MEC&F Expert Engineers

Wednesday, May 20, 2015

Cost Overruns do not Matter, the Taxpayers will be forced to pay anyway: New Supercarrier Is Super Over-Budget

Gerald R. Ford (CVN-78) float out at Huntington Ingalls shipyard in November 2013. Photo by Chris Oxley
Gerald R. Ford (CVN-78) float out at Huntington Ingalls shipyard in November 2013. Photo by Chris Oxley

By Tony Capaccio
(Bloomberg) — The second aircraft carrier in the Navy’s new Gerald R. Ford class is now estimated to exceed a cap imposed by Congress by at least $370 million, according to the Pentagon’s independent cost office.

The working estimate for the USS John F. Kennedy is about $11.868 billion as of late last month, which would violate the congressionally mandated cap of $11.498 billion, according to data reviewed by Bloomberg News. The estimate isn’t final because the office is awaiting additional Navy information to verify the costs of research and military construction.

The latest estimate will invite more scrutiny from lawmakers of the increasing costs and delays in the Navy’s $42.8 billion program for three carriers being built by Huntington Ingalls Industries Inc. The Senate Armed Services Committee’s version of the annual defense authorization bill would direct the Government Accountability Office to review the Navy’s history of cost estimates for the ships.

“Accountability must be restored to the Ford-class aircraft carrier program,” Republican Senator John McCain of Arizona, the committee’s chairman, said in an e-mailed statement in response to the new cost estimate. “Our nation simply cannot afford these kinds of cost overruns amid rising global threats and fiscal challenges.”

Paying for Increase

McCain, who has long complained about runaway weapons costs, called on the Pentagon to identify “who is responsible for this cost overrun and what will be done to hold those individuals accountable.”

The Navy would have to pay for the increase, either by reducing some of the Kennedy’s planned capabilities or requesting that Congress increase the cap lawmakers imposed to contain costs, according to information presented at an April 28 Pentagon meeting.

Frank Kendall, the Defense Department’s chief weapons buyer, is weighing the Cost Assessment and Program Evaluation office’s new estimate that the carrier will cost 3.2 percent more than the congressional cap as part of a decision on approving a construction contract for the Kennedy valued at as much as $4 billion.

Maureen Schumann, Kendall’s spokeswoman, declined in an e- mail to discuss any aspect of his pending decision, including the cost estimate.

Beci Brenton, a spokeswoman for Newport News, Virginia- based Huntington Ingalls, said in an e-mail that the company expects a contract by June 30.

Construction, Engineering

The cost office estimates that the Navy will spend at least $7.788 billion on construction, including engineering and production labor and changes. The Navy’s estimate, completed last month, is $7.542 billion for that work.

Remaining expenses bringing the projected cost to $11.868 billion include equipment such as the catapult and arresting system and radar, which are supplied by the government through contractors other than Huntington.

The new estimate is a setback for the Navy, which undertook an intensive effort to reduce cost estimates for the second carrier after the first one, the Gerald R. Ford, increased 22 percent since 2010 to about $12.88 billion. It’s set for delivery in March 2016.

In an effort to put more pressure on the Navy to keep costs under control, the Senate panel last week directed in its authorization bill, S. 1118, that the cap be lowered by an additional $100 million. The version of the annual policy bill the House passed last week, H.R. 1735, doesn’t include a tighter cap for the Kennedy, or CVN-79, which is the Navy’s designation for a nuclear-powered aircraft carrier.

“We do not discuss pending legislation, however controlling and improving CVN-79’s cost is of highest priority to the Navy,” Commander Thurraya Kent, a Navy spokeswoman, said in an e-mail. “The Navy is committed to maintaining the cost of CVN-79 within the congressional cost cap of $11.498B.”

Shock Tests

In another setback for the Navy, the Senate panel provided the service with $79.1 million for “full ship shock trials” on the Ford. The survival test conducted at sea is intended to assess how well a vessel stands up to underwater shocks.
McCain and Senator Jack Reed of Rhode Island, the committee’s top Democrat, wrote Kendall last month pressing for the testing. 

They supported a recommendation by the Pentagon test office. The service, which says the test would delay the ship’s deployment by six months, wants to conduct it later on the Kennedy.
©2015 Bloomberg News

Norwegian Cruise Ship Runs Aground Off Bermuda After Steering Failure

Norwegian Dawn file photo. Wikimedia Commons
Norwegian Dawn file photo. Wikimedia Commons
ReutersUpdate (May 19): The Norwegian Dawn has been refloated after running aground earlier Tuesday just off Bermuda. Here’s the full Statement from Norwegian Cruise Lines:

On Tuesday, May 19th at approximately 5:00 pm ET, Norwegian Dawn had a temporary malfunction of its steering system, causing the ship to sail slightly off course as the ship was departing Bermuda, resulting in the vessel making contact with the sea bed. All guests and crew are safe and there were absolutely no injuries.

The ship’s officers, engineers and an independent dive team have confirmed the structural integrity of the ship. With high-tide this evening, the ship was floated and moved to a nearby anchorage position where it will remain overnight. The ship will be thoroughly inspected in Bermuda by DNVGL, the ship’s classification society, before returning to Boston. The ship is fully operational with the full complement of onboard services available to guests.

The ship is sailing on a seven-night Boston to Bermuda cruise with 2,443 passengers and 1,059 crew. We will provide additional updates in the morning when more information becomes available.

Earlier:

May 19 (Reuters) – A Norwegian Cruise Line ship ran aground on a reef on Tuesday after leaving Bermuda but there were no reports of any injuries, the company said.

The Norwegian Dawn was returning to Boston with 2,675 passengers and more than 1,000 crew, U.S. media reports said. Norwegian Cruise Line said all guests and crew were safe.

In a statement, the world’s third-largest cruise operator said its ship was leaving King’s Wharf, Bermuda, at about 5:00 p.m. when it temporarily lost power.
“The ship’s propulsion was affected and, at which time, the vessel made contact with the channel bed,” the Miami-based company said.

“The ship has full power and onboard services continue as scheduled. The ship’s team is currently assessing the situation and we will provide more information as it becomes available.”

Photos posted on Twitter by people onboard showed passengers, some with drinks in hand, strolling on deck and peering over the rail at what looks like coral below in the bright blue sea.

A small boat launched to check for damage can be seen, as well as two tug boats, and scuba divers in wetsuits preparing to investigate below the waterline.
“Ship shuddered, then stopped really fast,” wrote one Twitter user, Rachel Hansen. “The captain said we won’t be moving for a while.”

Norwegian Cruise Line operates 13 purpose-built ships on routes spanning North America, the Mediterranean, the Baltic, Central America and the Caribbean. (Reporting by Daniel Wallis in Denver; Additional reporting by Steve Gorman and Dan Whitcomb in Los Angeles; Editing by Sandra Maler)
© 2015 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved.

Got Pipeline, We've Got an Oil Spill for You: Large Oil Spill Impacts Several Miles of Beach Near Santa Barbara, California. The responsible party has been identified Plains All-American Pipeline.

Photo via ABC News/Twitter
Photo via ABC News/Twitter

The U.S. Coast Guard and first responders are responding to a large oil spill that has impacted several miles of shoreline in Santa Barbara County, California.
The Coast Guard reports that the spill occurred Tuesday afternoon around 12 p.m. and the sheen washed ashore along Refugio State Beach, near Santa Barbara.

The source has been confirmed as a ruptured 24-inch pipeline, the Coast Guard said. The source has been secured.

Media has reported that the spill is estimated to be about 21,000 gallons.

The USCG in Los Angeles has reported that the sheen stretches across approximately 4 miles of beach at Refugio Beach.

A commercial oil spill response company has been contracted to begin clean up operations.

In addition to the Coast Guard, California Office of Emergency Services, California Fish and Wildlife, county fire departments, and ExxonMobil are currently on scene.

The responsible party has been identified Plains All-American Pipeline.  The messy Texans did manage to pollute our waters again.

A Incident Command Post has been established to respond to the incident.

PRISTINE NO MORE: MORE THAN 21,000 GALLONS OF OIL CREATE A 4-MILE OIL SLICK THAT CALIFORNIA COAST AFTER PLAINS ALL AMERICAN PIPELINE RUPTURE























MAY 19, 2015

GOLETA, CALIF. (AP)

A broken onshore pipeline spewed oil down a storm drain and into the Pacific Ocean for several hours before it was shut off, creating a slick some 4 miles long across a scenic stretch of central California coastline, officials said.

Initial estimates put the spill at about 21,000 gallons Tuesday, but that figure would likely change after a Wednesday morning flyover gave a better sense of the spill's scope, U.S. Coast Guard spokeswoman Jennifer Williams said.

By late Tuesday, a thick layer of crude had begun to wash ashore, with black tar smearing the rocks as the brackish tides arrived.

"It is horrible," said Brett Connors, 35, a producer from Santa Monica who said he spotted sea lions swimming in the oil slick. "You want to jump in there and save them."

The spill was about 20 miles northwest of the pricey seaside real estate of Santa Barbara, and the Coast Guard said overnight winds were likely to push it 2 to 4 miles closer.

Authorities responding to reports of a foul smell near Refugio State Beach around noon found a half-mile slick already formed in the ocean, Santa Barbara County Fire Capt. Dave Zaniboni said. They traced the oil to the onshore pipeline that spilled into a culvert running under the U.S. 101 freeway and into a storm drain that empties into the ocean.

The pipeline was shut off about three hours later but by then the slick stretched four miles and 50 yards into the water.

The 24-inch pipeline is owned by Plains All American Pipeline, which said it shut down the flow of oil and the culvert carrying the oil to the ocean was blocked.  The pipeline, built in 1991 is designed to carry about 150,000 barrels of oil per day.

"Plains deeply regrets this release has occurred and is making every effort to limit its environmental impact," the company said in a statement.

The Coast Guard, county emergency officials and state parks officials were cleaning up the spill. Boats from the nonprofit collective Clean Seas also were providing help but were having trouble because so much of the oil was so close to the shore, Williams said. About 850 gallons of oil have been recovered from the water, Williams said.

The accident occurred on the same stretch of coastline as a 1969 3 million gallon spill that at the time was the largest ever in U.S. waters and is credited for giving rise to the American environmental movement.  Several hundred thousand gallons spilled from a blowout on an oil platform and thousands of sea birds were killed along with many marine mammals.

The stretch of coastline is home to offshore oil rigs and small amounts of tar and seepage regularly show up on beaches.

The spill is largest in years and the Santa Barbara-based Environmental Defense Center said to have it occur in "a sensitive and treasured environment is devastating to watch." The group expressed special worry for the many species of whale that migrate through the area.

It was unclear how long the cleanup would take and whether Refugio and other areas would be reopened in time for Memorial Day weekend.

Tuesday, May 19, 2015

AT LEAST 2 KILLED WHEN A BEECHCRAFT BE-55 SMALL PLANE BOUND FOR MANSFIELD, OHIO CRASHES IN VIRGINIA




MAY 19, 2015

SALTVILLE, VA. (AP)

Police say at least two people died when a small airplane crashed into a mountain in southwest Virginia.

State Police Lt. Ed Murphy said Tuesday that there are conflicting reports on whether there were two or three people on the plane. Nobody survived.

The Federal Aviation Administration said the Beechcraft BE-55 was flying about seven miles northeast of Tazewell County Airport in Richlands when air traffic controllers lost contact with it Monday. Murphy said it appears the pilot was trying to avoid an isolated storm when the plane crashed.

It took rescuers 2½ hours to reach the heavily wooded crash site on Flat Top Mountain by foot Tuesday.

The FAA said the aircraft was headed from Spruce Creek Airport near Daytona Beach, Florida, to Ohio’s Mansfield Lahm Regional Airport.


////////////-------------------//////////////

SMYTH CO., Va. -- An aircraft missing since Monday has been located and there are no survivors, according to Virginia State Police.
The wreckage site is in a remote location of Smyth County, east of Saltville. The plane was found on Flat Top Mountain.

Ed Murphy, a lieutenant with Virginia State Police, said they have conflicting reports about the number of people onboard. They say either two or three people were on the aircraft.

According to the NTSB, the plane is a Beech BE55. Multiple sources have confirmed to WDBJ7's Shayne Dwyer the tail number of the plane as N5816S. The plane was flying from Daytona Beach, Florida, and was headed to Mansfield Lahm Regional Airport in Ohio.

The plane was spotted by a Virginia State Police helicopter around 12:35 p.m. Tuesday. Troopers arrived at the scene of the crash around 3:05 p.m.

The plane lost radio contact around 12:40 p.m. Monday. Based on information from the radar it appears the pilot was attempting to avoid weather pockets, according to state police. While making the maneuver, the plane crashed into the side of Flat Top Mountain. Murphy said search pilots were also having difficulty flying in the weather Monday.

WDBJ7 has learned more about a missing plane in the Smyth County area.

Multiple sources have confirmed to WDBJ7's Shayne Dwyer the tail number of the plane as N5816S. The plane is pictured above in a photo from 2010 at the Mansfield Lahm Regional Airport -- which is where the aircraft was headed according to the FAA -- at a Mansfield Airport Day event according to photographer Randy Broderick.

Multiple sources have confirmed the people at the controls are "extremely experienced pilots."

The aircraft filed an Instrument Flight Rules, otherwise known as IFR, flight from Spruce Creek airport in Port Orange, Fl. to Mansfield Lahm Regional Airport in northern central Ohio for Monday May 19.

N5816S is a 1965 Beechcraft Baron 55 twin engine plane that last changed registration in 2010 according to aviation data website Flightaware.com, and the FAA.

The aircraft is owned by LWF Holdings INC according to online records. LWF Holdings is a registered LLC in Dover Delaware according to Delaware state records.

Requests for comment at LWF Holdings Monday evening were not accepted.

The plane last made radar contact according Flightaware.com at 12:34:31 p.m. with Indianapolis Center. It reported a heading of 122 degrees, which is ESE, a groundspeed of 100 knots/115 mph, and a flight level altitude of 8,300 feet.

The second to last radar contact according to Flightaware.com was made with Indianapolis Center 61 seconds prior to the last, at 12:33:30 p.m. The reported heading is 45 degrees, which is NE, a groundspeed of 155 knots/178 mph, and flight level altitude of 8,900 feet.

In the 61 seconds between the two radar pings the, N5816S changed it's direction from Northeast to Southeast, decreased its airspeed by 55 knots/63 mph, and decreased its altitude by 600 feet according to the data from Flightaware.com

GPS locations and headings are reported to Flightaware.com following the last contact for groundspeed and altitude, although the reporting facility is listed as "Estimated" and "FlightAware Approximate."

According to flightaware.com N5816S filed an almost identical IFR flight plan for Tuesday May 19, around the same time as the one filed the day prior, and departing from and arriving at the same airport.

Flightaware.com data lists Cleveland Center as reporting a departure from Spruce Creek Airport at 8:27:58 a.m.

Position and orientations are listed following the departure but the reporting facility is listed as "Estimated."

The FAA has confirmed the aircraft in question, N5816S, departed Monday.

Officials said in their most recent media update Tuesday afternoon that searchers have still not found any signs of the plane, and are starting at square one.

Search efforts resumed at 8 a.m. Tuesday, according to Virginia State Police.

State police say they are starting at "square one" on Tuesday. They do not yet know if the plane crashed or if it only lost signal since there are no signs of wreckage and an emergency beacon has not been detected.

Authorities are looking primarily in a six-mile radius near the Saltville Rescue Squad. The area is mostly in a forest, and the terrain has had an impact on the search so far. The search area is the same as it was on Monday.

State police are not saying if anyone has heard from the pilot or passengers. Names are not being released at this time.