MEC&F Expert Engineers

Saturday, July 25, 2015

OSHA enforcement memo and interim policy on the Process Safety Management retail exemption

Seyfarth Shaw LLP
July 23 2015 
 
The Occupational Safety and Health Administration issued yesterday an enforcement memo (Memo) and an interim policy (Policy) on the PSM retail exemption.

Tho Memo revised OSHA’s interpretation of the exemption of retail facilities from coverage of the Process Safety Management of Highly Hazardous Chemicals (PSM) standard (29 CFR 1910.119). The revision, according to OSHA, is in accordance with the President’s August 1, 2013, Executive Order 13650, Improving Chemical Facility Safety and Security (EO). We had previously blogged about the EO.

While OSHA in its PSM rule had not defined the term “retail facility,” the preamble to the final standard explained that chemicals in retail facilities (“e.g., gasoline stations”), are sold in “small volume packages, containers, and allotments, making a release unlikely.” (57 Fed. Reg. 6356, 6369 (February 24, 1992)). Following the adoption of the PSM standard OSHA issued a series of interpretation letters and a PSM compliance directive (CPL 02-02-045) that, according to the Memo “interpreted the exemption more broadly.” Under the interpretations an establishment was exempt from PSM coverage if it “derived more than 50 percent of its income from direct sales of highly hazardous chemicals to the end user” (the “50 percent test”).

In a turn-around now, though, OSHA claims that the 50 percent test has “no relationship to OSHA’s original intent for application of the exemption, nor is it consistent with either the commonly understood meaning of retail establishment or the definition recognized by the U.S. Department of Commerce in the NAICS Manual.” For instance, OSHA believes that the 50 percent test allows employers who sell or distribute large, bulk quantities of highly hazardous chemicals directly to end users to claim the exemption, even if the end users are themselves commercial establishments.

OSHA through this Memo has now withdrawn and rescinded all prior policy documents, letters of interpretation, and memoranda related to the retail exemption and the 50 percent test. According to the Memo OSHA will now interpret the retail facilities exemption as follows:

Only facilities, or the portions of facilities, engaged in retail trade as defined by the current and any future updates to sectors 44 and 45 of the NAICS Manual may be afforded the retail exemption at 29 CFR 1910.119(a)(2)(i).

In OSHA’s related Interim Enforcement Policy, it indicated that for the first six months following the issuance of the Memo (July 22, 2015), OSHA will “focus its resources on providing compliance assistance to affected employers, engage key industry stakeholders, and will inform its State On-Site Consultation Projects that during this period, requests from newly covered employers should be their highest priority for receiving an on-site visit.”

For employers, and especially retail establishments, what this means now is that an OSHA inspector may recommend issuance of a citation for violations of the PSM Standard after determining that the employer’s primary NAICS related to the sale of “highly hazardous chemicals” is something other than a retail trade, as defined in NAICS sectors 44 or 45, and PSM coverage is otherwise established.

Use this six month interim enforcement period to examine and bring all of your facilities into compliance with the “revised” standard.

New Prime violated the Surface Transportation Assistance Act by “blacklisting” a former driver who refused to drive his truck while taking pain medication.

Judge sides with OSHA in case of New Prime 'blacklisting driver'
By Clarissa Hawes, Land Line contributing writer


Administrative Law Judge Lystra A. Harris recently agreed with the U.S. Department of Labor’s Occupational Safety and Health Administration’s ruling that New Prime violated the Surface Transportation Assistance Act by “blacklisting” a former driver who refused to drive his truck while taking pain medication.

Harris lowered the amount awarded by OSHA from $100,000 to approximately $20,000. In her ruling, she agreed with OSHA that New Prime had put damaging and misleading information on the New Jersey driver’s DAC, now known as HireRight, report after he notified the company that he had sustained an on-the-job injury and was seeking medical advice in October 2008. He had also reported to his supervisor that he had been prescribed pain medication that made operating a motor vehicle unsafe.

“Complainant has successfully shown a preponderance of evidence that his refusal to drive his commercial motor vehicle while taking prescription pain medication was a protected activity under the STAA and was a contributing factor in a negative notation of abandonment placed in his DAC report by respondent,” Harris wrote in her order.

New Prime appealed OSHA’s decision in January 2014 to the Department of Labor’s Office of Administrative Law Judges for review.

Judge Harris also ordered that the former New Prime driver should receive $10,000 in compensatory damages and $9,600 in back pay, and that New Prime must pay the driver’s pre- and post-judgment interest on his back pay award.

The judge ruled against punitive damages and a front pay award for the driver, stating that the driver has had several jobs since 2009 and “did not provide sufficient information about the compensation he received for all of the jobs he testified in his hearing testimony.”

After undergoing disc surgery, the driver was released by his doctor to return to duty in July 2009. According to court documents, he opted not to return to work at New Prime and applied for jobs with other trucking companies. After applying for 11 trucking jobs, he only heard back from one company. In her ruling, Harris stated that’s when the driver learned that negative information had been put on his DAC report by his former company, including “quit under load/abandonment” and a “no” answer to the question of whether the driver was “eligible for rehire.”

“It is undisputed that negative information remained on complainant’s DAC report from November 2008 to September 2009,” Harris stated in her ruling.

Judge Harris also ordered that New Prime expunge any negative comments on the driver’s DAC report and that his report should show a satisfactory work and safety record.

In her ruling, she stated that New Prime must post “a copy of the decision and order in this case for 90 consecutive days in all places where employee notices are customarily posted and to provide a copy of any decision favorable to the complainant.”

Worker burned by acetylene gas at Norco plant in South Boise, Idaho


adutton@idahostatesman.com 

July 23, 2015

An employee was flown to Salt Lake City with second- and possible third-degree burns Tuesday, after an incident at a Norco Inc. plant in South Boise.

There was a “small fire” Tuesday afternoon at the Boise company’s fuel-gas plant on Gowen Road, according to Norco President Ned Pontious.

The male employee was taking two small, empty cylinders out to a dock, but they contained residual acetylene gas that Pontious thinks must have been leaking. The gas ignited, and “when the flame shot up, it melted the fusible link on the cylinder,” he said.

The employee turned away, and the flame burned the back of his arm and shoulder. The plant manager put out the fire “within 30 seconds, probably,” Pontious said.

Ada County emergency dispatchers received a call about the incident shortly after 1 p.m. Tuesday. The dispatch report said a welding tank caught fire, and one employee with head and arm burns was taken to Saint Alphonsus Regional Medical Center.

Pontious said Norco called the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration within an hour to report the incident, and an OSHA investigator came the next morning to interview staffers and take video.

Pontious said Norco is working on an internal investigation. The fire was “a very unusual accident” for Norco and at that plant, he said.

Boise does not have a burn specialty unit in any of its hospitals, so patients frequently are flown to Utah for burn care.

The employee’s care and his lost days at work will be paid for by worker’s compensation insurance, Pontious said.

Read more here: http://www.idahostatesman.com/2015/07/23/3907843_worker-burned-at-norco-in-south.html?rh=1#storylink=cpy

Mohammed Sadiq, 67, of Oakland County, Michigan, Owner of Detroit Home Health Care Companies Sentenced to 80 Months in Prison for Role in $12.6 Million Fraud Scheme

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Friday, July 24, 2015

Owner of Detroit Home Health Care Companies Sentenced to 80 Months in Prison for Role in $12.6 Million Fraud Scheme

A Michigan resident was sentenced to 80 months in prison late yesterday for his leading role in a $12.6 million Medicare fraud and tax fraud scheme.  Eleven other individuals have been convicted in this case.

Assistant Attorney General Leslie R. Caldwell of the Justice Department’s Criminal Division, U.S. Attorney Barbara L. McQuade of the Eastern District of Michigan, Special Agent in Charge Paul M. Abbate of the FBI’s Detroit Field Office, Special Agent in Charge Lamont Pugh III of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services-Office of Inspector General (HHS-OIG) Chicago Regional Office and Special Agent in Charge Jarod Koopman of the Internal Revenue Service-Criminal Investigation (IRS-CI) Detroit Field Office made the announcement.

Mohammed Sadiq, 67, of Oakland County, Michigan, pleaded guilty on March 13, 2015, to one count of health care fraud and one count of filing a false tax return.  In addition to imposing the prison term, U.S. District Judge Denise Page Hood of the Eastern District of Michigan ordered Sadiq to pay $14.1 million in restitution and entered a forfeiture judgment for the same amount, which represents the proceeds traceable to his criminal conduct.

Sadiq owned and directed operations at two home health care companies in Detroit.  In connection with his guilty plea, Sadiq admitted that, working with co-conspirators, he billed Medicare for home health services that were not provided.  Sadiq also admitted to paying kickbacks to patient recruiters in order to obtain the information of Medicare beneficiaries, which he then used to bill Medicare for services that were not medically necessary or were not provided at all.  Sadiq further admitted that he created fake patient files to fool a Medicare auditor by making it appear as if home health services were provided and medically necessary.  Medicare paid $12.6 million for these services.

In connection with his guilty plea, Sadiq also admitted that he received proceeds of the fraud through bank accounts that he controlled, that he withdrew substantial sums for his personal use and that he failed to report these amounts on his individual federal income tax return in 2008.  In total, Sadiq admitted that he owes approximately $1.5 million in taxes, interest and penalties for tax years 2008 through 2010.

This case was investigated by the FBI, HHS-OIG and IRS-CI, and was brought as part of the Medicare Fraud Strike Force, supervised by the Criminal Division’s Fraud Section and the U.S. Attorney’s Office of the Eastern District of Michigan.  The case is being prosecuted by Trial Attorneys William Kanellis, Christopher Cestaro, Brooke Harper and Elizabeth Young of the Criminal Division’s Fraud Section, as well as Assistant U.S. Attorney Patrick Hurford of the Eastern District of Michigan.

Since its inception in March 2007, the Medicare Fraud Strike Force, now operating in nine cities across the country, has charged nearly 2,300 defendants who have collectively billed the Medicare program for more than $7 billion.  In addition, HHS’ Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, working in conjunction with HHS-OIG, is taking steps to increase accountability and decrease the presence of fraudulent providers.

Barrier Reef oil spill: oil washes up on three beaches


Oil has washed up on three beaches following an oil spill off the Great Barrier Reef. Oil has washed up on three beaches following an oil spill off the Great Barrier Reef. Photo: Phil Walter

Tony Moore

brisbanetimes.com.au senior reporter

 
Palm-sized clumps of oil have been washed up Hinchinbrook Island, Great Palm Island and a third beach near Ingham after an oil spill near Townsville last week.

Maritime Safety Queensland and Townsville Water Police on Friday afternoon confirmed clumps of "weathered oil" had been found in three locations.

Oil has washed up on Forrest Beach near Ingham, on beaches on Palm Island and on Mulligan Beach on Hinchinbrook Island.

Hinchinbrook Island is a national park with no permanent residents.

North Queensland Conservation Council co-ordinator Wendy Tubman said she was concerned that oil had now washed ashore on three pristine beaches.

A 800-metre diameter oil spill was first reported by a Townsville fisherman last Thursday and broke up to an oily film spreading over 30 kilometres south of Townsville.

Ms Tubman said she was concerned issues had been downplayed by authorities and the clean-up was slow.

"It seems a bit slow, it's now a week later," she said.
"It seems like it was downplayed for a long time."
"Now they are saying they have actually found bits of it on land that you can see.

"But what about all the rest of it, that you can't see .
"How far has that dispersed and what has been the impact? 
Hinchinbrook Resort manager Alan Hamilton said he had not been to the island on Friday and said he knew nothing about oil film being washed up on the island.

"Nothing, not a thing," he said.
Mr Hamilton said no-one had contacted him about the clean-up on Mulligan Beach beginning on Saturday.

"Local and state government agencies are co-ordinating the shoreline clean-up at Forrest Beach with further action planned for Great Palm Island and Mulligan Beach on Hinchinbrook Island," the MSQ statement reads.

"The majority of oil patties are described as palm-sized and limited to a narrow tide-line over one or two kilometre stretches."

Last Friday Fairfax Media broke the story that oil had spilled from a boat near Cape Upstart south of Townsville.

The oil formed a film that stretched for 30 kilometres in metre-square clumps that was five kilometres wide in places, MSQ chairman Patrick Quirk reported last Saturday.

Townsville Water Police confirmed late yesterday a report of weathered oil clumps, or patties, drifting west of the Palm Island group.

"This is understood to relate to a report of oil in the water off Cape Upstart late last week with patches of oil sheen sighted during aerial surveillance on Saturday," a Maritime Safety Queensland spokesman said.
The clumps of oil are restricted to "one or two kilometre long stretches" at each beach.

Clean-up plans are being put in place now.
"Maritime Safety Queensland has trained shore-line clean-up personnel in Townsville who will assist local councils on shoreline operations.
"It's expected first clean-up crews will start Saturday morning.

Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority and National Parks and Wildlife Services officers are also involved in the clean-up.

Oil samples have now been taken from 10 ships that were in the area near Cape Upstart last Thursday and Friday, an MSQ spokesman said.
Samples will be used to track down the vessel which released the oil.

Anyone finding unfamiliar material on the shore can report it to either GBRMPA on 0427 969 384 or to the Department of Environment and Heritage Protection on 1300 130 372.

Source: http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au

//--------------///


Barrier Reef oil spill: 14 suspect ships to be tested in leak hunt



Tony Moore

brisbanetimes.com.au senior reporter

Authorities are investigating 14 possible sources of an oil spill near the Great Barrier Reef. Authorities are investigating 14 possible sources of an oil spill near the Great Barrier Reef. Photo: Jessica Shapiro

 
Fourteen ships have been identified as possible sources of a film of oil stretching, in broken sections, 30 kilometres long and five kilometres wide south of Townsville, Patrick Quirk, general manager of Maritime Services Queensland said on Saturday.

An oil slick was confirmed 18 nautical miles (33 kilometres) NNE of Cape Upstart on Friday evening, but was broken up into metre-sized blotches of oily film by the weather.
"We know the ships that went past the area," Mr Quirk said.
"There are 14 ships that we consider are possible sources of oil and we plan to take oil samples from all of those ships," he said.

"We already have samples from five ships in Australian ports and when the others port in Australia or overseas we will get samples."
Townsville water Police took samples from the oily film confirmed on Friday night, after an 800-metre diameter slick it was reported by a fisherman to Townsville's Coast Guard on Friday morning.

"So we will try a chemical match," Mr Quirk said.
A Maritime Safety Queensland inspector will fly to Weipa tomorrow to test oil from one ship, he said.
"So we are pulling out all stops to find the culprit."
In 2010 the Chinese ship, Shen Neng 1, which leaked a 3km ribbon of oil from a ruptured fuel tank near Great Keppel Island, was fined $1 million by the Queensland Government.

Mr Quirk said the 2015 oil slick south of Townsville had spread with the currents and broken down into an oily film.
"In an area about 30 kilometres wide and around five kilometres wide, within that rectangle there are areas of sheen and small patties of oil," he said.
"The whole area is not covered by oil or sheen. It is very patchy."
The oily film could not be detected on Saturday morning by planes using ultra violet light sensors – which detects water temperature variations caused by oil – because it was below the threshold specifications for the equipment finding oil, Mr Quirk explained.

"But we are about to do another visual inspection of the area, because want to make sure that we are managing the situation correctly," Mr Quirk said.
He said the oil spill was "not a huge slick of oil from a massive spill from a tanker."
"We are talking about areas of sheen – and within that - there are thicker patties of oil," he said.

Mr Quirk said the oil was weathering in south-easterly winds in slight to moderate seas and was most likely to break-down before reaching beaches.
He said while the oil was not visible to plane equipment, it was still in the water.
"It is quite possible that in a week's time – maybe in three days time – on some of the beaches around Townsville – there will be small globules of a spongy material found on the beach, because it doesn't all deteriorate."
Mr Quirk said it would not be like the 2009 spill from the storm-wracked MV Pacific Adventurer spilled 100,000 litres of oil along 60 kilometres of Moreton Bay coastline.

"It would be little tiny oily patches on the beaches. That is most likely what will happen."
Maritime Safety Queensland is concerned at the possible impacts on reefs to coastal side of the oil slick.  

"There are some reefs four to five nautical miles from where we saw the slicks of oil yesterday and we are going there with our aircraft straightaway," he said.
A helicopter which was to inspect the site has been diverted to a road accident.
Mr Quirk said he was confident steps were in place to prevent oil damaging the environment.

 "We believe we are doing everything we can – in a practical sense – to monitor the environment – to determine the risk and we are ready to respond, if required."

Source: http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au