MEC&F Expert Engineers

Tuesday, March 17, 2015

CRASH INVOLVING TWO TRACTOR-TRAILERS IN VICTORIA TEXAS INJURES ONE DRIVER AND SPILLS THE CARGO ACROSS THE HIGHWAY US 59





MARCH 17, 2015

VICTORIA, TEXAS

A 46-year-old truck driver was taken to a Victoria hospital after being injured Tuesday morning in a collision on U.S. Highway 59. 

The driver, whose name and hometown were not immediately available, suffered non-life threatening injuries, said Victoria police Sgt. Adam Nieto. 

The crash involving two tractor-trailers occurred about 7:10 a.m. in the 7100 block of U.S. Highway 59. 

One tractor-trailer was entering the highway from a private driveway and crossed the path of another. 

One truck was hauling frozen boxes of chicken and the other was hauling pipes. The impact caused the cargo to spill across the highway. 

The cab of one of the tractor-trailers was smashed and the front of the trailer was torn off. 

Traffic was backed up in both directions on the highway. 

The Texas Department of Transportation also responded to the crash to help clear the roads.
Source:www.VictoriaAdvocate.com

NATURAL GAS EXPLOSION COVERED UNDER CONTRACTOR’S POLLUTION INSURANCE POLICY, WISCONSIN SUPREME COURT SAYS.




MARCH 17, 2015

An insurer that covered a contractor's liability for “pollution” damages must cover a share of defense costs and settlement amounts from a natural gas explosion that caused property damage and bodily injury, the Wisconsin Supreme Court has ruled.

In 2008, Dorner Inc. was performing road construction in Oconomowoc, which included underground excavation. Workers discovered a natural gas line and mistakenly thought it was inactive. When they tried to move the pipe, it ruptured and leaked gas, causing an explosion that leveled a church, damaged nearby residences, and injured workers.

Four lawsuits followed. Dorner had two liability insurance policies. One was a general commercial liability policy with Acuity Insurance Company (Acuity).
Another was a “contractors’ pollution liability policy” with Chartis Specialty Insurance Company (Chartis), which covered damages caused by pollutants specifically.

Acuity defended the lawsuits and indemnified Dorner upon settlement. But Acuity sued Chartis to pay half of defense fees and half the settlement. Chartis argued that the damages weren’t covered because an explosion caused the damages, not pollution.

The Waukesha County Circuit Court said the damages were covered, and ordered Chartis to pay 50 percent of defense and indemnity costs associated with the lawsuits.

But a state appeals court reversed, concluding that Chartis’s policy did not cover the losses. In Acuity Ins. Co. v. Chartis Specialty Ins. Co., 2015 WI 28 (March 17, 2015), a unanimous supreme court reversed the appeals court, concluding that the natural gas leak was a “pollution condition” that caused the bodily injury and property damage.

“We therefore conclude that Chartis’s CPL policy covers the insured’s liability arising from the natural gas-fueled explosion and fire,” wrote Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson. “Chartis must pay its share of the defense fees and indemnity payments as ordered by the circuit court.” Acuity had paid a $1.5 million settlement on behalf of Dorner.

In the Chartis policy, a “pollution condition” was defined as the “release of any solid, liquid, gaseous, or thermal irritant or contaminant” on land or into the atmosphere in concentrations not naturally present in the environment.
First, the supreme court rejected Chartis’s claim that natural gas released into the air is not a “irritant” or “contaminant” and thus not a covered “pollution condition.”

“Natural gas renders the surrounding ground and air space impure or unclean because natural gas is extremely flammable and explosive,” wrote Chief Justice Abrahamson, noting that in this case, its release resulted in great harm. “Thus, we conclude that natural gas is a contaminant under the circumstances of the present case.”

The supreme court noted that a company like Dorner, which does excavation construction work, would expect the pollution policy to cover natural gas leaks.
Second, the supreme court ruled that the Dorner workers caused a contamination of natural gas into the air, which caused damages by triggering the explosion.

“This sequence of events is sufficient to establish that the escape of natural gas (a pollution condition) caused the alleged bodily injury and property damage,” wrote the chief justice, rejecting Chartis’s claim that no coverage existed unless the leaked natural gas, in its gaseous state, caused the damage, not a resulting explosion of fire.

Finally, the court rejected Chartis’s claim that since Acuity’s policy applies to cover the loss, Chartis’s policy does not since Chartis’s policy merely fills a “pollution” gap in coverage. The court noted that both policies can apply simultaneously:

“Depending on the language of the policies and the facts of the case, it is entirely possible for both a commercial general liability policy with a pollution exclusion clause and a contractors’ pollution liability policy to cover the insured’s liability.”

The court noted that it was only deciding Chartis’s coverage obligation, not whether Acuity’s policy actually covers liability for a natural gas explosion.

SCRAP METAL COMPANY NOT COVERED FOR PCB DAMAGE, WISCONSIN APPEALS COURT RULES




MARCH 9, 2015

A scrap metal company that supplied wastewater containing polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) to a water treatment company isn’t covered by an insurance policy containing a pollution exclusion clause, a state appeals court has ruled.
United Milwaukee Scrap, which processes and sells scrap metals, contracted with Advanced Waste Services, to remove wastewater from the United Milwaukee Scrap facility. In turn, Advanced Waste treats wastewater to resell byproducts like oil.

But the wastewater that United Milwaukee Scrap provided contained PCBs. Advanced Waste alleged the PCBs caused significant damage to its recycling processes. Advanced Waste sued for negligence and breach of contract, among other claims.

United Milwaukee Scrap notified its insurer, Illinois National Insurance, but the insurer refused to defend the lawsuit, claiming damage caused from PCBs was not covered. The circuit court in Milwaukee County granted summary judgment to Illinois National.

In Advanced Waste Services Inc. v. United Milwaukee Scrap LLC, 2014AP1169 (March 3, 2015), a three-judge panel for the District I Appeals Court agreed that Illinois National’s policy contained an exclusion that barred coverage for pollutant damages.

United Milwaukee Scrap admitted that PCBs are “pollutants,” but said coverage still applied because United Milwaukee Scrap did not “disperse” the PCBs, Advanced Wastewater did. Milwaukee Scrap further alleged that Advanced Wastewater had a duty to check for PCBs.

“Under the plain language of the policy there is no requirement that the insured disperse the pollutant for the exclusion to apply,” wrote Judge Patricia Curley. “As we see from the policy language above, no actor is specified, leaving the possibility that a pollutant could be dispersed in any number of ways – including without the direct action of any party at all.”

The panel said its conclusion was supported by a recent case involving a home that was polluted with bat guano. In that case, the bats dispersed the pollutant, not the homeowners, and the state supreme court ruled that a pollution exclusion clause barred coverage.

“The Hirschhorns’ policy, like United Milwaukee Scrap’s policy, did not specify whether coverage required a particular party to disperse a pollutant,” Judge Curley wrote. “Instead, that policy, like the one before us, applied to any loss involving the dispersal of pollutants.”

The panel was not persuaded by a federal case from New Jersey involving Nestle Foods, which contracted with a company to pick up waste products, which were delivered to a landfill. Nestle’s insurer said a pollution exclusion barred coverage clean-up liability, but a court disagreed.

“While United Milwaukee Scrap contends that Nestle Foods should control, we disagree because it interprets New Jersey law, which reads an additional requirement into the standard pollution exclusion that Wisconsin does not,” Judge Curley explained.

BEDRIDDEN ELDERLY MAN DIES IN ANTIOCH, ILLINOIS MASSIVE FIRE. HE WAS ON OXYGEN, WHICH MAY HAVE CONTRIBUTED TO THE MASSIVE FIRE













MARCH 16, 2015

ANTIOCH, ILLINOIS

The first-arriving firefighters at Sunday's house fire in Antioch could hear a man calling for help, but with flames raging throughout the home, crews didn't make it to Lowell Simonson's bedroom in time to save his life. Antioch Fire Chief John Nixon said the 74-year-old was found in cardiac arrest. Firefighters carried Simonson out of the house on a ladder and paramedics attempted to revive him outside and on the way to Centegra Northern Illinois Medical Center in McHenry, where he was pronounced dead.

"His room was very hot; the firefighters' gear was damaged from the heat," said Nixon, adding that firefighters' helmets and face shields bubbled and strips on their equipment melted in the man's bedroom.

The McHenry County Coroner, which is handling the death investigation, has not yet released the cause of death. Simonson's wife, Patricia, 74, who was bedridden and on oxygen, is still in serious condition at an area hospital, Nixon said.

The first of several 911 calls was made at 10:11 a.m., reporting a house fire in the 38500 block of Drexel Boulevard. Fire officials said in a statement Sunday that the preliminary investigation showed the fire appeared to have started in an upstairs room of the three-floor home. Six of the seven residents were able to escape the fire before the arrival of firefighters.

Lowell Simonson was on the top floor while his wife and her sister, who has disabilities, were on the second floor. Patricia Simonson's daughter and three grandchildren lived on the basement level.

"From the initial interview, the daughter said she heard the gentleman yell there was a fire and she tried to do what she could do to get everyone out of the home," Nixon said.

The first tankers arrived on the scene in 12 minutes, finding the home's multiple levels engulfed in flames.

"The shift commander heard the victim and then he was silent," Nixon said.
"We don't know how long he lived after we got there. Firefighters thought he was still alive and climbed into his room from a ladder and found him on the floor of his room."

While fire officials continue to investigate the cause, Nixon said there are no indications that the house had smoke alarms, a state law in Illinois.

Nixon, however, said there is no reason to believe the death, serious injuries and total loss of the home could have been prevented if the Fire Department still had it's station just a few minutes away on Grass Lake Road.

The station was closed this year among sweeping budget cuts village officials said were the result of voters rejecting a November referendum that would have created a designated funding source for ambulance services.

"We started off at a disadvantage and it didn't get better after that," Nixon said, noting that there are no fire hydrants in the area.

The home also was packed with items that accelerate fires, Nixon said, listing oxygen tanks, wall paneling, boxes and bags. Patricia Simonson relied on the oxygen.

"It was a fast moving fire, that home was consumed rapidly," he said.
And while the first fire trucks arrived from the downtown fire station in 12 minutes, a second truck from the Deep Lake Road firehouse took 14 minutes after a freight train delayed its arrival.

"We did the best we could with the resources we had," Nixon said.
Water was pumped from the nearby Lotus Elementary School and trucked to the site where a large pool was set up to act as a reservoir to fight the fire. Twelve departments sent tanker trucks to keep the reservoir full of water.

Nixon said 87,000 gallons of water was poured on the fire.

A point of origin and cause may never be known, Nixon said, "because the house collapsed from the top down, pancaking the other floors. The destruction was so major," he said.

Nothing appears salvageable, save for a few bikes in the front yard.
On Sunday, Antioch Township brought in a backhoe to tear down part of the structure, but the heavy equipment was bogged down due to a septic field in the yard.

Neighbor Charlie Wilberg, 62, who has lived directly across the street for 12 years said the Simonson family moved in about six years ago.

"It was like a big mushroom cloud when I walked out," he said of the fire. "The flames were as high as the tree tops. The fire was so intense I don't think it would of made any difference if firefighters were here 10 minutes earlier."

Wilberg said the family was outside in T-shirts Sunday while crews worked the fire. His wife offered them money and clothes, but they declined. The Simonsons told authorities they had a place to stay and the American Red Cross has been assisting as well.

"They didn't know what they were going to do," Wilberg said.
Source: http://www.chicagotribune.com