MEC&F Expert Engineers

Thursday, June 15, 2017

Lead exclusion limited in toxic tort case: The Netherlands Insurance Co. and Peerless Insurance Co. are required to cover a lawsuit against the Butler Area School District surrounding lead-tainted drinking water that came from a well at Summit Elementary School.



Lead exclusion limited in toxic tort case, court rules


Rob Lenihan 6/13/2017 3:03:00 PM



Lead exclusions in a school district’s liability policies may not exclude losses resulting from a toxic tort class action class action that alleges the district should have known there were excessive levels of lead and copper in its water supply, a federal judge ruled June 9.

Ruling in The Netherlands Insurance Co., Peerless Insurance Co. v. The Butler Area School District, U.S. District Court Judge Arthur J. Schwab in Pittsburgh, ruled that the two units of Liberty Mutual Holding Co. Inc. must defend the Pennsylvania school district in the class action suit that alleges the district concealed dangerous levels of lead and copper in its water.

“The court will not countenance the insurers' invitation to turn Pennsylvania law relative to the duty to defend on its head so as to allow the potential exclusion of a single type of claim to relieve them of their duty to defend, when the law actually requires a defense when a single potentially covered claim is alleged,” Judge Schwab wrote in his ruling.

The school district installed a chlorinator prior to the 2016/2017 school year into the Summit Elementary School's potable water system and failed to operate it properly, according to court records.

As a result, the water system quickly corroded and resulted in a slow and continuous movement of dangerous levels of lead and copper into the school’s water system, court records say.

In January, the school district informed parents in a letter that students and staff at the elementary school had been told not to drink the water from a well on the property because it had been contaminated with lead. Attorneys suing the district in federal court in February said the administration knew of the problems in August last year.

Peerless issued a commercial umbrella insurance policy to the district, while Netherlands issued a commercial package policy. The policies had pollution exclusions and lead exclusions. The two insurers told the defendants in February that they would not participate in their defense or pay any amounts to satisfy any settlement achieved or judgment rendered in the litigation and later sought a declaration that they have no duty to defend or indemnify.

Judge Schwab’s ruling said the pollution exclusions were “ambiguous in the context of an alleged exposure to lead or copper in drinking water; and therefore, must be interpreted in favor of coverage.”

The lead exclusion, which excludes coverage for losses “arising, in whole or in part” from exposure to lead, do not exclude losses from exposure to copper, the ruling states.

“There are allegations of potential injury from copper that are not dependent on lead injury nor stem from lead injury. Copper is potentially a separate and distinct cause of injury,” Judge Schwab’s ruling states. “Liberty Mutual does not publicly comment on litigation," a spokesman said.

 =======================
BUTLER, PA

A federal judge has ruled that two insurance companies are required to cover any potential financial losses tied to a lawsuit against the Butler Area School District surrounding lead-tainted drinking water that came from a well at Summit Elementary School.

U.S. District Judge Arthur J. Schwab ruled that The Netherlands Insurance Co. and Peerless Insurance Co. can't shirk their coverage duties. Lawyers for both companies contended that they were not obligated to pay or defend the district or former Superintendent Dale Lumley, also a defendant.

“We are pleased with the decision and believe the court properly applied the law,” Butler Area School District solicitor Tom King said Monday.

A federal lawsuit filed in February against the school district contends Lumley and administrators concealed information for months that Summit Elementary's water supply from a well on school property contained dangerous amounts of lead. An executive summary of an internal investigation noted a possible cover-up or negligence in addressing and communicating the lead problem.

Three school district administrators, including Lumley, resigned during the scandal, and a criminal investigation is ongoing.

After the initial lawsuit, attorneys for the insurance carriers filed a separate action in federal court, arguing both companies are exempt from claims because their policies with the district did not cover lead exposure.

Schwab disagreed.

“The pollution exclusion at issue here is ambiguous.” he wrote.

Summit closed at the end of January because of the lead problem, and its approximately 250 students began attending the formerly shuttered Broad Street Elementary in Butler.

Jennifer Tait sued the district and Lumley after her daughter, Jillian, who attended Summit, tested positive for lead exposure. The case filed by attorneys Brendan Lupetin and Douglas Olcott seeks class-action status, which would let families of other students exposed to lead in the water join the lawsuit. The suit seeks medical monitoring and damages for anyone exposed to lead and copper in the water at Summit.

Lupetin said Monday he was pleased with Schwab's ruling regarding the insurance companies.

“Judge Schwab's decision on the ancillary insurance coverage dispute was the right decision and will hopefully pave the way for fair compensation for the affected students,” he said.

Philadelphia attorney John C. Sullivan, who represents both insurance companies, declined to comment.

Lead is a neurotoxin that can impair child brain development and cause kidney damage, mood disorders, weight loss and other ailments.

In April, the Butler Area School District finalized plans to bring public water to Summit Elementary with hopes of reopening the school by Sept. 1. 


=============





A third Butler Area School District administrator has resigned in the midst of an investigation involving lead-tainted water that forced closure of an elementary school.

Mary Wolf, assistant superintendent, resigned effective Monday night, the district's solicitor Tom King said.

Board members voted 6-3 to accept the resignation. Former superintendent Dale Lumley and maintenance director Glenn Terwilliger stepped down earlier this month.

King also released a summary of an internal investigation conducted by attorney Michael Witherel, that outlines possible misconduct among district employees including unauthorized access and removal of emails.

"The potential misconduct related to the employees' alleged failure to perform their respective job responsibilities; their alleged unauthorized access to the district's email system; their alleged unauthorized retrieval and removal of emails, including the emails of board members, legal counsel and others; and, their alleged making of false statements, under oath and during the investigation," the summary of Witherel's report said.

He was hired by the school board to investigate on Jan. 24.

The school district announced in a Jan. 20 letter to parents that students and staff at Summit Elementary School had been told not to drink the water from a well on the property because it was contaminated with lead. But the possible cover-up of the lead problems might date back to August.

A federal lawsuit against the school district contends that Lumley and administrators concealed information for months that Summit Elementary School's water supply contained dangerous amounts of lead.

Further testing last week found E. coli bacteria in the well that supplies the school, prompting the building to be closed indefinitely. Students at Summit are attending classes in the shuttered Broad Street School until the water issues are resolved.

The lawsuit, filed as a class-action complaint on behalf of all of the students, alleges the district and Lumley took no action to correct the water issue and didn't inform families. Their lack of action created "a school full of poisonous drinking water," the lawsuit contends.

"While we commend the district for conducting an internal review we are shocked to learn of the steps high-ranking Butler school officials took to cover up this disaster," Pittsburgh attorney Brendan Lupetin, the plaintiff's attorney, said Tuesday after reading the summary. "It is time to step up and make things right for the children that unwittingly suffered through all of this."

King declined further comment on the report, but said the board also voted to explore possibly serving Summit with public water in the fall. Summit was currently the only operating school with well water.

King told the Tribune-Review Tuesday that Wolf will use sick days and vacation through June 30, to remain on the payroll. She has been assistant superintendent since 2014.

The report indicated that separate investigations by the Butler County District Attorney's office and state Department of Environmental Protection are ongoing.

Wednesday, June 14, 2017

The cause of the barn fire in Jefferson Twp., Ohio was most likely lightning



UPDATE


JEFFERSON TWP., Ohio - Authorities say all of the livestock inside a Jefferson Township barn accounted for after the barn went up in flames Wednesday morning.

However, Fox 45 is told there was large farm equipment inside the barn and it is a total loss. While the cause of the fire is under investigation, firefighters say it was most likely caused by lightning. Firefighters say a neighbor heard thunder and saw a flash of lightning before the barn caught fire. 


=================
JEFFERSON TWP., Ohio (WKEF/WRGT) - A barn in the 8000 block of Hemple Road in Jefferson Township has been fully engulfed with fire.


Crews were called out shortly before 10:00 a.m. to the scene.


It's not clear what caused the fire at this point or if any animals were inside, but the smoke can be seen from quite a way off of the scene.

RODENTS EAT THE SOY-WIRES OF VEHICLES: car companies going green, turned to soy as an eco-friendly alternative to plastic for wrapping wires and car parts.








A furry little culprit is causing big problems for car manufactures and, possibly more importantly, for drivers whose vehicles are being destroyed.

Now lawsuits are popping up across the country claiming rodents are responsible, eating cars from the inside out. And it's likely not covered under your warranty.

Critics say soy-wire coverings now used in many new cars are also a tasty food source attracting rodents. They're chewing through wires, and costing car owners thousands of dollars.

Alice Clark, a rat enthusiast, says her cuddly little "pets" wouldn't hurt anyone, but what they could do to the insides of your car is a different tail.

"It's edible, rats will eat pretty much anything that's edible," Clark said.

Clark feeds her rats soy. And critics say as car companies are going green, they've also turned to soy as an eco-friendly alternative to plastic for wrapping wires and car parts.

Driver Sandy Medina doesn't know how long she had furry friends living under her hood.

"Driving around there could have been something underneath while I was driving it and who knows, maybe something would have popped out!" Medina said.

After owning her Toyota Forerunner for just three months, Medina says the first sign of trouble was when her engine light went on and she took it to her dealer.

"They told me, 'There's a nest in the car. Could be anything, could be rodents, could be squirrels, could be anything,'" Medina said.

She says mechanics told her these pests weren't just making her car their home, they were making it their meal.

"I don't even think that there was anything left. Everything was eaten," Medina said.

She fears it wasn't only bad for her car, it was a potential fire and safety hazard, too.

"I felt that my life was in danger," Medina said.

Attorney Brian Kabateck says, "It is a design defect which has effected a lot of people and has cost a lot of people a lot of money."

Kabateck has filed a class action lawsuit against Toyota, which is one of the manufacturers allegedly using a soy based compound for wire insulation.

"Rats think this is delicious," Kabateck said.

The lawsuit says the soy is "baiting rodents" and "enticing these pests to chew through... the wiring" which could "leave the vehicle partially or completely inoperable."

"It can be a life safety hazard, it can cause the car to stop in the middle of the highway, it can cause it to shut down, and it can cause serious problems," Kabateck said.

Kabatech says it's unknown how many manufacturers are using soy in their cars, but Toyota and Honda are two of the most prevalent.

He believes Toyota is using soy to cut costs, not necessarily to go green, and they are leaving car owners to pay for it.

"They ate $6,000 out of my pocket," Medina said.

While some insurance companies, like Medina's, will pay for repairs, the class action cases says Toyota won't cover it under their warranty. Medina says the wires in her truck were replaced with the exact same soy wire covers.

"They can't guarantee that it's not going to happen again," Medina said.

Mark Zickler of Terminex says, "Soy is a little bit sweeter than chewing on a petroleum product, obviously."

Zickler says there are things car owners can do. Honda has said that rodents chewing wiring has been a longstanding problem and they have seen no evidence that anything in their wiring is increasing rodents gnawing tendencies. Nonetheless, they have come out with a fix - spicy tape - that costs about $45.

"You wrap the wiring throughout your vehicle and it has a really super spicy flavoring in it that deters them from wanting to chew on it," Zickler said.

He also recommends owners move their cars, instead of leaving them in one place for long periods which makes them a more likely home, parking inside, and using traps and moth balls to deter rodents.

"They can come from anywhere and surprise you," Zickler said.

Medina, who is part of the class action lawsuit, just wants to warn other drivers and she wants manufactures to fix the problem, without passing the buck to consumers.

"Why wait until something catastrophic to occur, why can't you do something now?" Medina said.

In a statement to Action News Toyota said "rodent damage... occurs across the industry and is not brand or model specific. And they are "not aware of any scientific evidence that shows rodents are attracted to automotive wiring because of alleged soy bases content."

Honda tells us they believe the class action lawsuits have no merit.

STATEMENT FROM TOYOTA

Rodent damage to vehicle wiring occurs across the industry, and the issue is not brand- or model-specific. We are currently not aware of any scientific evidence that shows rodents are attracted to automotive wiring because of alleged soy-based content. Because these claims are the subject of current litigation, we cannot comment further.

STATEMENT FROM HONDA

It is a long established fact that rodents are drawn to chew on electrical wiring in homes, cars, or anywhere else where they may choose to nest.
Honda introduced a rodent-deterrent tape a few years ago to help combat this age-old issue for customers who live in areas where rodents have caused prior damage. Our attempt to provide some protection for our customers against this natural behavior should not lead to the assumption that Honda created the issue in the first place.

Further, Honda sources parts, including electrical wiring and wire harnesses, from several different suppliers who each have their own proprietary formula for wire insulation and wire harnesses. Honda has not received any confirmation from its various suppliers that the wiring insulation and harnesses used in Honda vehicles are soy-based, as the plaintiffs allege. Honda is not aware of studies or information indicating that any of the wiring insulation or other components used for Honda vehicles are derived from substances that attract rodents or increase their propensity to chew on wiring or other components in engine compartments. It is Honda's understanding that rodents may seek shelter in engine components and once inside, can cause damage as a natural result of their need to chew and use material that has been chewed for nesting. Honda is not aware of any information suggesting rodents use wire insulation as a food source.

Class action lawsuits have been filed against a number of auto manufacturers alleging that vehicles contain soy-based wiring insulation and that such insulations attracts rodents to chew on the insulation. Honda believes that the class actions filed against it have no merit.


=============

Rats! New Cars' Soy-Coated Wires Give Rodents Plenty To Chew On

 
20170210_143416
San Diego resident JoAnn Kozakowski-Koch uses coyote urine purchased from Home Depot to stop rats from chewing on wires the  engine compartment of her 2016 Volvo XC60.Photo Credit: T. Koch.
JoAnn Kozakowski-Koch loves her 2016 Volvo XC60.

Trouble is, so do the rats in her neighborhood.  They're chewing through wires in her engine compartment, causing hundreds of dollars in damages.
JoAnn and her husband Tracy live in Santee, Calif., just east of San Diego. Recently retired, they enjoy the open road, exploring new places.  The first clue that something was wrong came last October. "I had just taken the car in for the 10,000-mile check at the Escondido dealership," JoAnn said, "when I got an alert about the tires." 

At first, they thought the tire pressure alert might have something to do with their recent road trip to the Grand Canyon. The tires were just fine, it turns out. "The guys at the dealership had a look and told me that rodents had done some wire damage." JoAnn paid $400 for repairs and figured she'd left her Volvo in an unlucky place at the Grand Canyon National Park.

But JoAnn's duel with rats was just starting. Several days later she got an alert that her water coolant was low. Hmmm, strange. She checked under the hood and, to her dismay,  she saw freshly chewed wires. JoAnn read on the internet that peppermint worked as a rodent repellent so she spread some on the driveway.

One afternoon, she decided to check on the wiring. Any fresh damage?  Easing the hood up, she laid eyes on a portly rat crouched on top of the engine block. She slammed the hood and ran back into the house yelling for her husband.
Tracy came out, looked inside and assured JoAnn that the rat was gone. But he also saw that the wires looked more chewed up.  This time, they took the XC 60 to a different Volvo dealership in San Diego. The service guys confirmed what JoAnn already knew: Rodents had chewed through wiring. That set her back another $200.

Since the second visit, JoAnn and Tracy have upped their game. Tracy set out some traps and has caught one rat.

Meantime, JoAnn conducted an exhaustive Google search and discovered a new rat repellent: Coyote urine.  She bought a supply of the Coyote formula from Home Depot for $24 -- plus shipping.

20170210_144105
Every evening, Ms. Kozakowski-Koch places a sponge soaked in coyote urine on a tin vessel near her front tires. Photo Credit: T. Koch.

Every night, Joann's pours a little coyote piss around her tires. "I dot my driveway with some too," she says. She also places a  Coyote urine-soaked sponge inside a tin pan near the car. She's not sure it's working yet and does not want to take her car in for any more repairs until she's rid of the rats once and for all.

Meantime,  the couple noticed something else strange: Their other car in the driveway, an older Toyota MR2, seemed to be immune from the rat attacks. Why was her Volvo getting all the attention?
She called the Volvo service hot line. After some back and forth with the customer service representative, JoAnn unearthed a missing piece of the puzzle:  Some Volvo components are apparently coated with materials derived from soy.  Aha!
Some newer model cars use materials like soy that are more biodegradable than plastics. It's all part of an effort to make car parts more environmentally-friendly. A Volvo service representative at a Volvo dealer in Michigan confirmed some instances of chewed wires, though they "mostly occurred in rural areas -- not cities." A Volvo spokesperson said that an "initial investigation [into the subject] did not return any substantive info."  
But JoAnn's experience with her Volvo does not appear to be an isolated case. Honda, Toyota and other automakers seem to be experiencing chewed up wires, too.
Friends of mine experienced a setback with their recently purchased 2014 Mazda 5. One weekend, they parked at a campground in San Diego a few miles from the ocean. During the Sunday return drive, the car got stuck in second gear and would run no faster than 30 miles per hour. They had to get off the highway and take side streets home.
Service advisors at their dealership confirmed that chewed wires had caused the automatic transmission to lock into second gear. The entire wiring harness had to be replaced. Their newly-obtained Mazda had a 30-day warranty so the dealership agreed, "with great reluctance", to cover the $1,200 in repairs.
Some Toyota and Honda owners say they have shelled out thousands of dollars to replace wiring. In September, 2016, a class-action suit was filed against Toyota for vehicles produced between 2012 and 2016 that used soy-coated wiring. Honda was also slapped with a class-action suit earlier in 2016 for vehicles produced between 2012 and 2015. The common denominator appears to be soy.

Alas, no green deed goes unpunished.

Are the rat turf wars enough to spoil JoAnn's feeling for her Volvo? No -- at least not yet. "My husband and I do lots of road trips. I love the way the 4 wheel-drive works. It feels like the tires are bolted right to the road."
Now if only Volvo could find a way to bolt the rats at a safe distance from the soy, JoAnn's life would be perfect.

Former Linden, New Jersey police officer Pedro Abad received a sentence of 8 1/3 to 25 years in prison Wednesday for driving drunk and speeding in a wrong-way crash that killed a fellow officer and another man.



A former New Jersey police officer received a sentence of 8 1/3 to 25 years in prison Wednesday for driving drunk in a wrong-way crash that killed a fellow officer and another man.

Pedro Abad worked for the Linden Police Department in 2015 when he crashed into a tractor-trailer after a night at a Staten Island strip club with friends.

"This sentence ensures Mr. Abad is held accountable for the lives he destroyed when he decided to get behind the wheel and drive drunk," District Attorney Michael McMahon said. "My thoughts and prayers remain with the families and friends of all the victims affected by this tragedy."

Abad veered onto the other side of the West Shore Expressway and hit an oncoming truck just after 4:30 a.m., killing fellow Linden officer Frank Viggiano and Linden resident Joseph Rodriguez. Another officer in the car, Patrick Kudlac, was seriously injured.

Abad was convicted in May of aggravated vehicular homicide, aggravated vehicular assault, manslaughter and other charges.

He spoke before the court, apologizing and admitting he should not have gotten in the vehicle. He requested a minimum sentence of a year behind bars, but the judge showed no mercy, sentencing him to the maximum.

"You have no idea of the magnitude of what you did," Judge Mario Mattei told Abad. "You weren't an accident waiting to happen. You were a time bomb waiting to explode."

Prosecutors said Abad was intoxicated and driving 73 miles per hour when he plowed head-on into the truck.

Rodriguez's father would not refer to Abad by name during the trial, but did so after sentencing.

"To Pedro: You took the most precious thing from a parent - you took my precious little boy from me," he said.

Kudlac testified against Abad during the trial, describing the rounds of drinks, the whiskey shots and the strip club. He was asleep in the back seat seconds before the crash.

Earlier that evening, Abad and Kudlac had gone to Central Park, a bar and restaurant in New Jersey, and drank whiskey before joining up with Rodriguez and Viggiano. From there, the group drove to Curves gentleman's club on Staten Island, arriving at 2:21 a.m.

Credit card receipts from that evening showed Abad had purchased numerous alcoholic beverages for himself and others throughout the night. A blood sample revealed Abad had a blood-alcohol content of .24 -- three times the legal limit -- following the crash. A paramedic who treated Abad on scene also testified that he had a very strong odor of alcohol.

Abad had two drunken-driving arrests before the fatal crash: one from a 2011 accident in Roselle, New Jersey, after he allegedly drove through the wall of a convenience store; the other in 2013 after he struck a parked car in Rahway, New Jersey. The 2011 charge was later dismissed.  Corrupt judges and prosecutors are to blame for that.

GOING POSTAL IN SAN FRANCISCO: Mentally-ill United Parcel Service (UPS) worker Jimmy Lam shoots and kills 3, self at the UPS facility in San Francisco’s Potrero Hill neighborhood













SAN FRANCISCO — The day after UPS driver Michael Lefiti was gunned down in a deadly workplace shooting, a makeshift memorial of flowers, plants, teddy bears and balloons had cropped up along his daily delivery route in San Francisco’s Diamond

Heights neighborhood.

Lefiti, 46, of Hercules, known as “Big Mike,” was among three UPS staffers killed Wednesday morning after police said suspect Jimmy Lam, 38, opened fire and then shot and killed himself. San Francisco residents Wayne Chan, 56, and Benson Louie, 50, also died. Two others were also injured from the gun shots, and five others suffered minor injuries trying to get out of the building during the panic.

Lefiti worked at the UPS warehouse and customer service center in San Francisco, near 17th Street and San Bruno Avenue in the Potrero Hill neighborhood.

He was a father of five who worked for UPS for 17 years, as did Louie, while Chan had 28 years of service, according to UPS spokeswoman Susan Rosenberg.

“None of us has words to explain why a person of such kindness and warmth could have been targeted in this way,” read a message at the Diamond Heights shopping center memorial, with photos of Lefiti. “Big Mike was large in size. But his laughter, concern for others and dedication to those he loved were all much, much larger. Larger than life. And unforgettable.” People gather at the Diamond Heights shopping center in San Francisco to mourn their UPS man, “Big” Mike Lefiti, who was one of the victims in the gun rampage at the United Parcel Service building in San Francisco, California, Wednesday, June 14, 2017. (Karl Mondon/Bay Area News Group)

Nelson Barry, who owns a law office on Lefiti’s delivery route in the Diamond Heights neighborhood, said the memorial for the beloved UPS driver started because Lefiti was such a beloved figure among his customers.

“He was always upbeat and never, ever complained about anything,” Barry said of Lefiti.

Lefiti’s family could not be reached for comment.

“Mikey” was well-known around Diamond Heights because he’d had his delivery route for many years, Barry said. Hard-working, warm, personable and kind, Lefiti would always greet people by name, with a big, deep voice in a friendly, caring way, and ask about them and their families.


He would talk about his family and how they were growing, and what they were doing or going to do, Barry recalled.

He would joke about his kids and “how they were eating him out of house and home,” and about how he had to lose weight, “and I would say, yeah, me too,” Barry said.

“He was a gentle giant,” Barry said. “He was really compassionate and cared about injustice whenever he saw it. … No one will ever fill the hole that he filled.”

Rebecca Kim, who owns Diamond Cleaners in the area, said “Mikey” had been delivering packages for all of the 15 to 16 years she’d had her business in the area.

“He knew every person’s name, he knew their children’s name and their pets’ name, and he was always joking and smiling…,” she said. “I can’t believe he’s gone.”

He also was the type of person who would always go above and beyond in his job, offering to help out and cheering up others, she said.

“He would be having lunch and he’d say, ‘Are you hungry? Can I get you lunch?'” she recalled.

“All these people are just grieving because they loved the guy. He was really sweet.”

San Francisco police have not released any information about the suspect, San Francisco resident Jimmy Lam. A union official said Wednesday that Lam had filed a grievance complaining that he was working excessive overtime.

Joseph Cilia, with a local Teamsters Union, said Lam’s grievance filed in March requested that UPS relieve him from working overtime going forward.

Still, Cilia said, Lam wasn’t angry, and he could not understand why he would open fire on his colleagues at a morning meeting Wednesday.

Cilia said the two other drivers who were wounded have been released from the hospital and will be OK.

Reached late Thursday evening, Rosenberg said the company wanted to offer its thanks to community members in the tragedy’s wake.

“From the neighbors in the area to the church across the street, they were incredible to provide support services,” Rosenberg said. “Even the pastor of the church making it a safe haven for employees during the police investigation yesterday, it’s just been a tremendous outpouring of support.”

Rosenberg said worker resilience and shifts from workers at other nearby facilities would allow the company to catch up quickly. “One amazing thing is how they’ve pulled together. Today they were back providing service, consoling each another.”



============================

SAN FRANCISCO (CBS SF/AP) — Four people including the gunman were dead and two others wounded in a shooting involving UPS employees at the company’s facility in San Francisco’s Potrero Hill neighborhood Wednesday morning, police said.

San Francisco Assistant Police Chief Toney Chaplin said that the shooter, a UPS employee in uniform, was among the dead. When police found him, he was still armed with an “assault pistol” which he then put to his head and killed himself, Chaplin said.

Police sources told KPIX 5 the employee was identified as Jimmy Lam.
The shooting was reported around 9 a.m. at the packaging and sorting facility at 320 San Bruno Ave.

Chaplin said investigators haven’t determined a motive for the shooting and that there was no evidence that terrorism played a role.

UPS spokesman Steve Gaut said the unidentified employee opened fire inside the facility before the drivers were sent out to do their normal daily deliveries.
The wife of one of the survivors told KPIX 5 that her husband said the gunman broke into the workers safety meeting and shot three employees “execution-style.”

“My husband called and was in distress,” she told KPIX 5. “So I only got pieces. He just wanted to let me he was okay. He said someone started shooting execution style and he just started running.”

Chopper 5 over a shooting at the UPS facility in San Francisco on June 14, 2017. (CBS)
Chopper 5 over a shooting at the UPS facility in San Francisco on June 14, 2017. (CBS)

San Francisco police tweeted at 10:33 a.m. that the building had been secured. Special operations officers were continuing to search the building for more possible victims.

Nearby, auto shop owner Robert Kim said he heard about five to eight rapid gunshots. The next thing he knew, he said, “there’s a mob of UPS drivers” running down the street screaming “shooter, shooter.”

The San Francisco Office of Emergency Services said 911 calls began coming in around 9 a.m. of an active shooter at the massive facility.

Gaut said that the employee opened fire inside the facility before the drivers were sent out to do their normal daily deliveries.

San Francisco Mayor Ed Lee issued a statement thanking “our brave officers of the San Francisco Police Department, and our dedicated employees at 911 and San Francisco General Hospital.” He added:
I also want to offer my condolences and thoughts for the individuals and families affected by the senseless act of violence at the UPS facility. We all know the familiar faces of our local UPS drivers and delivery persons. Today’s tragedy will be felt in every community served by these committed employees.

U.S. Senator and former San Francisco Mayor Dianne Feinstein issued a statement recalling another mass shooting in San Francisco years ago:
I was heartbroken to learn that yet another senseless act of gun violence has marred our wonderful City. My heart goes out to the victims and their families, and to everyone affected by this despicable act.
I can’t help but recall the 101 California Street shooting in 1993, when eight people lost their lives. Violence is never the answer, but the continuing scourge of gun violence is particularly disheartening.
As we learn more details of this shooting, I’m hopeful that we can take away lessons to help prevent these acts from occurring in the future. We must do more to address the underlying roots of these tragic events.
California Gov. Jerry Brown tweeted: “Our thoughts & prayers with everyone impacted by senseless violence today in SF & Alexandria.”
The shooting came the same day a gunman opened fire on Republican lawmakers at a congressional baseball practice in Alexandria, Virginia wounding U.S. Rep. Steve Scalise of Louisiana and several others

============



San Francisco UPS facility shooting: 4 dead including gunman, police say


By Katherine Lam Published June 14, 2017
Fox News


Multiple injuries in workplace shooting in San Francisco

A UPS employee opened fire in a San Francisco package delivery facility in a shooting spree that left four dead, including the gunman, on Wednesday, police and the company said.

The gunman barged into the facility near 17th and Vermont streets around 9 a.m. local time and began shooting, San Francisco police confirmed to Fox News. The building is located in the Potrero Hill, which is about 2 1/2 miles from downtown San Francisco.

Two other people remain hospitalized. The gunman died of a self-inflicted wound, police said.


Police identified San Francisco resident Jimmy Lam as the shooter, according to NBC Bay Area. Lam has a history of mental illness, sources said. He was dressed in a UPS uniform at the time of the shooting, police said. UPS spokesman Steve Gaut confirmed the gunman was an employee at the facility.

The motive of the shooting is still unclear, police said, adding that they believe the incident was not terror-related. The FBI was aware of the shooting but did not intervene, the bureau told Fox News.

The shooting led to a massive police response, initiating a shelter-in-place for the surrounding area. The warning was lifted nearly three hours later after the incident was "contained" and the building was "secured," police said.


A woman who said she was an employee at the facility told KTVU that the gunman opened fire on the main sorting floor.

Auto shop owner Robert Kim said he heard about five to eight rapid gunshots. Just moments later, "there's a mob of UPS drivers" running down the street screaming "shooter, shooter," Kim said. Another witness said a group of about 10 workers assembled on the roof and held their hands up as police began to arrive.


A UPS spokesman said in an earlier statement to Fox News that there was an "incident involving employees" at the facility.

"Local law enforcement have control of the facility and are conducting an investigation. The company is cooperating with law enforcement. We cannot provide information as to the identity of persons involved at this time, pending the police investigation," the statement read.

"The company is saddened and deeply concerned about affected employees, family members and the community we share."

San Francisco Mayor Ed Lee offered his condolences and said he was "always saddened by the loss of life to gun violence."