MEC&F Expert Engineers

Thursday, January 22, 2015

US EPA Releases Sulfur Emissions Enforcement Policy for Ships

epa_logo 

On 15 January, Phillip Brooks from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s Air Enforcement division released the EPA’s policy for assessing civil penalties for violations of the sulfur standards applicable to ships operating in the North American and U.S. Caribbean Sea emissions control areas (ECAs).

Sulfur emissions standards are regulated on an international level by MARPOL Annex VI and is implemented in the United States via the Act to Prevent Pollution from Ships (APPS), 33 U.S.C. §1901.  As of 1 January 2015, the maximum fuel oil sulfur limit was reduced from 1.00% to 0.10% for ships operating in the Baltic Sea, North Sea, North American and Caribbean ECAs.

Around the world, ship owners that operate their vessels in these areas are faced with, in some cases, a complicated decision as meeting the requirements of MARPOL Annex VI entails significant cost – either through the burning of costly ultra-low sulfur fuel oil or the use of an emissions scrubber which could require an investment of well over USD $1 million per vessel.

Or, these owners could just ignore the rules and hope they don’t get caught.
Because there’s no set punishment for non-compliance on a global level, and the levels for non-compliance can be pennies compared to the cost of compliance, running the gauntlet so-to-speak is an option that a few owners are likely taking.  Groups of shipowners such as the Trident Alliance have come together in the past year to support “the transparent enforcement of current and forthcoming marine sulphur regulations,” which for them, helps to support a level commercial playing field.

In response to the dilemma of enforcement, the United States has put forth policy that specifically addresses how non-compliance will be handled.

Attorneys at Philadelphia-based maritime law firm Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads LLP note that for the EPA, the primary goal of this new policy is deterring ship operators from operating illegally and with that in mind, this policy concentrates on two components: (1) the “economic benefit” component; and (2) the “gravity” component. These two components are then combined into a “preliminary deterrence amount” which is adjusted pursuant to subjective factors.

In an emailed report, the firm breaks this down even further noting:
The “economic benefit” component is a mathematical formula based on factors such as the relative price difference between compliant and noncompliant fuel, and the amount of noncompliant fuel burned while within the ECAs. The policy includes methods for estimating these factors when actual data is not available.
The “gravity” component is intended to reflect the seriousness of the violation. One factor, for example, is the actual sulfur content of noncompliant fuel burned while within the ECA. Another factor is the number of record keeping violations.
The “economic benefit” and “gravity” components are combined into a “preliminary deterrence amount.” That combination is then adjusted according to factors designed to provide flexibility to account for the unique facts of each case such as degree of willfulness or negligence, degree of cooperation, history of noncompliance, litigation risk, ability to pay, and performance of a supplemental environmental project.

NTSB Report: 2013 Allision and Sinking of the OSV ‘Celeste Ann’ in Gulf of Mexico

The 112-foot steel-hulled MV Celeste Anne was built in 1979.
The 112-foot steel-hulled MV Celeste Anne was built in 1979.
The U.S. National Transportation Safety Board has released its Marine Accident Brief into the causes of the June 2013 sinking of the offshore supply vessel Celeste Ann after it struck an oil platform in the Gulf of Mexico.
According to the NTSB, the OSV Celeste Ann was receiving passengers from West Delta oil platform 73 about 20 nautical miles south of Grand Isle, Louisiana, when the vessel allided with the platform about 0836 on June 14, 2013. The allision punctured the hull, and the Celeste Ann subsequently flooded and sank. All passengers and crew evacuated to another vessel and no one was injured.
celeste ann
The report continued:
About 0810, the vessel arrived at West Delta 73 platform A to pick up passengers. The junior master backed the vessel into the landing area and held position for the transfer. The vessel was positioned stern in to the platform with its bow into a northwest wind of about 15 knots in 2- to 4-foot seas. Between 0820 and 0830, eight passengers boarded using the crane and man-lift on the platform. Shortly after taking on the passengers, the bow began to swing to starboard and the wind pushed the vessel sideways towards the platform.
The junior master attempted to maneuver the vessel away from the platform, but he was unable to overcome the wind on the vessel’s beam. The Celeste Ann allided with the platform about 0836. The vessel’s starboard side hit the platform twice before the junior master was able to back the vessel away.
About one month after the sinking, the owners of the Celeste Anne, B&J Martin Inc., decided to raise the vessel and bring it to Morgan City, Louisiana, for repairs. A damage survey determined that the initial impact with the landing platform resulted in a 2-inch-wide hole about 7 feet below the waterline near the pump room, while the second impact resulted in two holes in the engine room?one about 1 inch in diameter located 6 feet below the waterline and another about 12 inches by 1 inch about a foot below the first. Estimated costs to salvage and repair the vessel were estimated to be $1 million.
Probable Cause
The NTSB determined that the probable cause of the allision was the inability of the junior master to compensate for and overcome wind forces that pushed the vessel into the platform. The NTSB says that contributing to the hull breach and subsequent sinking were underwater protrusions from the platform and open watertight doors on board the vessel.


//________________________________________________________//

Image courtesy WDSU
Image courtesy WDSU
A 112-foot supply vessel sank on Friday after striking an oil platform in the U.S. Gulf of Mexico, WDSU News in New Orleans reports.
The U.S. Coast Guard told WDSU that the M/V Celeste Ann struck a platform located 15 miles west of Southwest Pass at about 9:18 a.m. on 14 June.  All 20 people onboard, including 4 crew, were rescued before the boat sank.
A Coast Guard aircraft flew over the scene and reported a half-mile by 150 foot sheen of oil on the ocean surface.
The Celeste Ann is one of three supply vessels owned by B&J Martin of Galliano, La.
MV Celeste Ann
MV Celeste Ann

Shell’s Curlew FPSO on Alert After Subsea Gas Leak Detected

maersk curlew fpso
Maersk Curlew FPSO, image: Maersk

Shell UK says there are no plans to evacuate the Curlew FPSO after a gas leak was detected late Monday night.  In an emailed statement, Shell says a release of natural gas originated from the subsea infrastructure located in the vicinity of the floating production facility moored 130 miles south east of Aberdeen.  The FPSO is connected to the Fulmar Gas Line which exports gas to the St Fergus terminal in Aberdeenshire.

Divers from the Dive Support Vessel (DSV) Bibby Polaris are currently in the process of isolating the leaking infrastructure from the Fulmar pipeline, according to Shell.

Utilizing a remotely operated vehicle (ROV) deployed from the subsea construction vessel Normand Subsea, a detailed investigation of the isolated infrastructure, adjacent to Curlew, will soon be underway.

“Once our initial investigation is complete into the cause of the gas escape, and we believe it is safe to do so, we will recommence gas export from the various producers connected to the Fulmar Gas line to the St Fergus Gas Plant,” says Shell.

THE AVALON OF EDGEWATER APARTMENT COMPLEX DESTROYED IN MASSIVE FIRE IN NJ. SHODDY CONSTRUCTION, CHEAP CONSTRUCTION MATERIAL, LUCK OF ACCESS TO FIREFIGHTERS, TIGHT SPACE AND MORE ARE CONTRIBUTING FACTORS TO THIS MASSIVE DISASTER: 400 DISPLACED RESIDENTS WHO LOST EVERYTHING, 200 APARTMENTS DESTROYED AND ALL THE CONTENTS WITHIN








THE AVALON OF EDGEWATER APARTMENT COMPLEX DESTROYED IN MASSIVE FIRE IN NJ.   

SHODDY CONSTRUCTION, CHEAP CONSTRUCTION MATERIAL, LUCK OF ACCESS TO FIREFIGHTERS, TIGHT SPACE AND MORE ARE CONTRIBUTING FACTORS TO THIS MASSIVE DISASTER: 400 DISPLACED RESIDENTS WHO LOST EVERYTHING, 200 APARTMENTS DESTROYED AND ALL THE CONTENTS WITHIN
Top of Form
Bottom of Form
Top of Form
Bottom of Form


Wednesday, Jan 21, 2015 

Everybody knows that the new areas of Edgewater were built by shady developers (Daibes, Demetrakis and other) who used their influence over the council of Edgewater Borough to cut corners in safety and proper construction:  buildings housing hundreds of people were built in small heavily contaminated lots where firefighters do not have access, firewalls are omitted or are of low quality material, light wood was used that is readily combustible, sprinkler systems are not maintained or tested for functionality, and so on.  These are some of the reasons that the entire Avalon of Edgewater development went up in smoke in such a small amount of time.

A five-alarm blaze swept through a luxury New Jersey apartment complex Wednesday evening, forcing hundreds to evacuate and sending plumes of smoke thousands of feet into the sky above the Hudson River.

Firefighters struggled for hours to quench the flames at the Avalon on the Hudson at 102 Russell Ave. in Edgewater, 15 years after an earlier blaze burned the same complex to the ground as it was being built.

"We left in what we had," evacuated resident Tamara Talbott said. "We got the kids and the dogs. Our cars are all underneath. There's nothing left.” 
The fire was mostly contained by Wednesday night, with no loss of life or major injuries reported, according to McPartland.

Edgewater Mayor Michael McPartland has declared a local state of emergency, announcing schools will be closed Thursday and roads will be restricted. 

The fire broke out around 4:30 p.m., and the 175-unit building was quickly evacuated. After firefighters first responded, the fire appeared under control for some time, but it escalated in the back part of the complex, which responders had a hard time accessing. 

The blaze then spread to the northern section of the building, engulfing multiple units. Flames and smoke could be seen from the top of Rockefeller Center, across the Hudson River. 
The fire drew a massive mutual aid response, with departments from Hudson, Bergen and Union counties responding. The FDNY and Jersey City's fire department also responded with fireboats, helping to draw water from the Hudson River, officials said. 

Tankers and engines attempted to fight the blaze from the exterior, and collapse zones were set up around the complex as the blaze tore down roofs.  
Thick plumes of smoke from the fire sent Chopper 4 over the scene to double its normal altitude -- from about 1,500 feet to 3,000 feet. 

The hillside communities surrounding Edgewater were also being watched, as embers from the blaze were whipped into the air. 
Around 160 people are being sheltered at a local community center with the help of the Office of Emergency Management and Red Cross, according to the mayor. 
Residents walked around River Road in shock as they wondered how a fire could spread so quickly. 

"For all the fire doors and things we have in the building, I'm shocked that it would go from something small to something like this," resident Talbott said. 
One responding fire chief told NBC 4 New York he thought lightweight wood construction was a factor in how quickly the fire spread. 

"It collapses very easily, and the fire spreads very easily throughout," he said.
The large Avalon on the Hudson apartment complex, located by the Hudson River across from Manhattan, is across the street from the Edgewater post office, and is located across a shopping complex that contains a Trader Joe's supermarket. 

The same apartment complex burned to the ground while it was being constructed in 2000. It was rebuilt featuring one-, two- and three-bedroom units designed to appeal to New York City commuters. 

McPartland said the building had sprinklers inside.  Yet, the condition of the fire fighting system is questionable 

Power and gas were shut off to the area as firefighters responded; some streets and buildings were still without power Wednesday night, and officials were expected to assess safety before allowing utilities to restore electricity. 

Wednesday, January 21, 2015

MAN DIES IN I-55 CRASH IN MISSISSIPPI AFTER FALLING ASLEEP AT THE WHEEL, HITS A TREE AND HIS RV BURSTS INTO FLAMES



MAN DIES IN I-55 CRASH IN MISSISSIPPI AFTER FALLING ASLEEP AT THE WHEEL, HITS A TREE AND HIS RV BURSTS INTO FLAMES


Posted: Jan 21, 2015 1:17 PM EST 

DESOTO COUNTY, MS (WMC) - 

Investigators are looking into a deadly crash on I-55 after a driver fell asleep behind the wheel.

The crash happened early Wednesday morning. 

A driver fell asleep behind the wheel of an RV on I-55 in DeSoto County, Mississippi early Wednesday morning. He was alone in the vehicle, which caught fire after the impact.

A photo from a WMC Action News 5 viewer shows the charred RV on the side on the highway.

Officials say the man was traveling alone when he hit a tree and died.

Investigators have not released his identity.