Report: Tenn. Ferris wheel that dropped girls 30 feet had worn out rivets
Greeneville Police Detective Capt. Tim Davis answers questions at the foot of the Ferris wheel at the Greene County Fair on Aug. 9, 2016 in Tennessee. Members of the Greene County Fair Board of Directors stand behind him. (O.J. Early / Greeneville Sun)
Worn out rivet fasteners on a Ferris wheel are being blamed for an overturned gondola at an eastern Tennessee fair that earlier this week sent three girls plummeting more than 30 feet to the ground.
The Tennessee Department of Labor and Workforce Development announced late Friday that it has renewed permits for the ride's owner, Family Attractions Amusement, to resume operations at other fairs around the state. But the Frris wheel is excluded from the permit.
Inspectors hired by the company and the Greene County Fair found that rivets had worn out on the bottom of the tub carrying the girls, allowing a trim piece to come loose and get lodged in the frame of the wheel and tipping the gondola over.
"Ride NOT safe to operate at time of inspection," Frank Guenthner, an inspector hired by ride owner Family Attractions Amusement, wrote in his report.
A team of IKEA experts are traveling across the country helping families tackle home challenge with design makeovers that have smart solutions to make everyday life at home better. See More
The Ferris wheel, which inspectors say was correctly assembled at the site, is being sent back to the manufacturer for repair.
Tennessee does not conduct its own inspections of fair or amusement park rides, instead relying on third-party inspectors. The company was allowed to operate in the state based on an inspection made in Indiana in June.
Six-year-old Briley Rae Reynolds suffered a traumatic brain injury in the fall on Monday and her 10-year-old sister, Kayla, broke her arm. Kayla and an unidentified 16-year old have been released from the hospital, but Briley Rae remained in critical condition.
Firefighters inspect a Ferris wheel that dumped three girls out of a passenger gondola on Aug. 9, 2016, in Tennessee. Police say one of three people who fell from a Ferris wheel during a county fair suffered a head injury and remains hospitalized in serious condition. (Ken Little / Greeneville Sun)
Republican Gov. Bill Haslam told reporters earlier Friday that it was too soon to say what Tennessee might do to avoid future injuries on rides
"I don't know that right now I have a policy shift of what should happen differently," he said.
It's not the first time Family Attractions Amusement rides have hurt riders.
At the 2013 North Carolina State Fair, five people were injured when an Italian-made ride called the Vortex unexpectedly restarted as they were trying to get off the ride, flinging them through the air and down to the steel deck below. Investigators determined that a safety mechanism had been disabled by ride operators including the son of company owners Dominic and Ruby Macaroni.
Joshua Macaroni earlier this year entered an Alford plea — a concession that there is sufficient evidence for a conviction without admitting guilt — on a felony charge of obstruction of justice. He was sentenced in February to five to 15 months in prison, though the judge suspended that to a month in jail. He was also ordered pay a $22,500 fine.
Amusement ride death, injuries put spotlight on safety at state fair
The Greeneville Sun has reported that Greene County Fair Board officials decided to go through with a five-year contract with a Family Attractions despite the North Carolina incident, citing the company's previous safety record in Tennessee and the owners' claims that they were not involved with the Vortex ride. "
Their rides were not inspected when they were assembled in Tennessee.
Family Attractions Amusement had already taken down its rides in Greeneville the day before the state decision to allow most of the rides to resume.
Associated Press
====================
(Twitter/ Greenville Sun)
Updated 4 mins ago
NASHVILLE, Tenn. -- Worn out rivet fasteners on a Ferris wheel are being blamed for an overturned gondola at an eastern Tennessee fair that earlier this week sent three girls plummeting more than 30 feet to the ground.
The Tennessee Department of Labor and Workforce Development announced late Friday that it has renewed permits for the ride's owner, Family Attractions Amusement, to resume operations at other fairs around the state. But the Ferris wheel is excluded from the permit.
Inspectors hired by the company and the Greene County Fair found that rivets had worn out on the bottom of the tub carrying the girls, allowing a trim piece to come loose and get lodged in the frame of the wheel and tipping the gondola over.
"Ride NOT safe to operate at time of inspection," Frank Guenthner, an inspector hired by ride owner Family Attractions Amusement, wrote in his report.
READ THE REPORT HERE (.pdf)
The Ferris wheel, which inspectors say was correctly assembled at the site, is being sent back to the manufacturer for repair.
Tennessee does not conduct its own inspections of fair or amusement park rides, instead relying on third-party inspectors. The company was allowed to operate in the state based on an inspection made in Indiana in June.
Six-year-old Briley Rae Reynolds suffered a traumatic brain injury in the fall on Monday and her 10-year-old sister, Kayla, broke her arm. Kayla and an unidentified 16-year old have been released from the hospital, but Briley Rae remained in critical condition.
Republican Gov. Bill Haslam told reporters earlier Friday that it was too soon to say what Tennessee might do to avoid future injuries on rides
"I don't know that right now I have a policy shift of what should happen differently," he said.
It's not the first time Family Attractions Amusement rides have hurt riders.
At the 2013 North Carolina State Fair, five people were injured when an Italian-made ride called the Vortex unexpectedly restarted as they were trying to get off the ride, flinging them through the air and down to the steel deck below. Investigators determined that a safety mechanism had been disabled by ride operators including the son of company owners Dominic and Ruby Macaroni.
Joshua Macaroni earlier this year entered an Alford plea - a concession that there is sufficient evidence for a conviction without admitting guilt - on a felony charge of obstruction of justice. He was sentenced in February to five to 15 months in prison, though the judge suspended that to a month in jail. He was also ordered pay a $22,500 fine.
The Greeneville Sun has reported that Greene County Fair Board officials decided to go through with a five-year contract with a Family Attractions despite the North Carolina incident, citing the company's previous safety record in Tennessee and the owners' claims that they were not involved with the Vortex ride.
Their rides were not inspected when they were assembled in Tennessee.
Family Attractions Amusement had already taken down its rides in Greeneville the day before the state decision to allow most of the rides to resume.
==================
Link between NC, Tenn. amusement mishaps
The Macaroni family owns Family Attractions Amusement in Georgia, which owns the Ferris wheel that malfunctioned in Tennessee on Aug. 8. The company also owned the ride that went out of control at the North Carolina State Fair in 2013 after the operator, Tim Tutterow, tampered with safety equipment on the Vortex.
On Wednesday night, a private inspector and police in Tennessee blaming the accident on "mechanical failure," but government investigators are still sorting out exactly how the Ferris wheel seat flipped over, sending three girls plummeting about 25 feet to the ground.
The accident left a 6-year-old girl with a traumatic brain injury, and has prompted renewed scrutiny of the lack of state or federal inspections to ensure that traveling carnival ride has been safely installed before it opens for business.
Tennessee authorities decided to stop doing inspections altogether after a 2014 audit found shortcomings in the state's regulatory program for rides at fairs and amusement parks.
The state relies instead on private inspectors hired by ride operators as well as inspections in other states to determine whether roller coasters, zip lines and Ferris wheels are safe. But there is no state requirement for an inspection to confirm that traveling equipment has been properly reassembled before children climb on board.
Greeneville Police Capt. Tim Davis said at a news conference late Tuesday that "mechanical failure" appeared to have caused the basket the girls were riding in to overturn Monday night at the Greene County Fair in eastern Tennessee.
Frank Gunther, an inspector hired by Family Attractions Amusement, also cited mechanical failure at the news conference Tuesday night. Three other inspectors - the police captain didn't say who they represent - are at the scene investigating.
Bracken Burns, the director of trauma services for Johnson City Medical Center, said the 6-year-old was critically injured, while her 10-year-old sister and a 16-year-old female who shared their seat were described as stable. Burns said the 10-year-old's forearms were injured, and that he couldn't release information on the other girl.
The company received its permit to operate the Ferris wheel in Tennessee for the next three months based on a June inspection in Indiana, according to state Department of Labor and Workforce Development spokeswoman Jennifer Farrar.
Because of this accident, the operators will have to have a new third-party inspection conducted before the ride can qualify for a new annual permit in Tennessee, Farrar said.
In a follow-up to the audit last year, the state Department of Labor and Workforce Development said Tennessee law does not require the state to hire its own inspectors. Funding for the Amusement Device Unit was requested for the budget year ending in June but was denied.
Tennessee shifted responsibility for ride inspections from the state Department of Commerce to the Department of Labor and Workforce Development in 2009, but failed to develop a "viable amusement device regulatory unit" thereafter, the 2014 audit found.
Auditors said mistakes in record-keeping and a lack of inspectors created "serious concerns about whether the unit is able to ensure that all amusement devices in the state are appropriately permitted and inspected both annually and following accidents and fatalities."
The Greene County incident was the eighth injury incident reported to Tennessee authorities on amusement rides this summer. In Gatlinburg, a woman's wrists and knee caps were fractured when she was ejected from a ride. At three different attractions in Pigeon Forge, people suffered a broken arm on a roller coaster and back injuries were reported after doing flips at a trampoline park and getting hit from behind on an alpine coaster.
After the accident in North Carolina in 2013, the state made a number of changes in how it considers and contracts with companies at the fair. This is a list of those changes given to us by the Department of Agriculture.
- Contract now requires the contractor to provide the State Fair with a list of all persons or businesses supplying rides, games or concessions, including name, address and contact person, at least 30 days prior to the start of the fair for rides and seven days for games and concessions. Previously, the requirement was 14 days for rides, games and concessions.
- Another new requirement is that the contractor must provide copies of all insurance certificates from subcontractors and furnish, upon request by the State Fair manager, safety inspection reports performed by the insurance carrier and any inspection reports from the last fair played.
- The new contract places less emphasis on the number of rides that must be provided. The previous minimum was 93 rides. Now, it's 85. (This recognizes the fact that one larger ride, which uses more space, may be preferable to three smaller rides. Also, this change can reduce the number of rides needed from subcontractors.)
- The new contract also specifies that the State Fair manager will determine which rides fall into various classifications, such as spectacular, major and kiddie. Previously, the contractor submitted a list of rides already categorized. The State Fair manager will base his determination on factors such as the height requirement set by the ride manufacturer, how many tickets it takes to ride, and height, size, length, capacity or complexity of ride assembly and operation.
- Contract requires criminal background checks and drug tests of all employees of the contractor and subcontractors. (Powers already did this, but it will be a requirement going forward, regardless of carnival contractor.)