This blog presents Metropolitan Engineering Consulting & Forensics (MEC&F) claim management and claim investigation analyses of some of the typical claims we handle
EPA, DOJ and IDEM Reach Agreement with Gary, Ind., to Resolve Clean Water Act Violations 12/14/2016 Contact Information: Peter Cassell (cassell.peter@epa.gov) 312-886-6234
For Immediate Release: No. 16-OPA048
CHICAGO (Dec. 14, 2016) – U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, the Department of Justice, and the Indiana Department of Environmental Management, have reached an agreement with the city of Gary and the Gary Sanitary District that will resolve long-standing violations of the Clean Water Act, including the release of raw sewage. The city will pay a civil fine of $75,000 and take corrective steps starting immediately and continuing over the next 25 years to eliminate these problems.
“I am pleased that Mayor Freeman-Wilson is addressing this long-standing problem,” said EPA Acting Regional Administrator Robert Kaplan. “This is an important step toward cleaning up Northwest Indiana’s waterways.”
The agreement requires the city to take actions to manage sewer overflows over a 25-year period. The city must ensure the wastewater treatment plant sufficiently treats wastewater during all wet weather conditions. Gary will also develop a long-term control plan including steps to limit the occurrence of combined sewer overflows. As part of the agreement, the city will also remove invasive plants and restore native plants to an area along the Grand Calumet River, which has been affected by the contamination.
The agreement also addresses PCB contamination in an area known as the Ralston Street Lagoon. The lagoon was originally used during construction of the Indiana Toll Road. Later, it was used to dispose of PCB-contaminated sludge from the wastewater treatment plant, a violation of the federal Toxic Substances Control Act. In 1988, the city stopped using the lagoon for sludge storage.
The city of Gary has 12 combined sewer outfalls: five discharge to the Little Calumet River and seven to the Grand Calumet River. When wastewater systems overflow, they can release untreated sewage and other pollutants into local waterways, threatening water quality and contributing to beach closures and health concerns. Untreated sewage contains bacteria, viruses and parasites that can cause diseases.
Ned Stevens Gutter Cleaning cited for fall protection violation as worker falls in Lexington from roof as unprotected foreman stands on another New Jersey contractor cited twice in 11 months for allowing fall hazards in Massachusetts
ANDOVER, Mass. - An employee of Ned Stevens Gutter Cleaning and General Contracting of Massachusetts Inc. was injured when he fell 9 feet from a garage roof in Lexington on Oct. 24, 2016. It was the second such incident in Massachusetts in less than a year for the New Jersey-based company that specializes in cleaning gutters and roofs. On Nov. 29, 2015, another employee fell 26 feet from a roof in Newton.
An inspection by the U.S. Department of Labor's Occupational Safety and Health Administration found that the employee working in Lexington atop a garage at 21 Adams St. lacked fall protection as did his foreman who was exposed to a 21-foot fall from the roof of the adjacent house. As a result, OSHA has now cited Ned Stevens for a repeatviolation of fall protection requirements and proposed $68,591 in fines for that violation. In March 2014, the agency cited the company for a similar hazard at a northern New Jersey worksite.
"This is a disturbing pattern - two falls, two incidents - in which this employer did not provide its employees with the proper and required safeguards. The seriousness of fall hazards cannot be understated. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports 10 workers in Massachusetts died in falls in 2014. While the workers in these two incidents were not killed, the threat of death or disabling injuries was real and present. Ned Stevens must act to protect its employees against this common but preventable hazard at all its jobsites," said Anthony Covello, OSHA's area director for Middlesex and Essex counties.
In the Newton case, OSHA cited Ned Stevens in April 2016 for two violations, with $45,500 in fines, for failing to ensure the use of protective equipment when the workers went atop the roof and not guarding two skylights through which the workers could also have fallen. Those citations and penalties are currently under contest.
Headquartered in Fairfield, New Jersey, Ned Stevens provides gutter cleaning, repair and installation and other services in 11 states, most on the Eastern seaboard as well as in Illinois and Texas. The company has 15 business days from receipt of its citations and proposed penalties to comply, meet with OSHA's area director, or contest the findings before the independent Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission.
To ask questions, obtain compliance assistance, file a complaint, or report amputations, eye loss, workplace hospitalizations, fatalities or situations posing imminent danger to workers, the public should call OSHA's toll-free hotline at 800-321-OSHA (6742) or the agency's Andover Area Office at 978-837-4460.
Under the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970, employers are responsible for providing safe and healthful workplaces for their employees. OSHA's role is to ensure these conditions for America's working men and women by setting and enforcing standards, and providing training, education and assistance. For more information, visit http://www.osha.gov .
Alabama auto parts supplier to Kia and Hyundai, staffing agencies face $2.5M in fines after robot fatally crushes young bride-to-be Ajin USA, Alliance Total Solutions and Joynus Staffing Corp. cited for 27 safety violations
CUSSETA, Ala. - When she wasn't employed as a temporary worker at a Cusseta manufacturer that stamps metal parts for Hyundai and Kia vehicles, Regina Allen Elsea was making final plans for her wedding and looking forward to a new life with her future husband.
On June 18, 2016, those dreams ended when the 20-year-old Elsea was crushed to death in a robotic machine. That day, the assembly line stopped and she and three of her co-workers entered a robotic station to clear a sensor fault. The robot restarted abruptly, crushing the young woman inside the machine. Her death occurred two weeks before her wedding day.
An investigation by the U.S. Department of Labor's Occupational Safety and Health Administration has led the agency to issue citations for 23 willful, serious and other-than-serious violations, including 19 egregious instance-by-instance willful violations, to Joon LLC, doing business as Ajin USA of Cusseta. OSHA also cited two staffing agencies - Alliance HR Inc., doing business as Alliance Total Solutions LLC and Joynus Staffing Corp. - for two serious safety violations each. Collectively, the three companies face $2,565,621 in penalties for the federal safety and health violations.
"This senseless tragedy could have been prevented if Regina Elsea's employers had followed proper safety precautions," said Dr. David Michaels, assistant secretary of labor for Occupational Safety and Health. "In addition, it is unfortunate that Hyundai and Kia, who set strict specifications on the parts they purchase from their suppliers, appear to be less concerned with the safety of the workers who manufacture those parts."
In 2015, Dr. Michaels traveled to Korea and met with Hyundai and Kia's top managers, warning them of hazardous conditions at their suppliers, explaining to them that the automobile firms' production policies were endangering workers at the suppliers' factories.
"Kia and Hyundai's on-demand production targets are so high that workers at their suppliers are often required to work six and sometimes seven days a week to meet the targets," said Dr. Michaels. "It appears that - to reduce its own costs in meeting these targets - this supplier cut corners on safety, at the expense of workers' lives and limbs."
Failing to utilize energy control procedures to prevent machinery from starting up during maintenance and servicing.
Exposing workers to caught-in, struck-by and crushing hazards by allowing them to enter a robotic cell without shutting down and securing hazardous stored energy according to safety procedures.
Exposing employees to crushing and amputation hazards due to improper machine guarding.
OSHA issued two serious citations to Ajin USA for exposing workers to laceration hazards by allowing them to work with parts having sharp edges while improperly wearing or not wearing protective sleeves and not installing effective shields or curtains on welding machines to protect the operator and others from flying sparks.
The agency also issued two serious citations to Alliance and Joynus for failing to utilize specific safety procedures to control potentially hazardous stored energy during maintenance and servicing and not providing or ensuring employees had locks to properly shutdown machinery.
Alliance and Joynus, both based in Opelika, provide approximately 250 temporary employees to Ajin USA. Elsea was hired to work at Ajin through Alliance Total Solutions.
"This was a preventable incident - Ajin USA only had to ensure that proper safety measures were followed to de-energize the robot before the workers entered the station," said Kurt Petermeyer, OSHA's regional administrator in Atlanta. "Incidents like this one are not isolated and that is why OSHA has developed and implemented its Regional Emphasis Program on Safety Hazards in the Auto Parts Industry."
The agency has also placed Ajin USA in its Severe Violators Enforcement Program. The program focuses on recalcitrant employers that endanger workers by committing willful, repeat or failure-to-abate violations. Under the program, OSHA may inspect any of the employer's facilities if it has reasonable grounds to believe there are similar violations.
Based in Korea, Ajin USA, is a global auto parts supplier with plants in South Korea, China, Vietnam and the U.S. It employs approximately 700 workers at the Cusseta facility.
Alliance Total Solutions is a staffing agency with branches in Alabama, Georgia and Tennessee with over 4,000 employees. Joynus Staffing Corp. has offices in Georgia and employs over 600 workers.
To ask questions; obtain compliance assistance; file a complaint or report amputations, eye loss, workplace hospitalizations, fatalities or situations posing imminent danger to workers, the public should call OSHA's toll-free hotline at 800-321-OSHA (6742) or the agency's Mobile Area Office at 251-441-6131.
# # #
East Alabama woman, 20, killed from workplace incident at Ajin USA
By Elizabeth White, East Alabama Bureau Chief
(Source: WTVM)
CHAMBERS COUNTY, AL (WTVM) -
Chambers County investigators shared what they
believe led up to a 20-year-old woman being impaled and crushed at an
automotive supplier on June 18.
The victim has been identified as Regina Elsea, who was newly-engaged and planning her wedding. She was critically-injured Saturday, then died on Sunday.
The
Occupational Safety and Health Administration, or OSHA - has taken the
lead on the investigation into the death at Ajin USA in Cusseta, AL.
On
Saturday around 11:00 a.m, Chambers County investigators say the
machine on Elsea’s line quit working, witnesses on her team told
investigators they tried to inform maintenance to the problem so they
could come fix it.
"They stated they did try to notify
maintenance, but to no avail, they did not answer the phone, so no one
came to their line to fix the problem,” Chambers Co. Sheriff’s Office
Investigator Shannon Fraley said. “My understanding is the victim walked
around to the back side of the machine with her back turned to the
robot and pushed something on the machine and it engaged and pushed her
from the rear crushing her against another machine.”
Investigators
say Elsea was impaled by two welding tips, as she was crushed between
two machines. Fraley says it appears the machine was not “locked out,
tagged out” meaning it wasn't turned off. He says that's standard safety
protocol for most manufactures when a repair is being made.
“In
fact, when I arrived I had to ask them to do it. It still had not been
locked out tagged out, even after the incident had taken place,” said
Fraley. The question remains, was proper safety protocols and
procedures being followed at the time of the 20-year-old's death? Before
we could get to the door, security at Ajin USA turned us away and asked
us to leave the property. Ajin USA management did release a
statement, but it did not specifically address if safety protocols were
being followed at the time of Elsea’s accident. The statement, sent from David Wilkerson, General Manager of HR and Administration with Ajin USA, reads:
Ajin
USA is deeply saddened by the tragic loss of Regina Elsea. Ajin takes
any accident seriously, and a full investigation is being carried out
into the full details of the incident. In the meantime, Ajin USA is
retraining all employees on Ajin USA's safety precautions. Ajin USA will
fully cooperate with the appropriate authorities, including OSHA,
during the investigation process. The safety of our employees has been
and continues to be our greatest priority.
It could take months for OSHA to release their findings. According
to the OSHA website, they have investigated four complaints at Ajin
USA. One complaint in 2011 led to Ajiin being fined an initial penalty
of $14,500.
North Dakota Oil Spill Raises Questions About Safety
By blake nicholson and james macpherson, associated pressBISMARCK, N.D. — Dec 14, 2016, 11:25 AM ET The discovery of an oil pipeline spill earlier this month in western North Dakota has drawn heightened attention because of the battle over the Dakota Access oil pipeline being built about 150 miles to the southeast. While the spill was on a different pipeline, the Standing Rock Sioux and its supporters say a spill on the Dakota Access pipeline could threaten the tribe's drinking water, which is drawn from the Missouri River.
The developer of the Dakota Access project, Energy Transfer Partners, and the Army are battling in court over permission for the pipeline to cross under Lake Oahe, a Missouri River reservoir in southern North Dakota. It's the last large chunk of construction for the $3.8 billion project to move North Dakota oil 1,200 miles to a shipping point at Patoka, Illinois.
Here are some questions and answers about the spill on the Belle Fourche Pipeline:
———
HOW BIG WAS THE SPILL?
The pipeline rupture spilled about 176,000 gallons of oil, about 130,000 gallons of which flowed into Ash Coulee Creek. The spill went about 5 miles down the creek, which feeds into the Little Missouri River, a tributary of the Missouri River. A photo released by the North Dakota Department of health shows the creek with a brown muck on it. Another photo shows what appears to be the pipeline break with oil oozing out.
As of Wednesday, about 46,000 gallons had been recovered.
It appears no oil got into the Little Missouri, and no drinking water sources were threatened, according to Bill Suess, an environmental scientist with the North Dakota Health Department. The creek was free-flowing when the spill occurred but has since frozen over.
The spill was in a remote area of the southwest part of the state, far from any major population centers. It fouled an unknown amount of private and U.S. Forest Service land along the waterway.
Dozens of workers have been at the site the past week in subzero temperatures cleaning the spill, which regulators don't expect to be completed until spring.
———
HOW WAS THE SPILL DISCOVERED?
A landowner spotted the spill about 16 miles northwest of the town of Belfield on Dec. 5.
Electronic monitoring equipment failed to detect the rupture, but it's not clear why, according to Wendy Owen, a spokeswoman for Casper, Wyoming-based True Cos., which operates the pipeline.
The pipeline was shut down as soon as the leak was discovered. Owen said erosion of a hillside might have ruptured the pipe, but the cause is still being investigated.
———
IS THIS A BIG SPILL?
It's sizeable, but there have been much larger oil spills in North Dakota. For example, in September 2013, a Tesoro Corp. pipeline break spilled more than 840,000 gallons of oil into a wheat field near the northwestern town of Tioga. That spill is still being cleaned up.
True Cos. has a history of spills in North Dakota and Montana, including a January 2015 pipeline break into the Yellowstone River. That 32,000-gallon spill temporarily shut down water supplies in the downstream community of Glendive, Montana, after oil was detected in the city's water treatment system.
———
IS THIS PIPELINE LIKE THE DAKOTA ACCESS PIPELINE?
It's much smaller. The 6-inch steel Belle Fourche Pipeline, built in the 1980s, is mostly underground but was built above ground where it crosses Ash Coulee Creek.
It's one of a network of thousands of miles of similar "gathering" pipelines that crisscross western North Dakota's oil patch to pick up oil from wells and carry it to collection points, where it ultimately moves into larger pipelines or railroad tankers destined for refineries across the U.S.
The Dakota Access pipeline is a much larger 30-inch steel "transmission" pipeline that will carry nearly 20 million gallons of North Dakota oil daily through South Dakota and Iowa to a shipping point in Illinois, some 1,200 miles away.
It is largely complete except for a segment near the Standing Rock Sioux reservation, where it would be buried 90 to 115 feet below Lake Oahe. Dallas-based Energy Transfer Partners says the line will have modern leak detection equipment, and that workers monitoring the pipeline remotely in Texas could close valves within three minutes if a breach was detected.
The pipeline route skirts the northern edge of the Standing Rock Reservation, which straddles the North Dakota-South Dakota border.
The Standing Rock tribe argues that putting the pipeline under the lake imperils drinking water for more than 8,000 tribal members and millions downstream. ETP and other pipeline advocates maintain that transporting oil through pipelines is safer than shipping it by truck or train.
Investigation Underway into Cause of Rosemount Business Fire
December 14, 2016 09:31 AM
Firefighters are investigating what caused an early morning fire at a business in Rosemount on Wednesday.
The fire took place about 2 a.m. on the 1500 block of Clayton Avenue at Olson Carriers, Inc.
Crew members worked to extinguish the 4-alarm fire. Firefighters say at one point, there was a small explosion and the building collapsed.
Rosemount Fire Department Chief Rick Schroeder said there may have been 50-gallon drums of oil inside the building.
He added that the collapse and the cold conditions made fighting the fire difficult.
"It causes issues with fire lines, slippery conditions," he said. "All in all a tough battle, and then you add the cold. Makes it a lot more difficult."