars’ “black boxes” could provide information about the speed at the time of impact.

Williams and Barson both said they had green lights. Williams told an officer she stopped “in the median break due to other traffic.”

The lawsuit blames Williams for “failing to yield the right of way, failing to stop at a red-light ... failing to stop for oncoming traffic, driving too fast for the conditions, driving carelessly and recklessly, and distracted driving.”

After her opening round victory at Wimbledon on Monday, Williams, 37, cried when speaking to reporters about the crash.

“There are no words to describe, like, how devastating and, yeah,” she said as her words trailed off. “Yeah, I am completely speechless.”

On Williams’ Facebook page, she posted a statement Friday after being sued: “I am devastated and heartbroken by this accident. My heartfelt condolences go out to the family and friends of Jerome Barson and I continue to keep them in my thoughts and prayers.”



==============



Venus Williams: Brandy Norwood’s wrongful death lawsuit is a cautionary tale
By Yvette Caslin | June 30, 2017 2:04 PM EST



NEW YORK – AUGUST 25: Venus Williams attends press conference at Arthur Ash stadium on August 25, 2012 in Queens New York (Photo Credit: Lev Radin)

Michael Steinger is the attorney for Linda Barson, wife of Jerome Barson, 78, who died during a fatal car crash involving Venus Williams.

On “Good Morning America” on Friday, June 30, Steinger said that the family will file suit against the tennis star over the accident that left Jerome with head injuries. Barson died two weeks after the crash.

A police report obtained by TMZ Sports states that Williams, who was driving a 2010 Toyota Sequoia, is “at fault for violating the right of way of [the other driver].” Williams’ SUV darted into an intersection in Palm Beach Gardens. Linda Barson, who was also injured, said she could not stop her 2016 Hyundai Accent in time and hit Williams’ car.
 

“At this point we are attempting to both preserve the evidence and gain access to evidence,” Steinger said. “There were video cameras placed at guard houses where Ms. Williams lives; police have refused after multiple requests to turn those over to us, and we would like to see visual portrayal of the accident on those videos. They have impounded all the vehicles and have impeded our ability to do our investigation and move forward. Not sure what their reasoning is. They have refused to turn them over to us at this point.”

LAS VEGAS – MAY 20: Brandy Norwood at the 2012 Billboard Music Awards held at the MGM Grand Garden Arena on May 20, 2012 in Las Vegas, Nevada (Photo Credit: By Joe Seer)

Similarly, in 2007, a wrongful death suit was filed against Grammy Award-winning singer Brandy Norwood by the parents of a woman who died in a Los Angeles freeway car crash involving the singer. The parents of victim Awatef Aboudihaj, 38, claimed both compensatory and punitive damages in the amount of $50 million. According to reports, Norwood was driving her Land Rover at 65 miles per hour.

Norwood’s vehicle hit a 2005 Toyota, which then hit a 1989 Toyota. The 2005 Toyota slid sideways into the center divider and was hit by a 1988 Acura. Aboudihaj was the driver of the 2005 Toyota. The mother of one was taken to Holy Cross Hospital and died the next day from blunt-force injuries, according to the coroner’s office.

On Nov. 13, 2009, Norwood reached a settlement with Marouane Hdidou, husband of Awatef Aboudihaj, the mother of two who was killed in the December 2006 crash. The terms of the settlement were not disclosed.

Canadian National Railway employee Jim Wagner of Dubuque drowned after he slipped off the train bridge, and fell into the Mississippi River water







East Dubuque, Illinois
UPDATE:

Authorities have identified the missing railroad worker who fell into the Mississippi River.

The Canadian National Railway employee is Jim Wagner of Dubuque.

"We are presuming that he drowned," said Joe Heim, East Dubuque Fire Chief.

Authorities say Wagner somehow slipped off the train bridge, and fell into the water, early Monday morning.

On Tuesday, day two of the search, about 25 first responders went up and down the river using sonar technology to scan for the body. The AirCare3 Helicopter was flown above to assist in the effort.

Hours gone by, but Wagner's body has not been recovered. The East Dubuque Fire Department made the tough decision to scale back.

"At this point, going forward, we're gonna start scaling our operation back -- we're gonna periodically check this week, and the following week going up and down the river and checking the back waters at the time," Heim said.

One of the challenges for authorities is the immense size of the mighty Mississippi. "And the current is very swift right now, that's what makes it very difficult for operations because of that, that swift current," added Heim.

KWWL reached out to Canadian National. A spokesman said: "CN continues to investigate the circumstances surrounding this tragic incident. We are deeply saddened and our thoughts and prayers are with Mr. Wagner’s family, friends and co-workers. We also will continue to work with local authorities."

-----------------------------------------

PREVIOUS:

East Dubuque Fire Chief confirmed today in a press meeting that the worker, who fell in the river, is Jim Wagner from Dubuque.

---------------------------

Part of the Mississippi River has been closed for much of the day, crews worked to find the missing man.

Law enforcement say the rescue operation has switched to recovery mode.

First responders from Iowa, and Illinois searched the water for a Canadian National employee.

The search area is about 30 miles -- north of the train bridge to Bellevue.

They are using sonar equipment, to scan for the person in the water.

Officials say they believe he slipped, and the railroad company has video of it.

"This morning at approximately 7:15 we were notified to check on a worker on the train bridge, up here just north of town, upon looking at video when the Canadian National got in, they found that a person had fallen off the bridge," said Joe Heim, chief of the East Dubuque Fire Department.

Several hours went by before first responders were called. At the time, the employee was the only person on the bridge.

Crews plan on resuming their search Tuesday morning.

The identity of the operator will not be released until family has been notified.

Canadian National Railroad released the following statement:

"The name of the individual is not being released at this time. At this point all I can confirm is a CN employee is missing. Our emergency responders are working with local officials on the search. "We have launched an internal investigation into the circumstances of this tragic incident. Our thoughts and prayers are with our employee’s family and co-workers during this difficult time."

Thank you,

Patrick Waldron

CN spokesman

--------------------------------------------

The Jo Daviess County Sheriff's Department says a part of the Mississippi River is closed for some sort of missing person investigation.

In a news conference this afternoon, fire chief says was he was a Canadian National operator. The incident seemed to be accidental, and they believe he slipped into the river.

The East Dubuque Fire Department is currently conducting an investigation on the river. It is closed from the train bridge to the Julien Dubuque Bridge until further notice.

A 20-year-old worker was killed after a pipe fell off a jack and struck him while he was working at Michels Corporation as employees of a subcontractor, All Tools LLC of Fond du Lac were cleaning pipes
















Update on the tragedy at Michels

Dodge County Sheriff's Office


FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
July 6, 2017
Sheriff Dale J Schmidt
Office: 920-386-4115
dschmidt@co.dodge.wi.us

At 12:44 PM on Thursday, July 6, 2017 the Dodge County Sheriff’s Office received a 911 call of an industrial accident that took place at Michels Corporation, 817 Main Street Brownsville, WI involving a 20 year old male.

First responders arrived to provide care for the victim but he was declared deceased at the scene. Investigation showed that a subcontractor of Michels Corporation (All Tools, LLC of Fond du Lac) were cleaning pipes. One of the pipes fell off of a jack and slid into the victim causing fatal injuries. Sheriff’s office deputies along with the Dodge County Medical Examiner’s Office conducted the investigation into the incident.

The name of the victim is being withheld pending notification of family members. The name will not be released until proper notification of family has been made but not before 3 PM on Friday, July 7, 2017.

Michels Corporation and All Tools, LLC will be working closely to cooperate with OSHA officials in further investigation of the incident. There will be no further information available on this incident from the sheriff’s office except for the release of the name of the victim at such time as it is appropriate to do so.
Further questions should be directed to Michels Corporation.



=========================
Man dies in accident at Michels Corp. in Brownsville, WI

TERRI PEDERSON 

tpederson@wiscnews.com



BROWNSVILLE, WI — A 20-year-old man was killed Thursday afternoon after a pipe fell off a jack and struck him while he was working at Michels Corporation, 817 Main St., Brownsville.

According to the Dodge County Sheriff’s Office, a call was received at 12:44 p.m. Thursday that there was an industrial accident at Michels Corporation.

First responders arrived to provide care for the victim, but he was declared dead at the scene. Investigation showed that employees of a subcontractor, All Tools LLC of Fond du Lac, were cleaning pipes. One of the pipes fell off a jack and slid into the victim causing fatal injuries. The name of the victim is being withheld pending notification of family members.

Sheriff’s deputies along with the Dodge County Medical Examiner’s Office conducted the investigation into the incident.

The Sheriff’s Office said Michels Corporation and All Tools will closely cooperate with the Occupational Safety and Health Administration as the incident is further investigated.




================
The Dodge County Sheriff says that a 20-year-old man has died in an industrial accident there.

It happened at about 12:40 p.m. at Michels Corporation, a pipeline and excavation company located in Brownsville, Wis.

The Sheriff says a subcontractor based in Fond du Lac, All Tools, LLC, was cleaning pipes when one of them fell off a jack and went into the victim, which lead to injuries that killed him.

According to the Sheriff, no specifics will be given on the victim's identity until family have been notified.

OSHA will work with Michels Corporation and All Tools, LLC in the investigation. 




=============

BROWNSVILLE — A 20-year-old man died as a result of an industrial accident at Michels Corporation in Brownsville.

The call came in around 12:45 p.m. from Michels, located at 817 Main Street (near Prospect Avenue).

The man died at the scene.

An investigation has revealed officials with a sub-contractor of Michels Corporation (All Tools, LLC of Fond du Lac) were cleaning pipes when one of the pipes fell off a jack and slid into the victim — causing fatal injuries.

The name of the victim is being withheld pending notification of family members.

Michels Corporation and All Tools, LLC will be working closely to cooperate with OSHA officials in further investigation of the incident.

THE DANGEROUS ATV TAKE SO MANY YOUNG LIVES







OSHA issues fact sheet on farm workers and ATVs







Washington, DC – A new resource from OSHA explains how employers can help protect agricultural workers who operate all-terrain vehicles.

The fact sheet details why ATVs can be dangerous, how employers should train operators and what personal protective equipment they should provide. It states that employers should train workers to perform safety checks before and after rides, consider load and weight limitations, and know how to safely cross roads and work solo.

Agricultural workers use the vehicles to perform activities such as pulling trailers, hauling loads and rounding up livestock.

According to the fact sheet, NIOSH found that 2,090 injuries and 321 fatalities related to ATVs occurred between 2003 and 2011 – with 3 out of 5 workplace deaths occurring in agriculture.

The fact sheet states that employers should train operators to do the following:

  • Before starting the ATV, put it in neutral or park.
  • Drive at a speed appropriate for the terrain and visibility.
  • Do not speed.
  • Keep alert around hazards such as holes, stumps and fences.
  • Operate the ATV in accordance with the owner’s manual. Do not attempt wheelies or other stunts.
  • Stay alert when approaching hills, turns and other obstacles.
===========================

Oregon OSHA Posts ATV Safety Fact Sheet

Paved roads, excessive speed, steep slopes, and carrying passengers and unstable loads are the chief risks and hazards for ATV riders, the sheet explains.
 



Oregon OSHA recently posted a fact sheet about all-terrain vehicles, explaining Oregon's three ATV classifications, listing the industries from which accepted disabling claims involving ATVs in Oregon originated in 2009-2013, and offering guidance on hazards, PPE, training, and state laws. Anyone younger than 18 who rides an ATV on public lands must wear an approved motorcycle helmet with the chinstrap fastened, for example, except when the ATV is being used exclusively in farming, agriculture, forestry, or nursery or Christmas tree growing operations; the ATV is being used on land owned or leased by the vehicle's owner; or the ATV is a street-legal Class II vehicle registered in Oregon.



The fact sheet shows that more than half of the accepted disabling claims -- 59 out of 110 during the five-year period -- came from the agriculture, forestry, and fishing industries in Oregon. Another 17 came from local and state governments. Only two came from the construction industry, both in 2010.

Paved roads, excessive speed, steep slopes, and carrying passengers and unstable loads are the chief risks and hazards for ATV riders, the sheet explains.


Riding risks and hazards of ATV

 
Paved roads.
ATVs can be difficult to control on paved roads, even at slow speeds. They
are also a hazard for other motorists who pass them on highways.


Rough terrain and excessive speed.
ATVs make it easier to reach remote locations, but drivers need to be aware of rocks, logs, ditches, equipment, and other obstacles. Driving too fast limits reaction time and increases the risk of overturning the ATV or striking and unmarked object.


Steep slopes.
ATVs are easy to overturn, especially on steep slopes. Inexperienced
drivers tend to overestimate an ATV’s stability on such terrain. Traveling across slopes on three-wheeled vehicles is particularly dangerous
.
Passengers and unstable loads.
Most ATVs are not designed to carry passengers; an extra rider does not have a secure place to stand or sit and makes the vehicle unstable. Improperly secured cargo also affects an ATV’s stability.


================

Deceptively Dangerous: Why ATVs keep killing






Deadly thrills: An all-terrain vehicle rider heads up a hill at the Oregon Dunes National Recreation Area near the spot where Justin Miller, a 23-year-old from Yelm, Wash., died last July when he crashed his ATV. Though an experienced rider, Miller ended up beneath the machine and suffocated.
The final weekend in March dawned gray and damp across much of the country -- but eager riders pulled out their all-terrain vehicles anyway and hit the springtime trails. 

Soon the ambulances rolled, too. 

In North Carolina, an ATV overturned and crushed an 18-year-old woman to death. A collision with a truck killed two ATV riders in Centertown, Ky. Two girls, ages 4 and 7, died in separate ATV wrecks in eastern Texas. And two infants -- a 14-month-old in South Carolina and an 8-month-old in Perris, Calif. -- died in two more ATV crashes.

In Oregon that weekend, Debby Schubert, 45, and Donnie Moody, 31, became the state's first ATV fatalities this year when their machine tumbled into a dry canal east of Redmond.


Nine dead, including four children. Another bloody weekend in ATV country, where the quest for thrills and family fun can turn to grief in one terrifying moment.


Nearly 20 years ago, the federal government declared ATVs an "imminent hazard" and forced manufacturers to drop unstable three-wheel models in favor of the four-wheelers sold today. Regulators also compelled the ATV industry to adopt safety warnings and offer rider training to stem the accidents.

Since then, federal officials have done little more than tally the dead, and the failure of their approach can be seen in the grim body counts from Oregon to West Virginia.


The rate of injuries per ATV has barely budged from where it stood in the years after the government acted in 1988. Though death rates initially plummeted as three-wheelers disappeared, there's been scant improvement since.

Over the past decade, the machines have soared in popularity, with 7.6 million in use. The result: Record numbers of riders end up in emergency rooms and morgues as accidents kill about 800 people a year and injure an estimated 136,700.

"This is one of the worst examples ever of a government agency failing in its fundamental mission to protect the American public," Stuart M. Statler, a former U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission member, said of the agency's inability to significantly reduce ATV deaths and injuries during the past two decades.


Statler never imagined, when he helped lead the crackdown on ATVs in the 1980s, that deaths might someday surpass 1,000. Now, nearly 8,000 people have died in ATV crashes since the commission began counting, and 2 million have been seriously hurt.


A quarter of the dead and nearly a third of the injured are children. In Oregon, at least 82 people have died on ATVs since 2000, including 22 younger than 16. Serious ATV injuries in the state have increased at almost double the national rate in recent years.


Safety risks haven't dented the allure of ATVs. Over the past decade, sales tripled to $5 billion a year as companies introduced bigger, faster models. Though companies have added new features such as four-wheel drive and power steering, they haven't eliminated a long-standing problem: overturns.

The machines flip over with punishing regularity -- smashing faces, breaking necks, crushing chests.

The major manufacturers -- Honda, Polaris, Yamaha, Kawasaki, Suzuki, Bombardier and Arctic Cat -- insist their machines are safe and stable if operated properly. They fault riders for accidents.

"The safety issue is with the appropriate use," William Willen, a lawyer for ATV market leader Honda, told The Oregonian. "It's how people use the machines."

Honda's safety slogan sums it up: "Stupid Hurts."


But reckless riders are only part of the problem. The federal government has not extensively tested ATV stability since at least 1991. An engineering firm hired by The Oregonian tested the stability of four popular ATV models and concluded they were dangerously prone to overturns.

The newspaper also analyzed fatal crashes and reached a surprising finding: Overturns were as common among riders who appeared to be obeying basic safety warnings as among those who didn't.


Together, the results point to the role that ATV design plays in many crashes, yet regulators have largely ignored it. Meanwhile, abundant evidence shows that riders don't follow the warnings and decline free training programs, the key tenets of the government and industry approach to safety.


If only irresponsible or inexperienced riders were getting killed on ATVs, the roster of the dead might look different. Last month, a Ripon, Calif., cop and a biologist studying turtles at the Padre Island National Seashore in Texas perished in on-the-job ATV crashes.


The costs associated with ATV accidents aren't borne by victims alone. Taxpayers and employers pick up about $3 billion a year in medical expenses through government and private insurance, the consumer agency has estimated.


For parents who've lost children, the dollars pale next to the price in sorrow.

Last Mother's Day, 17-year-old Crane Mattox, an experienced rider, took his ATV out for an evening spin in the Blue Mountains near his home in Dayton, Wash. As Mattox rode up a slope, the machine flipped over backward. Searchers went out when Mattox didn't return. A cousin found him the next morning, dead under the ATV.


"If you're going to ride these things, you need to know the risks," said Mattox's mother, Dana Martin. "And the risks are death and losing your child."


The riders
On a chilly weekend last August, thousands of ATV riders flocked to the south coast near Reedsport for DuneFest, the wildest ATV party of the year at the Oregon Dunes National Recreation Area.

Riders roared by at 60 mph, doing doughnuts and jumping over huge dunes that can soar hundreds of feet. Dozens lined up to challenge Banshee Hill, one of the biggest and steepest inclines. A man with no helmet crested the summit pulling a wheelie -- a preschooler clutching the ATV's handlebars in front.

Nearby stood a small wooden cross, where three weeks earlier a passer-by found 23-year-old Justin Miller. An expert rider from Yelm, Wash., Miller wrecked his Yamaha Raptor and suffocated under the 400-pound machine.

Since the first ATV casualty reports long ago, manufacturers have deflected questions about the design and safety of their product by pointing to reckless behavior by their customers.

Places such as the dunes, the epicenter of Northwest ATV culture, help explain why the industry's emphasis on rider responsibility and the government's reliance on warning labels haven't worked.

Few rules apply at the dunes, and disregard for ATV safety warnings is widespread.


Riders go without helmets and carry passengers. They do jumps and stunts and ride over the roughest terrain. Some drink and drive. Children commonly race around on adult-sized machines. All are behaviors that ATV owner's manuals and the Consumer Product Safety Commission warn against.


Larry Runk, a retired Oregon State Police trooper who patrols the dunes for the U.S. Forest Service, has seen it all: airborne ATVs coming down on top of other riders; adults zooming by with babies on the seat behind them; a preschooler, leg broken in a crash, sobbing as medical crews hauled away his dead father.

"If I could write a ticket for stupid," Runk said, "I'd run out of pens and paper."

Matt Gerber, a veteran rider of both ATVs and motocross bikes from Milwaukie, counts himself in the slice of the country's 16 million enthusiasts who see ATVs as a family activity and try to stick to the rules. Many invest tens of thousands of dollars in ATVs for parents and kids, not counting safety gear, trailers and other trappings of the sport.


Gerber, 37, is a stickler for safety. He limits his 11-year-old daughter to riding her youth ATV, "and I'll never let her out of my sight." But after 22 years of off-road riding, he acknowledges there's another reality.


"For at least half the riders or more, it's just an adrenaline junkie thing," he said. "It's people who want to just go at breakneck speed."


Accidents aren't limited to public recreational areas like the dunes. A growing number involve riders taking ATVs on paved roads, where traffic increases odds of a collision. Millions use them for ranching, hunting and family outings on private trails, and the casualties hit riders of all ages and experience levels.

In some cases, riders seem to be doing only what their ATV's name says: driving on all terrain.


Arnold "Leroy" Thompson, 67, of Seaside appeared to be following all the rules last October, when he and his son went out on the Thin Wolf Trail in the Tillamook State Forest. Though experienced on ATVs, Thompson was relatively new to the Arctic Cat he drove. He couldn't work up much speed on the narrow, switchback trail.


Nevertheless, the back end of Thompson's ATV pitched forward as he rode down a hill. Tony Thompson, 25, found his father lying on the ground "folded like an accordion." He was conscious but had trouble breathing and couldn't move his legs. Thompson told his son the accident happened without warning.

Minutes later, he died.


The rollovers
Federal records show that more than half of those who die on ATVs perish in crashes where the machines roll over sideways or flip forward or backward. In some cases, overturns happen after the ATV hits something or tumbles off a steep drop.

But about a third of the time, the government data show, rollovers are the first known event in a fatal crash. And as ATV companies make heavier machines, overturns pose an increasing danger. The Arctic Cat 500 that crushed Thompson, for example, is among the heavier ATVs made -- more than 600 pounds.


ATV companies are quick to point to the large number of crashes in which riders ignore warnings. That is true more than 80 percent of the time in the government's database of fatal crashes, The Oregonian's analysis found.

The warnings are posted right on the ATVs and state clearly what riders shouldn't do: drink and drive, ride without a helmet, carry a passenger or operate an adult machine if under 16. Labels also warn against riding on public roads, where traffic is a hazard, or on pavement, because ATV tires are for off-road surfaces.


But failure to comply with warnings doesn't always explain rollovers, The Oregonian found.


Working with the Consumer Product Safety Commission's crash data, the newspaper examined 2,732 fatal accidents involving four-wheel ATVs since 2000 and separated the cases into two groups: the large group of riders who ignored at least one safety warning, and the much smaller group of riders who didn't.

The newspaper then looked to see how often overturns were the primary event in the crash.


The unexpected result: Riders who followed the warnings overturned in about two out of five cases, a rate comparable to the frequency of rollovers in the group that ignored one or more warnings.


The comparison doesn't suggest that riders should ignore safety warnings. The analysis also showed, for example, that overturns are more likely in crashes where an adult-sized ATV is driven by a child under 16.

A lawyer for the industry's trade group, the Specialty Vehicle Institute of America, called The Oregonian's analysis "fatally flawed," saying the industry's research over the years shows the benefits of following warnings.

The persistence of rollovers among riders who followed the basic precautions shows why engineers and safety advocates have long pointed to another factor: ATV design.

ATVs have a narrow track width and high ground clearance, necessary qualities that allow them to travel on rough territory and narrow trails. The same qualities make them far less stable than cars or SUVs.


Under pressure about rollovers, the ATV companies in 1988 signed agreements with the Consumer Product Safety Commission pledging not to build four-wheel ATVs with less sideways stability than those they sold at the time. Since 1991, the commission hasn't performed tests to check whether the companies kept their pledge.


To find out, the newspaper hired engineer Thomas R. Fries of Portland to measure the stability of four popular models. Fries has been a plaintiff's expert in ATV lawsuits and has done defense work in other vehicle crash cases.

Fries followed industry and Consumer Product Safety Commission methods. He first measured front and back stability -- called pitch stability -- and found that all four machines met the current, industry-adopted standard.

But Fries said the government's test method overstates stability by 10 percent to 15 percent.


To get a more realistic result, he performed a different test. ATVs were placed on a table and tilted sideways to discover their tip angle -- the point at which their upper wheels lift off the surface. The tilt table method is better, Fries said, because it accounts for the way an ATV's suspension and tires behave.

On the tilt table test, all of the machines came in below a stability threshold Fries considered safe.

"They're dangerous," Fries said. "They are too prone to tipping over."

Fries said that small changes in ATV design -- such as widening the track width by a couple of inches and lowering the rider seating position -- would significantly increase stability. His report can be read online at www.oregonlive.com.

The ATV manufacturers don't dispute that their machines can roll or flip. Instead, they argue that ATVs are a special breed of vehicle they describe as "rider-active." In other words, it's up to drivers to keep the ATV upright by shifting their body weight from side to side or front to back.

That's why the consumer product agency warns so strongly that children younger than 16 should stay off adult-sized machines: They lack the size, strength and judgment to control a big ATV.

Overturns showed up often among 69 Oregon and Washington ATV deaths that The Oregonian documented by gathering accident reports. The deaths, spanning the past 3½ years, include 18 crashes in which overturns appear to be the first event. Six of the overturns involved children younger than 16.


With their four fat tires, ATVs look stable. But their name is misleading. ATVs can't go on all terrain, and manufacturers explicitly warn against taking them on rough, steep or unfamiliar ground.


In its safety video, Polaris offers riders this advice if an overturn seems imminent: "Be prepared to dismount quickly if necessary."


The toll
Aryck Kalinsky didn't get the chance to bail out. It was another bad break in a life filled with them.
Raised in a troubled home, he spent his adolescence in foster care. But Kalinsky was a stubborn optimist and a hard worker. He loved his job at a local dog kennel. By the summer of 2004, the 16-year-old persuaded state officials to let him move into his own place in Rainier.


On Aug. 12, 2004, Kalinsky was a passenger on the kennel's ATV when it flipped forward and landed on him, severely damaging his lungs. He died after four days in the trauma unit at Oregon Health & Science University.

The price tag for Kalinsky's hospital care: about $120,000, paid for by the kennel owners, who had to borrow the money against their property.

Not everyone dies in ATV wrecks -- many more suffer grievous injuries: On average, 375 people are hospitalized each day, and the severity of ATV injuries often means enormous medical bills.

Taxpayers picked up nearly a quarter of the $50 million in hospital costs for 1,795 Oregon ATV trauma cases from 2000 through 2005. The cost does not include doctors' fees, rehabilitation or other follow-up care.

"We see so much of it," says Matt Danigelis, an emergency room doctor at Peace Harbor Hospital in Florence near the dunes, "you start to go a little numb."

State figures show that the number of ATV permits sold in Oregon doubled over six years, and so did the number of trauma cases, reaching 414 in 2005. That's twice the rate that injuries grew nationally in the same period.

The industry's trade group says the rising numbers of dead and injured simply reflect the fact that more ATVs are in use.


"Millions of Americans operate ATVs safely every day," said Tim Buche, executive director of the Specialty Vehicle Institute of America.

Instead, the group focuses on the rate of injury per 10,000 ATVs, arguing that it has declined since 2001. The group also says children younger than 16 make up a smaller portion of the injured -- 30 percent -- than a few years ago.

It is true that injury rates have shifted some since 2001, but according to the Consumer Product Safety Commission's latest report, the changes aren't significant enough to indicate a trend up or down.

Of the 136,700 people hurt seriously enough to be hospitalized in 2005, an estimated 40,400 were children. The commission said child injuries have increased 18 percent overall since 2001. The industry points to a 10 percent dip in child injuries last year, but the commission says that change wasn't statistically significant.

Fatality trends are harder to characterize because the consumer agency has used different counting methods over the years. But except for an upward spike in 1999, when the newest method took effect, the agency's estimated risk of death has fluctuated little.


The commission disagrees with the industry's emphasis on rates.

"Our commitment is to drive down not a rate of deaths and injuries," said commission spokesman Scott Wolfson, "but the numbers of actual lives and family members affected by incidents that are happening across the country."

The Oregonian sent written questions about safety and other matters to all the major ATV companies, and they chose to respond through the SVIA. The answers are online at www.oregonlive.com.

Some ATV enthusiasts say safety concerns are overblown.

In testimony before an Oregon legislative committee earlier this year, enthusiasts asserted that riding an ATV is no more dangerous than skiing, skateboarding or playing baseball.

Statistics suggest they're wrong.


Bicycling and some contact sports such as football and basketball do cause more injuries than ATVs. But ATV injuries are more severe. The consumer safety agency found that ATV riders had triple the hospitalization rate of people hurt on bicycles, four times that of skateboarders and more than seven times that of football players.

Hospital bills reflect the relative severity of injury. Since 1998, the cost of treating child ATV patients in Oregon averaged $23,039 per case -- 43 percent higher than for kids hurt on bicycles, trauma data show.

Dr. Richard Mullins, chief of trauma/critical care at OHSU, led a recent study that charted a sharp rise in off-road accident victims treated at the university. Two-thirds of the cases involved ATVs, with a quarter of the patients younger than 15.


What bothers Mullins is the way the industry markets faster and bigger machines for their thrills.


"I have a problem with making these things look fun," he said. "There's nothing fun about a brain injury, or a ruptured eyeball, or broken ribs."


The regulations
As ATV casualties hit new heights in recent years, trauma surgeons, pediatricians, public health officials, consumer advocates and bereaved parents all have clamored for action.

They have little to show for it.

For the first time since the 1980s, the Consumer Product Safety Commission is proposing new ATV safety rules. But the steps outlined by the agency largely preserve the status quo. One exception is a proposal to create a new class of faster ATVs for older teens, hoping to woo them from adult-sized models.

The rules do not propose a lateral stability standard or design changes to reduce rollovers.


Former commission officials and consumer advocates say the effect is to continue leaving the industry in charge of safety.


"There's this idea the watchdog government is there, and they protect us," said Leonard Goldstein, a longtime commission lawyer who worked extensively on ATV issues until retiring in 2005.

When it comes to ATVs, he said, the commission "has done essentially nothing except monitor deaths and injuries and study the problem for close to 10 years."


Last summer, the commission rejected a petition by the Consumer Federation of America and other groups to ban the sale of adult ATVs for use by children younger than 16 -- after deliberating nearly four years. The commission said such a ban would be unenforceable.


Commission officials say there are limits to their powers. Unlike states, the commission doesn't have the ability to regulate how consumers use a product. Under the law, the agency also must defer to industry safety standards before taking more aggressive action to ban a product or impose its own rules.

ATVs, officials say, pose a more complex problem than a single agency can solve.

"We want people to realize that everyone has a role to play in this," says Elizabeth Leland, who is leading the commission's review of ATV rules. "Parents are important, state and local governments are important, the industry is important, the federal government is important."


Last fall, the commission launched a safety Web site and public service ads that echo the industry emphasis on rider behavior. Asked then whether ATVs are designed as safely as possible, acting commission Chairwoman Nancy Nord told The Oregonian: "I believe the people who ride them need to take greater responsibility for their own safety."


The ATV industry argues that states are better suited to control how ATVs are used. But that has led to a grab bag of inconsistent state laws as enthusiasts and dealers fight restrictions on their right to ride.

In Oregon, four of five ATV safety bills introduced this legislative session appear dead after ATV rider groups overwhelmed safety advocates in a bitter political battle. The House defeated a mandatory helmet bill in March, and supporters have given up on a bill to ban riders younger than 12.

There was a time when Sue Baron would have marched alongside opponents of ATV laws.


But Baron, a longtime rider from Abbottsford, B.C., hasn't touched her ATV since the day two years ago when her 13-year-old son, Drew Dickson, died at the dunes near Florence.


An expert rider who had raced ATVs and dirt bikes, Drew was closely supervised and wore a helmet and chest plate. But friends found him at the bottom of a sand dune, pinned under his adult-sized ATV, his neck broken.

"Drew was wearing all the safety gear," his mother said. "It didn't make any difference."