MEC&F Expert Engineers

Friday, May 1, 2015

Workplace Medical Mystery Solved: An Unknown Exposure Leaves a Child with High Amounts of Lead in her Blood



MMpurpSolved

The local health department conducted a lead risk assessment of Michelle and Ted’s house that turned up some interesting findings. While their home was built before 1978—when lead-containing paint was banned by the U.S. Consumer Products Safety Commission—no lead-based paint was found in the house. The homes that were demolished to make way for the construction of the family’s home and the proximity to the freeway and vehicle exhaust could have contaminated the soil in the yard, however, no lead was found there either. Lead dust was found on the floor in the family’s laundry room. So where did the lead dust on the floor come from?



Upon further testing of the family, Ted was found to have a BLL of 25 micrograms per deciliter (µg/dL). The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) defines an elevated BLL for those over age 16 to be 10 µg/dL or more.

Ted told the lead risk assessor that he typically came home from work at the e-scrap recycling facility with dust in his hair and on his clothes. He routinely picked up and played with his two-year-old daughter Sarah when he arrived home, then would take a shower and throw his clothes in the laundry before sitting down for dinner.

The type of work Ted performed at the e-scrap recycling facility, crushing cathode ray tubes from discarded TVs and computer monitors, exposed him and his coworkers to lead.

Without access to showers at work or uniforms that could be left at work for laundering, employees of the e-scrap recycling facility risked contaminating their personal clothes, vehicles, and homes with lead. This is known as “take-home” exposure and how Ted’s daughter Sarah came to have an elevated BLL.

The Occupational Safety and Health Administration estimates that approximately 804,000 workers in general industry and an additional 838,000 workers in construction are potentially exposed to lead as a result of the production, use, maintenance, recycling, and disposal of lead material and products.

NIOSH has studied take-home contamination from workplace chemicals, including lead, since 1992 when Congress passed the Workers’ Family Protection Act. Since then, NIOSH has found that take-home exposure is a widespread problem.

Workplace measures effective in preventing take-home exposures include:
  • Reducing exposure in the workplace
  • Changing clothes before going home and leaving soiled clothing at work for laundering
  • Storing street clothes in areas separate from work clothes
  • Showering before leaving work
  • Prohibiting removal of toxic substances or contaminated items from the workplace
Preventing take-home exposure is critical because decontaminating homes and vehicles is not always effective. Normal house cleaning and laundry methods are inadequate, and decontamination can expose the people doing the cleaning and laundry.

Shortly after lead was found in their home, Ted decided to quit his job at the e-scrap recycling facility. Three months following his job change, Ted’s daughter’s BLL decreased to 8 µg/dL.

CONSUMER ADVISORY: NHTSA ADVISES OWNERS OF CERTAIN FORD FIESTA, FUSION AND LINCOLN MKZ VEHICLES TO TAKE SAFETY PRECAUTIONS. Defective latches could allow doors to open unexpectedly




WASHINGTON – In response to Ford Motor Company’s recall of approximately
390,000 Ford Fiesta, Ford Fusion and Lincoln MKZ vehicles, the U.S. Department of Transportation’s National Highway Traffic Safety Administration advises owners of affected vehicles to watch for notification from Ford and get their vehicle fixed as soon as possible.

The defective door latches on these vehicles can prevent the door from properly closing. This can result in the door opening while the vehicle is moving.

The recall affects certain model year 2012-2014 Ford Fiestas, all model year 2013 Ford Fusions and Lincoln MKZs, and certain model year 2014 Ford Fusions and Lincoln MKZs.  

CONSUMER ACTIONS:
  1. Check your vehicle’s identification number (VIN) online at safercar.gov/vin to see if it is included in the recall.
  2. Keep an eye on the mail for a notice from your vehicle’s manufacturer to bring your car in to be fixed.

    Example of a Recall Notice
  3. Always wear your seat belt and make sure everyone riding in your car is buckled up.
  4. If you experience difficulty getting the door to latch while attempting to close it, do not drive the vehicle, even if it appears the door has latched. Do not attempt to temporarily secure the door in a closed position (e.g., with a rope or by using the seat belt), and do not have an occupant attempt to hold the door closed while the vehicle is being driven.  Be safe and have the vehicle towed to the nearest dealership instead.
  5. If the door opens while the vehicle is in motion, pull over immediately and have the vehicle towed to the nearest dealership. Do not attempt to reclose the door or to drive the vehicle. 

Legal action taken against several insurance companies in the wake of Superstorm Sandy stalled this week after government officials declined to pay the plaintiffs’ legal fees

Legal action taken against several insurance companies in the wake of Superstorm Sandy stalled this week after government officials declined to pay the plaintiffs’ legal fees, citing federal law.

According to a Newsday report, attorneys for the Department of Homeland Security – which oversees FEMA – concluded the government was prohibited from covering legal fees for roughly 2,000 home and business owners involved in the lawsuit. The ruling means plaintiffs will now owe their lawyers as much as one-third of any settlement from the National Flood Insurance Program and affiliated private insurance companies.

Talks, however, are still ongoing and attorneys working on the lawsuits say they are optimistic about reaching a deal. So, too, are government regulators.
“We remain committed to reaching a settlement with policyholders,” FEMA spokesman Rafael Lemaitre told Newsday.

The lawsuits were filed after flood insurance claims from the 2012 storm were rejected with engineering companies associated with private NFIP-backed carriers filed bogus reports eliminating flooding as the cause of property damage. Policyholders allege insurance companies and engineering firms were engaging in a racketeering scheme, driving up claims handling costs and exploiting the storm’s damages for their own financial benefit.

The accusations have led to a criminal probe by the New York attorney general’s office, as well as a federal order for insurance companies to turn over to home and business owners all copies of claims reports made after Sandy.

Perhaps most significantly, reforms to the flood insurance program were made shortly after the lawsuits were filed. As of December 2014, FEMA is authorized to penalize insurers just as much when they underpay a legitimate flood insurance claim as when they overpay a claim. Additionally, a flood insurance advocate’s office will be installed within FEMA to protect consumer rights.

The news comes at an already difficult time for NFIP, as the program faces backlash following significant premium spikes for flood insurance policyholders.

As part of a renegotiation of the Biggert-Waters Act, gradually higher premiums and new surcharges are asking home and business owners to pay an average 15% to 18% on their flood policies. Premiums will increase 25% per year, reducing the number of NFIP policies receiving premium subsidies, until they reflect the building’s actual flood risk.

DUE TO CARELESS DRIVING, FUEL TANKER OVERTURNS ON CAPITOL CREEK ROAD SPILLING 518 GALLONS OF GAS AND 23 GALLONS OF DIESEL IN COLORADO




MAY 1, 2015

PITKIN COUNTY, COLORADO

A fuel truck overturned on Capitol Creek Road and spilled 518 gallons of gasoline and 23 gallons of diesel fuel on Capitol Creek Road on Thursday.
The Basalt Fire Department dammed water in a ditch and pumped it across the road into a field to avoid the potential greater spread of fuel. 

A fuel tanker got into an accident and overturned shortly before 1 p.m. Thursday. 

The driver of the Roaring Fork Co-op truck refused treatment at the scene, but was going to be taken to a hospital by his wife, Burchetta said.

Trooper Steve Wall of the state patrol identified the driver as Bernard Nygaard, 65, of Rifle. He was cited for careless driving.

“He said he looked down at a map for a minute, went into the ditch, overcorrected, and that’s when he overturned,” Wall said.


The fuel was removed onto another tanker and the overturned vehicle was brought upright and towed away by 8 p.m. 

When the accident occurred, Pitkin County deputy sheriff and public information officer Alex Burchetta said the focus was on stopping the fuel from leaking, transferring the fuel to a different tank and getting the truck upright. The cause of the crash wasn’t immediately known. The driver of the truck was unhurt, according to Burchetta. He was the only occupant. 

The truck was carrying 1,500 gallons of diesel fuel and 1,100 gallons of gasoline prior to the accident, based on information the driver gave to the Fire Department, Burchetta said. There are no commercial fuel outlets on the rural road, but there are ranches beyond the point where the truck crashed.
The first firefighters arrived on scene at about 1:15 p.m. 

“We definitely noticed there was fuel leaking out of the truck,” Burchetta said. The crew that contained the leak reported it was a “steady stream” at first. By 2:15 p.m., the leak had slowed to a “few drips,” he said. 

Firefighters used rocks to dam the roadside ditch upstream from the accident site, then they pumped water over to a field on the opposite side of the ditch, Burchetta said. 

The State Patrol established a 1,000-foot perimeter of no occupancy around the site. No one had to be evacuated from the two homes within that perimeter because no one was home at the time, Burchetta said. If they arrived home, they wouldn’t be allowed to return to their residences until the hazard was gone, he added. 

The accident site was about 11/2 miles from where East Sopris Creek Road/Capitol Creek Road comes to a T-intersection with Snowmass Creek Road. The accident was between the point where Capitol Creek Road branches off from East Sopris Creek Road and the Little Elk Creek subdivision. Residents of the subdivision had to come and go via alternate access that ties into East Sopris Creek Road. 

The site is about 4 miles from the Old Snowmass Conoco station.
Reporters weren’t allowed into the site because of the possible risk posed by the fuel fumes. Burchetta said when he drove up to the site he could smell the fumes from inside his vehicle about 200 yards from the site. Basalt firefighters were working in full gear. 

The private-sector firm Metropolitan was enlisted to help with the mitigation.  They are the best firm in the United States and abroad for environmental remediation, emergency response, property damage assessments, accident reconstructions and many other service areas.

COMMONLY USED CHEMICALS COME UNDER NEW SCRUTINY: increased debate about a class of chemicals known as poly- and perfluoroalkyl substances, or PFASs




MAY 1, 2015

A top federal health official and hundreds of environmental scientists on Friday voiced new health concerns about a common class of chemicals used in products as varied as pizza boxes and carpet treatments.

The concerted public campaign renews a years-old debate about a class of chemicals known as poly- and perfluoroalkyl substances, or PFASs. After studies showed that some PFASs lingered in people’s bodies for years, and appeared to increase the risks of cancer and other health problems, the chemical manufacturer DuPont banned the use of one type of PFAS in its popular Teflon products, and other companies followed suit.

At issue now are replacement chemicals developed by those manufacturers and used in thousands of products, including electronics, footwear, sleeping bags, tents, protective gear for firefighters and even the foams used to extinguish fires.

The companies assert that the alternatives are safe and vehemently contest the scientists’ contentions, pointing to extensive studies conducted in the last decade or so.

PFASs have strong water-resistant properties; pizza boxes, for example, stay sturdy even when grease seeps into the cardboard.  This means that they can "resist" or "suffocate" life itself, the same way the other man-made chemicals have done: DDT, TCE, PCE, chlordane, and so on.

But two separate salvos fired on Friday question whether enough research has been done to justify the chemical industry’s confidence in the safety of this crop of PFASs.

“Research is needed to find safe alternatives for all current uses of PFASs,” Linda S. Birnbaum, the head of the national toxicology program for the Department of Health and Human Services, wrote in a commentary piece published Friday in Environmental Health Perspectives. “The question is, should these chemicals continue to be used in consumer products in the meantime, given their persistence in the environment?”

The journal, published by the National Institutes of Health, devoted several pages to the issue, with articles from researchers and from the industry trade group.


“We call on the international community to cooperate in limiting the production and use of PFASs,” the statement said.

In a counterpoint, the American Chemistry Council, the industry trade association, argued that the statement ignored the fact that such chemicals use “essential technology for many aspects of modern life,” and that tests, reviewed by the Environmental Protection Agency, concluded that these alternatives were safer than the chemicals they were replacing.

The PFAS family of chemicals represents an important part of DuPont’s $34.7 billion in sales last year.

Thomas H. Samples, the company’s head of risk management for the division that manufactures these chemicals, rejected the scientists’ concerns.

“We don’t dismiss the right of folks to debate this,” Mr. Samples said. “But we just believe based on the 10-year history of extensive studies done on the alternatives, that the regulatory agencies have done their job of determining that these things are safe for their intended uses.”

This business sector, the fluoro-technology industry, is considerable and reached $19.7 billion in sales in 2013, according to the most recent estimate from the FluoroCouncil, a division of the American Chemistry Council.

This class of chemicals is known for its durability. PFASs have strong water-resistant properties. Cardboard pizza boxes treated with the chemicals, for example, stay sturdy even when grease seeps into them.

But some of these same features worry environmental health specialists because traces of the chemicals linger and have been detected in the bloodstream of a large segment of the population, although typically at low levels. In some cases, detectable levels of the older class chemicals have been declining as major manufacturers have developed alternatives they say are safer.

Some researchers cite lingering concerns about a chemical spill more than a decade ago. The health of residents of Parkersburg, W.Va., is still monitored related to a spill of an older form of PFAS from a nearby chemical plant. A class-action lawsuit accused DuPont, which owned the plant, of knowingly contaminating the residents’ groundwater, and the company faces new accusations, in a separate report being issued Friday by the nonprofit Environmental Working Group, that it is not living up to the terms of a court settlement.

Mr. Samples, from DuPont, which is based in Delaware, disputed any suggestion that it was not complying with those terms.

But Dr. Paul Brooks, who helped conduct a study in the West Virginia case that found probable links between the chemical and health issues like thyroid disease and kidney cancer, said DuPont needed to do more to ensure that local residents were participating in the monitoring program. He said he was not convinced that the alternative chemicals that DuPont and other companies were selling would eliminate the health threat.

“When you have something that is a first cousin or brother-in-law to a chemical that we are certain is carcinogenic, you have to somehow prove that it is safe before you use it — that it is not injurious,” he said. “You just have to be cautious.”

Some environmental scientists point to a chemical called GenX as an example of a newer but questionable alternative. Some studies have linked GenX to short-term symptoms like eye and skin irritation in humans, as well as liver damage in animals. Mr. Samples, of DuPont, which manufacturers GenX, said that the tests involved exposing animals to levels so concentrated that they were intended to cause health complications. He also said the chemical was used in industrial settings, not as an ingredient in consumer products.
Still, environmental and health specialists are urging consumers to avoid products containing PFASs “whenever possible.”

“It’s likely they’re going to have some health effects, it just may take us a while to figure out what it is,” said Thomas F. Webster, a professor of environmental health at Boston University’s school of public health who was an author of a paper seeking more scrutiny of PFASs. “It might take five or 10 years to really do the research.”
Source: http://www.nytimes.com