MARCH 17, 2015
Agrochemical giant Monsanto has been sued by the City of San
Diego and the San Diego Unified Port District for selling chemicals the
multinational knew were harmful to the ecology, including that of the now
heavily polluted San Diego Bay.
According to the San Diego Reader, city agencies filed suit
on Monday, alleging Monsanto hid its knowledge of the toxicity of
polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs).
Despite being aware of these facts, the
company peddled its chemical compounds for industrial use, including
shipbuilding, electrical component manufacture, food packaging and paint
plasticizers.
The city and port were previously held responsible by the
San Diego Regional Water Control Board for the bay’s pollution, resulting in
fines of $949,634. The city set aside $6.45 million to improve the Shipyards
Sediment Site, the most notoriously polluted section of the bay. City and port
authorities have already sued shipbuilding companies BAE and NASSCO, and are
now going for Monsanto.
"PCBs manufactured by Monsanto have been found in Bay
sediments and water and have been identified in tissues of fish, lobsters, and
other marine life in the Bay,” the city said in the lawsuit. “PCB contamination
in and around the Bay affects all San Diegans and visitors who enjoy the Bay,
who reasonably would be disturbed by the presence of a hazardous, banned
substance in the sediment, water, and wildlife.
"PCBs were not only a substantial factor in causing the
City and Port District to incur damages, but a primary driving force behind the
need to clean up and abate Bay sediments. In addition, fish consumption
warnings are posted at locations in and around Bay tidelands warning the public
that fish within the Bay may contain contaminants and directing consumption
limitations."
Monsanto was the practically the only PCB producer in North
America, marketing the products under the name Aroclor from 1930 to 1977, according
to US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
The lawsuit claimed Monsanto had known about the risks of
inhaling or ingesting PCBs since the 1930s.
A report from 1969, the suit noted, showed that a Monsanto
committee discussed ways to continue propagating the organic pollutants, which
have been linked to non-Hodgkin lymphoma by the International Agency for
Research on Cancer, among others.
"There is little probability that any action that can
be taken will prevent the growing incrimination of specific polychlorinated
biphenyls as nearly global environmental contaminants leading to contamination
of human food (particularly fish), the killing of some marine species (shrimp),
and the possible extinction of several species of fish eating birds,” the
internal Monsanto report said.
"Secondly, the committee believes that there is no
practical course of action that can so effectively police the uses of these
products as to prevent environmental contamination. There are, however a number
of actions which must be undertaken to prolong the manufacture, sale and use of
these particular Aroclors as well as to protect the continued use of other members
of the Aroclor series."
Through the suit, the city and port want to recoup costs of
removing PCBs from the bay and for loss of natural resources.
PCBs have been banned in the United States since 1979.
Much of Monsanto’s PCB production occurred in plants based
in Anniston, Alabama and Sauget, Illinois, just across the Mississippi River
from St. Louis.
In 2013, a Missouri appeals court ruled that a lawsuit --
alleging PCBs produced by Monsanto caused cancer -- could move forward in a
reversal of a lower court’s decision.
The case, according to attorneys for the plaintiffs, is
monumental given the plaintiffs alleged “general population” -- and not
occupational -- exposure.
“The case represents
the first time that injured victims have sought to hold a company accountable
for producing a chemical that has contaminated the entire planet, including
every person in the United States,” wrote Allen Stewart, P.C., a Dallas law
firm that handles lymphoma claims.
“The plaintiffs are three lymphoma patients who each have
elevated levels of PCBs in their blood. The original Monsanto Co. (now known as
“Pharmacia Corp.”) produced more than 99% of all of the PCBs ever used in the
United States. Because PCBs are far more persistent in the environment than
most other chemicals, PCBs are now a ubiquitous environmental contaminant.
Today, PCBs can be found in measurable levels in virtually any sample of soil
or air, and also in the food chain. PCBs contaminate fish, dairy products,
beef, pork, poultry, and eggs.”
Source:rt.com