MEC&F Expert Engineers : OLD DRIVER CAUSES COLLISION WITH TRAIN IN BAINBRIDGE, PA. CLAIMS HE DID NOT HEAR OR SEE THE MASSIVE TRAIN.

Tuesday, April 7, 2015

OLD DRIVER CAUSES COLLISION WITH TRAIN IN BAINBRIDGE, PA. CLAIMS HE DID NOT HEAR OR SEE THE MASSIVE TRAIN.



















MARCH 27, 2015

 CONOY TOWNSHIP, PENNSYLVANIA
 
An 85-year-old man is recovering after his pickup truck was struck by an empty oil train March 27 in Bainbridge, Conoy Township, along the Susquehanna River.
Clark “Red” Arnold, of Marietta, was in critical condition as recently as Friday, but was listed in good condition Monday, a spokeswoman at Penn State Hershey Medical Center said.

Arnold was trapped in the truck after he apparently stopped his vehicle in the train’s path.

“He just didn’t hear the train,” Conoy Township supervisor Stephen Mohr said Friday afternoon.

“He and the train got to the intersection at about the same time. When he did see the train, he panicked and stopped on the tracks.”

Mohr, who witnessed the crash, said he had been speaking to Arnold just moments before the accident at the nearby Koser Park Boat launch area.
“You’re helpless,” he said. “I knew it was going to happen before it happened, but there’s nothing you can do.”

The crash occurred at the Race Street crossing at North Front Street.

Emergency crews were called to the scene at 1:29 p.m.

The Norfolk Southern oil train was heading north toward Harrisburg and was not carrying oil at the time of the crash, according to police.

Local, state and federal officials have expressed concerns about explosive Bakken crude oil being transported by train after several recent derailments.
Oil trains, often pulling more than 100 tanker cars, roll through about 35 miles of Lancaster County along the Susquehanna River up to 16 times a week.

Arnold was freed from his truck and taken to Hershey Medical Center for treatment, according to Lt. Stephen Englert of Susquehanna Regional Police.
“It was pretty serious,” Mohr said. “He took a beating. ... They had to take the vehicle apart to free him.”

Mohr said Arnold was "conscious and talking to us" while rescue workers freed him from the truck.

There are no crossgates or warning lights at the intersection, Mohr noted.  Howver, there are railroad signs before the intersection and the tracks are right there, easy to see.

Witnesses at the scene stated they heard the Norfolk Southern train horn well before the train collided with the vehicle, according to the Susquehanna Regional Police report.

Randy Gockley, director of the Lancaster County Emergency Management Agency, said the train did not derail, and responders on the scene reported no leakage from the train.

The Race Street intersection is the entrance to Bainbridge American Legion Park, which serves as the trailhead for the Northwest Lancaster County River Trail, as well as the location of the Bainbridge Inn.

Englert said the collision does not make him any more concerned about oil trains traveling through Conoy.

Capt. Leonard Crater of Bainbridge Fire Department said the the victim apparently “got a little too close to the tracks, and was unaware of the train coming.”

Onlookers “didn't think he was trying to beat the train,” Crater said.

He was glad train cars were empty so “there was no kind of worry about any kind of leak or explosions or anything like that.”

The Bainbridge fire captain said nearly 20 firefighters from his department and nearby units responded, along with police.

Penny Rhan of 114 Race St., some 50 yards from the crash, heard a boom but didn't initially realize it had been a train accident.

Another Race Street resident, Wayne Brooks, said “it's been a long time since we've had an accident there.”


So many accidents, including deadly accidents, are caused by old drivers. We have to better test their abilities to operate a motor vehicle.  We do know that the old people lose with aging their eyesight, their hearing, their reflexes and so on.  This old driver fits the pattern:  he did not hear the train, while other people did hear it.  It is simply not safe to let them drive without more safeguards to protect them and the rest of us.