Thursday, June 2, 2016
Thousands of U.S. Victims Defrauded Out of Over $18 Million Annually
The United States filed a civil complaint in the U.S. District Court
for the Eastern District of New York against an individual and two Dutch
companies that allegedly engaged in multiple international mail fraud
schemes that have defrauded elderly and vulnerable U.S. victims out of
tens of millions of dollars, the Department of Justice announced. The
Department sought a temporary restraining order, which was entered by
the court yesterday, as well as preliminary and permanent injunctions to
prevent the defendants from further victimizing U.S. consumers.
According to the complaint, U.S. residents received fraudulent direct
mail solicitations that falsely claimed that the individual recipient
had won, or would soon win cash or valuable prizes or otherwise come
into great fortune. Victims sent payments through the U.S. and
international mail systems to defendants Trends Service in Kommunikatie
B.V. (Trends) and Kommunikatie Service Buitenland B.V. (KSB), both in
Utrecht, Netherlands, and both owned and operated by defendant Erik
Dekker, 54, of Langbroek, Netherlands.
At the same time that the Justice Department took this law
enforcement action, Dutch law enforcement agents executed search
warrants on the business address used by both companies and on Dekker’s
home address. The Dutch authorities also took control of the Dutch P.O.
boxes used by the defendants to receive victim funds. The coordinated
U.S. and Dutch enforcement actions seek to immediately stop the use of
Dutch P.O. boxes to receive payments from fraud victims and to
immediately stop the defendants from continuing to victimize the
elderly. Learn more about the actions taken by Dutch authorities at: https://www.om.nl/actueel/nieuwsberichten/@94702/fiod-and-us-doj/ [external link]
“Schemes targeting elderly victims are increasingly international in
scope, but geographic distance will not prevent us from seeking justice
and holding bad actors accountable,” said Principal Deputy Assistant
Attorney General Benjamin C. Mizer, head of the Justice Department’s
Civil Division. “Dutch authorities have done a great service to U.S.
residents and elderly victims worldwide by addressing fraud facilitated
within their borders. The Justice Department will continue to work with
our international law enforcement partners to put a stop to fraud
schemes that exploit vulnerable Americans.”
“As alleged in the complaint, defendants act as the clearinghouses
for multiple international mail fraud schemes, taking money from
thousands of elderly and vulnerable victims not only in this district
but also throughout the United States,” said U.S. Attorney Robert L.
Capers for the Eastern District of New York. “Together with the U.S.
Postal Inspection Service and our international partner, the Fiscal
Intelligence and Investigation Division of the Netherlands, we will
track down, and stop, the schemes wherever they lead.”
“No one should ever be told they must pay a fee, or make a worthless
purchase, to collect a prize,” said Inspector in Charge Regina L.
Faulkerson of the U.S. Postal Inspection Service’s Criminal
Investigation Group. “When that happens, it’s fraud - plain and simple -
and Postal Inspectors work to keep those falsehoods out of the U.S.
mail.”
The complaint filed June 1 in U.S. federal court in the Eastern
District of New York alleges that, since at least 2012, Trends, KSB and
Dekker have used P.O. boxes in the Netherlands to receive payments from
various predatory mass-mailing fraud schemes. Solicitations are mailed
from locations around the globe to residents in the United States. The
solicitations purport to be personalized to each individual recipient,
even though they are form letters mailed to hundreds of thousands of
potential victims. Some solicitations instruct recipients to pay a
processing fee in order to receive lottery winnings or other prizes;
other solicitations urge recipients to purchase goods or services based
on false promises that they will guarantee future lottery wins.
As alleged in the complaint, victims responded to the solicitations
by completing a form and submitting a payment, usually around $15 to
$55, via U.S. mail. The solicitations contain pre-addressed envelopes
in which victims send payments. The envelopes are addressed to P.O.
boxes in the Netherlands. Trends and KSB operate more than 50 of these
P.O. boxes. Like other so-called “caging services,” Trends and KSB open
the payment envelopes, remove the contents, enter payment and other
personal information from the victims into a database and handle victim
payments. The U.S. government estimates that U.S. victims mail more
than $18 million annually to the defendants’ P.O. boxes.
The government is seeking an injunction under the Anti-Fraud
Injunction Statute immediately shutting down the defendants’ role in the
fraudulent schemes in order to protect U.S. victims from further harm.
The injunctions sought by the United States would enjoin the defendants
from using the U.S. mail or causing the U.S. mail to be used, to
distribute the fraudulent solicitations or to collect victim payments,
and from selling lists of American victims who have responded to the
solicitations. If granted, a permanent injunction would allow the U.S.
Postal Service to intercept mail heading to the defendants, and return
that mail—along with any money being sent to the defendants—to U.S.
victims.
U.S. District Court Judge I. Leo Glasser for the Eastern District of
New York set a hearing on the preliminary injunction on July 18 at 10
a.m.
The Justice Department’s case is being handled by Trial Attorney
Kerala Thie Cowart of the Civil Division’s Consumer Protection Branch,
Assistant U.S. Attorney John Vagelatos of the U.S. Attorney’s Office in
the Eastern District of New York and Postal Inspector Joseph R. Bizzarro
of the U.S. Postal Inspection Service.
The claims made in the complaints are allegations only, and there has been no determination of liability.
A copy of the complaint, case # 16-CV-2770, can be found here: https://www.justice.gov/opa/file/863501/download
More information on fraud against the elderly is available here: https://www.justice.gov/elderjustice/.
Additional information about the Consumer Protection Branch and its enforcement efforts may be found at http://www.justice.gov/civil/consumer-protection-branch.